Tamamono

I doubt that they're both scum and I doubt that Creeper has some confirmation of Clayface. However, what are the odds that they decide to copy Deadshot and use his action on Calendar Man, but Clayface instead kills Riddler while Deadshot kills their original target (Calendar Man)? That is way too much of a coincidence, and I don't believe in coincidences. Face it Crane, Deadshot is the scum day-killer. You and Music Meister are standing around saying that it isn't 'strong enough' evidence against Deadshot, when frankly, there isn't much anyone can do but claim things. If someone came forward with an investigation result, would you dismiss them saying that it was 'only a claim'? No, you would follow the investigator's result just like everybody else would, and if it turned out wrong, then you would start entertaining possibilities that the investigator lied. Nope, I didn't forget, and I'm not 'happy to forget' it either. In fact, I think it's very likely that the scum will convert Creeper at some point. However, he isn't converted at the moment. The scum can kill or convert during a day/night phase. They killed today (and don't say that a day-kill doesn't count as a kill. It does.), so he wasn't converted on Night 2. He wasn't converted Night 1, either, because since Day 2 he's been on Ventriloquist's case, who almost everyone (including you!) agrees is incredibly scummy. If you think that Creeper has been converted, then you can't suspect Ventriloquist. Use your head! I don't know, but it's pretty easy to figure out. If Clayface is scum, why would he use someone else's action on Nygma? Why wouldn't he just use a collective kill? And don't come to me saying the scum don't have a killer. Every scum team has a collective kill (except in a book called Prison Riot, but that was because there were four scum teams).

The same goes for Wesker. If he's really a protector, then we certainly don't want to kill him. However, we have to take a chance here. Someone is going to die. Honestly, I don't see why you people are doubting Deadshot's guilt. Two (two!) day kills happen in the same day, and then Clayface comes forward and says that he copied Deadshot and used his action on Calendar Man. This claim is backed up by Creeper, who is confirmed town because of Catwoman's conviction. This means that Deadshot killed The Riddler, who was the investigator. No vigilante would kill the investigator. That means that Deadshot is the scum day-killer.

Egg-cellent! Vote: Deadshot (Rumble Strike)

But you yourself said that you never miss! If your role is based on your identity (it's starting to look that way for everyone), then your vigilante kill is 100%, because you never miss. Besides, Doll already said that a vigilante (with a different MO from yours) killed Ra's on night 1. I seriously doubt that there are two vigilantes. Also, if Clayface is scum, why would he copy you and use your action against Nygma? It would have been much easier for him to get his scum team to use their collective kill against Nygma without having to go through all that trouble. Nice try, Floyd, but you're not fooling anyone.

Wait, he claimed that he had targeted Doll? I was under the impression that he had promised beforehand to protect Doll and then the tracker found that he targeted Deadshot instead. With this new piece of info about Deadshot being the scum killer, I think it's possible that Wesker is the scum bodyguard. I agree, but he said he was protecting them, not blocking them. That's strange. Usually, when you get bussed, you get a message explaining that you targeted the other target instead. There is no 'I was probably bussed' involved. Either you were bussed or you weren't, and frankly, I don't think Wesker was. Damn, it looks like Nygma got poached. And Calender Man too! I've heard of poisonings, but I've never heard of someone getting shot in the middle of the day... So that means that Deadshot is really the scum day-killer. In that case, I know where my vote's going today!

No he wouldn't have. Joker only tells us the allegiances of dead people. Ra's is alive. It's always one extreme or another with you people. I wasn't saying that all the people who voted for Bane are town, I was simply saying that the fact that some people voted early does not automatically make them scum. In fact, most (if not all) of the scum were probably on that bandwagon, since Ventriloquist is likely to be scum himself.

How do you know Ra's isn't neutral? There's no reason why he couldn't be. Frankly, I don't think we can learn much from the Bane lynch. He really was digging his own grave by admitting that he overlooked/forgot about Joker's revelation about Doll, and there's no reason why townies wouldn't have voted for him as soon as they got the chance. While I am highly suspicious of Wesker and Pinocchio, it's early days yet, and nothing is guaranteed. Stop being such a sheep!

I agree. Wesker's not going to be able to lie his way out of this one. As are we all.

Damn it! How could Bane have been town!? And a more important question: was he really the doctor? If he was, then why was there no scum kill last night? Could they have targeted Nygma on Night 1 and then converted tonight? I'm very sorry to the late Bane and to the rest of the town for pushing for his conviction so hard. It appears my scumdar isn't getting any better. While it's great that Ra's has returned to the world of the living, his re-animation definitely reminds me of the Vampire role. Care to explain why exactly you were brought back to life, Ra's?

Welcome to the game, JimB!

Wow, that looks amazing! I'll be looking forward to it!

After completing Quest 4, Tomas strides back into the Hall and signs up for Quest 14: The Family Recipe, Quest 16: The Paladin Conquest, and Quest 17: The Lion's Share. That having been taking care of, Tomas walks over to a table and orders a drink. "Thank you very much, De'kra! Come, take a seat."

Wow, that was an amazing quest, Doc! Thanks for letting me be a part of it!

"Hoorah!" "I will give Chunk of Lucky Table to Thormanil and Robe of Spell Resistance to Ad-Hoh."

"Normally I would heal you, but the battles going to be coming to an end soon, so there really isn't much point."

OOC: Whoops, I completely forgot about that! "I think I will attack Lord Ricroar from the back row."

Order of action: Leo Xander Thormanil Cinna Ad-Hoh Benji De'kra Tomas OOC: I'm pretty sure that potion restored my health. "I will attack Lord Ricroar from the front row!"

Wait, did you forget it or did you not read it? Your lies and justifications are getting more ridiculous by the minute. There is nothing wrong with having your own opinions. In fact, I want to encourage everyone to act upon their own opinions and not bandwagon like a bunch of sheep. However, your refusal to vote for Catwoman used completely different criteria than your initial vote for Nygma. According to you, you only voted for Nygma so that we could all 'work together', but you refused to vote for Catwoman because you said that you thought she was town. Why did this criteria not apply to Nygma? Why would you suddenly start caring about guilt when the vote for Catwoman came up? While I do think that Wesker and Pinocchio are scum, the case against Bane seems much stronger to me. I'll stand by my vote.

And what use to the town is a townie who pays no attention? Vote: Bane (Masked Builder) Agreed. There's no unvote limit, so there's no reason to not vote yet.

That's true, most night one targets aren't based on much information. Still, the bus driver could just have easily been a townie criminal. It's also possible that you're a scum doctor and you Deadshot are both scum, and you protected him last night. Or maybe you're the converter and you chose to convert him to replace Catwoman. Or maybe you're the framer and you chose to frame someone who seems to be flying under the radar. It's obvious that it will be between Bane and The Ventriloquist today. Both are claiming to be doctors, and both are acting extremely scummy. I'm personally leaning towards Bane (his lies are so ridiculous, it's almost impossible that he's not scum), but I'm perfectly open to the Ventriloquist vote.

Oh, that is hilarious! Didn't you see Joker's announcement earlier? Baby Doll has been confirmed town criminal! Although I find it strange that the suspects are turning on each other. Maybe this means that they're not both scum after all... Wait, so you're claiming to be the protector as well? I suppose it is possible that your target was switched, but why would the bus driver target you on night one?

Order of action: Leo Xander Thormanil Cinna Ad-Hoh Benji De'kra Tomas "I'm not going to be able to take another hit, so I will drink a potion."

Wait, the Ventriloquist targeted Deadshot when he said that he was going to target Doll? Would you care to explain why you did this, Ventriloquist? I doubt that very much, Bane. Between your sketchy voting yesterday and your blatant lies today, I'm almost completely sure you're scum. I know where I'm putting my vote today.