JackJonespaw
-
Posts
2,872 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Gallery
Everything posted by JackJonespaw
-
So it's between Greg, Russel, and Eric.. Aren't many of us left, we'll have to decide who to vote off today, there have to be...7 of us for a majority? Pa-da-ping! I love pointing out contradictions! Distance? Oh, no, no, my friend. I thought it 'twas merely a coincidence that you both posted the same vote for me near the same time!
-
Not sure how Pamela felt about your sausage (which might be a matter you'd want to take up with Al), but I'm happily married. So keep that sausage where it belongs, sir! Day 3: The Day of Fluff Posts! Maybe he was trying to hide his scum pal, Greg, by just avoiding contact whatsoever.
-
Sure convinced me there! I might as well vote now, too, nothing has change. Vote: Gregory McHenry (Lady K) I wonder what we'll do for the next 70-odd hours?
-
Was it watcher? My bad, thought a cop was mentioned somewhere in there. So, either the blocker blocked the scum or the vig. Or SK, I suppose. How did we get from 3 kills to one kill? Multiple blockers? Or someone was protected and got lucky, then. Maybe the scum were out for Al, but he got protected. There's way too many variables in that.
-
Alright, so seems that Al's cop was right. Today's probably going to be either with Greg or Russell lynched. Anyone have any new ideas during the night?
-
Congrats, all!
-
Bit contradictory there. Obviously, this doesn't change my vote. Just thought I'd point that out. Or I missed something. I'm not sure how a redirected kill is shown.
-
It's illogical to not: Unvote: Gregory McHenry (Lady K) Vote: Irene Allen (mostlytechnic) Greg, I suppose we can put you off for another day.
-
Everything, to me at least, points directly to Greg being scum. Am I reading too much into all these events? Eh..possibly, but I'm not willing at this moment to change my mind, unless Greg writes something amazingly convincing. Shirley firmly stood against Greg from the beginning of Day 1, a bit of waffling in the middle, and then voting against Greg at the end, saying "we should have stuck to Greg". Night 1, Shirley dies, begin, again, the only vote against Greg. Greg, already under suspicion for being scum by Shirley, and having lots of pings by the rest of us, decides to get rid of Shirley, hoping that, with Shirley, the suspicion will go away. Mix in allusions to past games, weak defenses, and, now that I remember, saying that Brian "could be town or scum". I'm not quite sure how to take that at all. But it's such a ping that, along with the rest of this stuff, it rolls up into a big metaphorical ball of ping-y-ness and suspicion and overall scumminess. Thus, I voted for who I think is most likely scum. End of story. Well, as Brian is scum and I am town, I'm not sure why such a scenario is so impossible. I'm not calling you, Eric, directly out, but one of those who voted for me was surely scum. I've got time to think about exactly who, as well as hearing others' thoughts, so for now, getting Greg lynched and removing one more scum is the best option for me.
-
It just makes too much sense for one of you guys in the bandwagon to be scum. A last minute attempt to save your scum buddy Brian by throwing attention on a nice little townie like me (which, your reasons at the time were...somewhat...warranted. I was lurking, but Brian was too big of an issue to attempt to remove everyone's attention from him.) And it wasn't "just three votes". It was three consecutive votes, one right after another. (with a Bob vote tally in the middle of them)
-
This makes a great deal of sense, actually. It would make sense for Russel to attempt to create a bandwagon to move the vote away from his scum bud Brian and to a townie. It's your turn to speak up, Russel.
-
Haha nice, man, nice!
-
I've been saying this since the beginning of this day, so it shouldn't be any surprise - Vote: Gregory McHenry (Lady K) Why? A weak defense in the face of accusations. When Shirley and Al voted Day 1, this was Greg's response: Yep, fluff. As a defense. I do admit that Shirley's sudden vote and the Al's follow up vote with little reason given was a bit strange, but that would have been the perfect time to convince those two of town-y-ness. Yet there was nothing there. It'll have to be a strong defense to get you out of this one, Greg. Also, wow. We're 24 hours into Day 2, and we're only at 2 pages. That's just...wow. Really unusual. I remember one day in a forest that went on for 19.
-
I mean that I'm voting for him because I think that he's scum. Why else would I even consider voting for him? Wording gets a bit complicated, sorry 'bout that.
-
That's just how I am. We've still got..well...actually I think we've passed the first 24 hours, but once voting becomes official I'll start my firm opinions. There's no point in threatening people if your opinions change. I, personally, only think that threats should come after lots of thought processes and private decisions. Clearly you don't feel the same. Do you really not see any connection? I've said it at least once today - there are hardly any coincidences. Earlier, Al said that it's likely that Shirley's death came from an anti-town killer, which makes a lot of sense - why would we kill someone who was really helpful and vocal yesterday? I'm still inclined to vote for Greg today, therefore, of course, I'm inclined to think that he's scum, therefore, either he or one of his scum pals killed Shirley. It's not super complicated. Mainly that in past...events (mafia games, I guess. How do I metagame..) the most vocal haven't really ever died during the first night. Just a pattern I've noticed. I never thought that Shirley was scum, quite the opposite, in fact, I thought she was one of us.
-
Except that she's contributing more and not lurking like she was? That was your reason, after all, so what's the problem now?
-
This makes sense, to me. Carl and Katherine were both on the Brian bandwagon, but so were the rest of us, pretty much, so that tells us pretty much nothing. Most likely an unlucky vig kill, choosing a random person to kill, hoping for scum; and a SK chipping away at our numbers. Odd move... Only because you claimed town yesterday, right? Still, though..I wouldn't say the smartest move on their part, no offense, but it's still too early to completely trust anyone here.
-
It's more so that Shirley unvoted Brian, who at that point was already near lynch (Shirley's vote put him at 8), and so firmly voted for Greg. I'm not throwing any definite blame on anyone, but hardly anything is chance in Mafia, and Shirley would have most definitely (I think, at least) pushed for a vote for Greg today, if she was still alive. Also, for everyone, here's the mess of votes that is Day 1: Clicky! Really difficult to organize in any chronological way, so I just put numbers in front of the order of the vote, i.e. Eric voted for Al first, so there's a 1 in front of his vote; Carl voted next, thus, a 2.
-
There was so much switching between votes yesterday that it potentially could be anyone. Eric voted for Al first, and then switched to me, so looking into him could be worth something. Has anyone started a table to keep track of votes? If not I will.
-
Has to be a scum block, then. Probably. There's no reason that the town would block Al. Shame about the three deaths, I really wasn't expecting Shirley to die this early on. Greg's on my suspicion list, too, especially after Shirley was the only one to vote for him yesterday. Bit...coincidental...he died, wouldn't you say? Maybe because Al declared his role yesterday, so we'd know it? Not sure..
-
Well, things got complicated, both life-wise and game-wise. I've finished my exams for this year, so no more disappearances from me. (Didn't have much time to catch up on the game before this moment, so pardon my lurking, I was just trying to get a quick understanding of what's going on.) As for the vote and what I said, well, at the time, what more could be said? It was an empty post from Wanda that pinged me, and her next post didn't even acknowledge the previous votes. I'm still a tad suspicious, but I suppose it can wait until later, since we need to secure a majority. If Al is the watcher, or tracker, or whatever it's called, then yea, its way too risky to lynch him now. On one hand, it could be a desperate scum move to avoid a bandwagon, but, on the other hand, he could be telling the truth. Impossible to tell at this point. You've gotta hand it to him, regardless, he's completely avoided the bandwagon. I'm going to Unvote: Wanda (Piratedave84) and Vote: Brian (Shadows) There's been so much jumping around, we need to secure a vote before the day ends. It really seems like Al against Brian, and since Al claimed a role, and as Brian nearly has the 10 votes, I've got to vote Brian, for the good of the town.
-
Damn, I'm at the Emporium for 9 hours, and then all this happens?! I can't believe you guys left me out of the fun! The votes are good, and I'll never not say that a vote isn't justified (except those attention-grabber votes. Damn those.), but out of all this behavior, the only strange ping I got was from Wanda. The only strategy (if there is one at all) that I can see is trying to just fade out until tomorrow, when hopefully everyone's forgotten about this vote.. But again, I don't try to guess people's strategies - I'm usually wrong. IWanda's been playing a while, though.. Right? Or did I miss that? Inexperienced or not, saying absolutely nothing about a direct vote is just...weird. And scummy. Scummy vibes. Anyway, I'll go and Vote: Wanda (Piratedave84). I'm willing to change it, I just need a really good reason for the behavior.
-
Oh crap! No, no I'm...no! I meant...collaboration! I meant collaboration! No fish/donut collaboration! By the way, we all know that these offers for fish and donuts are for the cheapest, least edible kind of donuts and fish. If you want the tastiest, go with the Emporium. "Selling literally everything excepts deities since 1805"
-
It can't be, no no. There is no correlation between donuts and fish. It's either one or the other. Donut=town, fish=scum. Basis? Killing fish, murder=scum. It's the most simple choice. I've got my eyes on you, Eric. Your defense of fish is a little too strong.
-
Oho, nice one! We all have products to offer, it just depends on what is offered... If we get some scum-tracking radars in at the Emporium, I'll let you all know. I'm going to add 300% to the price, since you all seem desperate enough.
