Louisa Hammond

Lynching me will be the end for town unless Patrick successfully stops tonight's kill. Pat we need to lynch Jack, and I need you to trust me and help me block and jail Tim and Henry.

lol I could say the word "pickle" and you'd find a way to use it to make me look like scum. All that matter's is that Pat and I stay alive.

Uh...

??? All I said was that all of Tom's three town investigation reads can't be godfathers. Was it suggested some where that scum can only perform one action per night? We caught two scum through jailing and traps. Perhaps you didn't get the chance to kill him. Also, after we lynched Remy and Geoffrey, we decided that the remaining scum had to be either the supposed masons or you and Tom. Why risk being discovered, when you could have us do all the work for you? Cause it couldn't have been Joseph. Also I'd like to add that town needs me and Pat tonight in order keep scum from killing anybody. Basically I say we lynch Jack, and tonight Pat and I block and jail Henry and Tim.

Vote: Jack Alden

Oh that's right. oof

That's a theory to work on. Wow now I'm thinking we should lynch Tim. If Tim is a JOAT, then he could be saving something powerful like a strongman for the end of the game.

LoL. @Jack Alden if I'm scum then who's my scum buddy? You? BTW if we mislynch and there's a night kill, then we lose if there are still two scum left. Knowing Tom was town so very likely the investigator, he cleared Jack, Henry, and Joseph. All three of those can't be godfathers though. The people who aren't on my list of potential suspects are Patrick and Joseph. Patrick because obviously he's town, and Joseph who I successfully blocked last night so he couldn't of performed a night kill or get Jack out of jail. That leaves Jack who has a role which only Patrick knows. Henry who has a role which a godfather could potentially pull off. And Tim who you probably know by now has a protective role. Maybe Tim who I've been blocking all game is the JOAT. He could have poisoned Nigel night five, or something random just in case Nigel was watching. Hmm.

Can't be Joseph since I blocked him. I'm so confused.

I could see Jack being a JOAT, but who killed Nigel?

This is bad this is real bad I blocked Joseph and I believe Patrick jailed Jack. I believe Tim protected Patrick. Henry?!

Cause she wanted to see a man lay bricks.

Why did the chicken cross the road?

If Jack is scum then Tom is scum as well. That or you, Malcolm and Jack are scum in which case your the godfather and Jack is a JOAT. That or Tom is scum and lied about having no result on Malcolm and further more isn't even a investigator. Unlikely. Yes it would suck but it wouldn't be the death of us.

This made me think that maybe Jack could indeed be a fifth scum, but he was investigated as town along with Joseph, and both of them can't be godfathers. Unless Jack got crazy lucky and made himself a godfather the night Tom investigated him. If Malcolm and Joseph were indeed scum, and there was a fifth scum, between Jack and Tom who's more likely to be the fifth scum? Maybe we should lynch Jack instead.

Come to think of it, could a JOAT have a janitor ability?

Vote: Thomas Chapman

Yup.

Which is why it makes more sense for both of you to be scum.

With that logic, who would be Jack's remaining fourth scum buddy? Also just wanted to point out that Jack as a janitor could be X shot, but we would be blocking/jailing him so no need to worry. Of course unless it's a day action... Maybe we should lynch Jack instead?

That could mean Jack. However regarding the block, I think Tom might have withheld his supposed result on Malcolm. If he had said Malcolm was town, we would have been looking at Tom and Jack. And if you put into account the possibility of Jack being a janitor, there's even more reason to believe scum buddies Tom and Jack would to this.

So we should stop talking about you and wait for you to be killed? Okay. Scum please kill Jack. Confirmed or just your claim? You make it sound as if Tim's role could mean the life or death of scum. While his role is helpful, it's not town's lifeline.

@Jack Alden & @Thomas Chapman what's your view on each other in light of the events from today so far? IMO, you seemed rather convinced yesterday the other was scum.

If Joseph isn't scum, then Tom is looking the scummiest right now since there was no night kill. I'm also of the belief there's only four scum, and Joseph was blocked so It couldn't of been him who cleaned Malcolm's quarters unless it's some sort of day action? Doubt it. That leaves Jack as the culprit since everyone else is cleared in my book.

What if Malcolm wasn't scum and Tom and Jack are the scum who cleaned up Malcolm's quarters so we wouldn't know for a fact that Malcolm was town. If Malcolm is town and we knew, then we would lynch Tom, and then Jack. Either way I say we lynch Tom, and block and jail Joseph and Jack.