Zandder

Vote: Zandder Can we call it a day guys? I thought it was well established that the Baritones set was long gone.

In exchange for preventing him from being lynched, isn't that obvious? His win condition doesn't explain my actions because I don't know what his win condition is or was.

duh. No Traveler, no scrolls. I don't suppose anyone received a scroll today, did they? I can say the same about you, buckaroo. Yesterday we were six with one scum and one neutral. If we had mislynched (or lynched Luxxon), we'd have been down to five, and we could reasonably expect to lose one more to bring us to four. With four people, as you say you feared, the no-lynch was in play. With five, that would have been less likely. As it happened we lost Eeyara and Nancy, plus Luxxon. So that doesn't matter anymore. Am I supposed to apologize for not being cleared into the Cool Kids' Mermaid Club where I could hear all the gossip about Luxxon's win condition? He promised help and he snaked us. As I said, Araveea, it's your decision. It's your funeral if you make the wrong choice (mine, too).

With the scrolls. I don't know what was on the scrolls aside from the one that saved me and the one Tameekys said she got yesterday and didn't pass on (of course she didn't pass it on - she wouldn't have wanted Luxxon to steal her kill). Numerically, having him around would prevent Tameekys from outnumbering us, and the powers we could get from giving him the scrolls would help us out. Saving me prevented a mislynch which would have been bad for us. But he tricked us, got his win, and disappeared into the sunset. So it's a moot point now.

I thought he would be able to help us, but obviously he can't now he's Traveled onward.

It's Tameekys. Look, Araveea, you're like Tamamono in Day Five of Belville Mafia. You are clearly town because you gave us Coralaaze. So Tameekys is going to vote for me. Are you going to vote for me and let Tameekys win, or are you going to see through her weed granny act and vote for her so that we win? It all hangs on you.

He told me he could help us win. That's kinda sorta true because at least we didn't mislynch yesterday... but on the other hand he's just buzzed off and really it's no different now than it would have been had we actually lynched him. Luxxon would have lost if we'd lynched him so he basically bamboozled me into keeping him alive so he could win. Not much help to us in the end, then.

Pay for what? I said for days it was Tameekys and everyone was like "no it's not" but here we are.

No Eeyara? Nevertheless Unvote: Eeyara Vote: Zandder

@Araveea do to you mean to say you think I'm town? Thanks for the vote of confidence amongst all these other meanies.

How kind of you

Well, it's true. I've already laid out my case against Eeyara, and I hope you realize that she, somehow, is in the town bloc despite not (apparently) being cleared, and she is the one capable of strongarm murdering Marwyyn in the night. Vote: Eeyara

Cadd *told me* that if I didn't believe him I should "go check with the investigator" which is one hell of a fishy thing to say. And then he told me to check with Araveea (presumably because she's the one who delivered us Coralaaze)

Araveea did no such thing. I did no such thing. And please spell my name correctly if you're going to come for me.

Cadd kind of spilled the beans yesterday if you paid attention to who had posted when: As for yesterday: I understand your reasoning yesterday, Nancy, but it makes me sad nonetheless . I'm sorry you feel like I didn't respect your judgment about Cadd; I just thought you were wrong. But you weren't . Cadd is confirmed Oceanide so I've gone back to look at his notes from yesterday, in particular the one about Eeyara (emphasis mine): Eeyara said after Araveea brought us Coralaaze that she knew who the investigator was. Was Eeyara cleared last night? Or is she pulling the wool over our eyes? This situation reminds me very much of the legend I once heard of a ship called Enterprise, floating amongst the stars. In that legend, the crew of the ship had the final scum in their sights from the first day, but it wasn't until the final day that the crew were released from the Klingon threat by voting for Dr. McCoy. Eeyara was a leading lynch candidate on Days One and Two, and Coralaaze and Nerrio split their votes on Day Two. In addition, Eeyara voted with Nerrio (and me ) on Day Two for Marwyyn, who is now confirmed town. She's uncleared, apparently in the town bloc, and has been in our sights since Day One. mmmm weed Granny

It's a real shame we were wrong about Cadd... it seems he did have his wits about him in the end.

Hinck memed

You'll be able to throw together a nice scene on short notice, it'll be OK. At the time I changed my vote, Tameekys was not in a position to be pew-pewed, while Marwyyn had four votes and Nerrio six. So I voted for Nerrio to put a lynch of Marwyyn out of reach, because I trusted her more than I trusted Nerrio. As I said at the time. Huh?

Yeah, you do seem to be making shit up and can't even keep your actual story straight about which scrolls were delivered on which days. Unvote: Tameekys Vote: Cadd I want to point out, as Marwyyn pointed out, that this is just about the only thing you have to say about anyone whom you can't pump for information behind the swingset. I for one am not about to go blabbing to you the way you seem to be doing in the thread today.

I apologize; in this first full week of the new year my coral-protection duties have taken me far and wide. Why on earth would you assume that? It seems like it's an excuse to vote for me more than it's a logical or reasonable guess. Now you've got Cadd's support on this vote, now that Cadd's satisfied you're town? Lucky for you it seems that Nancy vouches for you.

I'm going with my top suspect from yesterday. Vote: Tameekys

Well the only thing I can 100% rely on is that Nancy is the inventor, since nobody has counterclaimed against her. I don't know who has been investigated, and because of lack of clarity over whether the traitor was recruited or not, I don't even know if the people who do know should trust those results. I'm glad you're so confident.

It matters. Are people being investigated as "Not Gorgon" or "Town" or "Oceanide"? That's how we can tell whether the Gorgons recruited or just failed to kill on Night Two. Whom can we trust then, your cryptic majesty?