Louisa Hammond

IMO, Geoffrey was going at Tim hard in either a desperate attempt to not be lynched, or was trying to make his scum buddy look a little bit more townier in the morning. You and Pat are more confirmed town right now then if you were cleared by the investigator.

Right now the best options we have for a lynch are Timothy or the claimed masons. Patrick is definitely town since he jailed and voted for Bart. He also jailed himself and was visited by Geoffrey. Nigel is definitely town since he set the trap for Geoffrey. Joseph had this to say yesterday after the info came out that Nigel had seen Geoffrey visiting Patrick.

Agreed 100%. It was merely a joke.

Well Jack said we had an investigator, and most everyone had already claimed a role, so it just would have been a choice between Tom or Henry. Who do you think we should lynch today?

Blocked Tim again last night. Was going to block Tom but Patrick discouraged that so I blocked Tim instead. So why did Tom not get a result? Can see why scum killed Gordon. Inventor sounds OP. I'm assuming you could only use your watcher ability or the tool Gordon gave you, but not both in the same night. I'll just say right now the only scum I could see being left would be our two masons. That or Henry is a godfather who has been busing his mates (unlikely but lol if you did ), or Tim is scum who hasn't been cleared but has been blocked by me for the past three nights cause I'm annoying.

The choice of you over Timothy makes way more sense. On night two I blocked Tim, and Pat jailed Bart. There was no night kill. We lynched Bart, he flipped scum. Last night I blocked Tim again and Pat jailed himself. So either Tim is scum and I stopped him from performing a night kill, or you were unsuccessful in trying to kill Bart who jailed himself, all while Nigel was watching. Not to mention something entirely different could be at play.

Patrick Locked himself up last night, Nigel stood watch, Geoffrey shows up, no night kill. What makes more sense for a lynch at the moment? Why am I scummy? Unless you think a scum would bus their own teammate, there's nothing to defend this. Patrick decided on Barty vs Timothy for yesterdays lynch in PM, and I followed his lead.

He claimed tracker. If I remember correctly he wouldn't say who he tracked or what his results were.

We haven't had any counter claims meaning scum were very lucky in the roles they falsely claimed, or much more likely they do indeed have those roles except they are obviously not town aligned. Agreed. Vote: Geoffrey Holton

I agree, but no one is ever 100% confirmed. Needless to say though that he's the only one here I fully trust.

So I believe this is what we have so far. Jack Alden, claimed Town Timothy Dixon, unknown Myself, claimed Town Blocker Patrick Triggs, claimed Town Jailkeeper Joseph Finch, claimed Town Mason Thomas Chapman, unknown Malcolm Langley, claimed Town Mason Geoffrey Holton, claimed Town Tracker Gordon Smith, claimed Town Inventor Henry Ogden, claimed Town Nigel Clayton, claimed Town Watcher

Voting will be open soon. A lynch is our best solution for making sense of all this, and I am very much looking forward to being able to clear my head.

Wow. So your saying we have an investigator and a inventor correct? With all these claimed town PRs, what the heck kind of PRs do the scum have???

Things are getting am wee bit confusing in here. Who would you have us lynch @Geoffrey Holton?

Why didn't I think of that? Makes more sense than us catching two scum. It's not off the table, just unlikely IMO.

I blocked Timothy again last night. Sooooo... And Patrick jailed himself... We've had no doctor claim as of yet so that's not something entirely worth considering as explanation for why there was no kill. @Nigel Clayton see anybody last night?

Yup. Hammond & Triggs Persian Maple rum. Ever since now. Drink responsibly. In all seriousness though IMO just keep it to yourself.

Oh wow I totally forgot that you could have been protected last night from a kill. I must admit however Barty, you've changed your opinion awfully quickly, as well as accepted your potential fate quite easily.

Couldn't decide whether to vote my block or Patrick's so I'ma follow Patrick. Vote: Bartholomew Brewster

Hold up! If I'm a roleblocker and Patrick is a jailkeeper, then there's a chance there's no doctor which means there's a very good chance at least one of are targets last night is scum. So which one then? Timothy Dixon (mine) or Bartholomew Brewster (Patrick's)?

That's not a counter claim. Similar role yes, but not a counter claim. However personally I think your telling the truth. So wait, who are you proposing we lynch? Me or Barty?

For real?! This gonna be happening!!! I bet my life on it!

BTW you guys are aware that you shouldn't lynch me until Patrick tells us who counter claimed right? Unless you want to see this play out. Also, what would your thoughts be tomorrow when I flip town after you've lynched me? Would you be 100% sure that the counter claimer is scum?

I know I'm town, So for scum to counterclaim makes know sense. @Patrick Triggs Who's the counterclaimer??? Seriously, from the perspective of me being town, what possible scenarios would make sense in this situation. Also the flip flopping, I already explained myself on that yesterday. At the beginning of yesterday, I wanted to lynch Remy, but was discouraged by the quick construction of agreed consensus that Remy was scum, which didn't feel town led. However after it died down a little bit (probably cause I pointed it out), I felt my suspicion was unwarranted since it hadn't snowballed to level I'd expected, so I went back to believing the wagon was town led. Like I said, I know I'm town, and I doubt scum would counterclaim, so what else makes sense? Exactly! So if I'm town, what the heck is going on? Good question. ???

Best case scenario for the scum assuming the counterclaimer is scum, Patrick never says who counterclaimed, I get lynched, Patrick gets offed. Honestly IMO scum counterclaiming makes no sense for the long run which is why I would believe in the possibility of there being two town blockers. Unless I'm scum and didn't notice. *Checks role PM*. Nope, still town.