Star Trek Mafia - Day Two

[Umbra-Manis]

19 hours ago, Khscarymovie4 said:

Ok sorry, Not so poor because he looked scummy but I still feel bad he is no longer with us Spock. There you go! As for not looking into my concerns its because I have been examining a new medical device called Wastage Oblivion Remover K8759. Now in general I was talking about how fast the votes happened. In a very short amount of time he went from 0 to 4. The four that first four that voted for him were me, Chekov, McCoy, and Mallory. I definitely would not think it too odd for there to be a scummo in that group. Of those votes I think McCoys strikes me as the most suspicious. 

I find it interesting he mentions Spock hoping on a bandwagon early and then does just that. I agreed with voting for Spock but to me McCoy's vote seems rather sheepish. Just sort of repeating what others have said and carrying along. The most interesting thing I think is that this ties McCoy and Spock together with 3 votes. Could it be a scum scared of getting lynched voting for Spock just so they can survive? McCoy also only mentioned Spock once more responding to my thoughts about him yesterday. 

It seems he wants to see some explanation to Spocks vote, fair enough I was very vocal about that myself. But McCoy never actually pushes Spock or questions him ever. His vote and this comment are the only times he actually seemed suspicious of Spock. This looks like someone who is already satisfied with lynch option to me. 

Well Nurse, I'm not a very pushy person, and Spock wasn't all that coherent in his responses (gifs and all) so I passed on conducting a full interrogation. I'm not entirely sure what your sentence "Could it be a scum scared of getting lynched voting for Spock just so they can survive?" means so if you could clarify that for me, I'll be happy to answer it. I'm not sure why you find two mentions of suspicions to be a low amount, given how quiet Sulu was as well as Uhura right at the end of the day. 

11 hours ago, Chromeknight said:

I didn’t feel I had to be.

i was asking what McCoy thought I should have been doing, since he didn’t like what I did do. Which, admittedly was, not much.

It’s not like I’m some little child named miri

Honestly at that point in the day, silence would have been better for your perception, as your post just seems like a weak way to confuse which voting group you were in. 

[Bob]

Vote Count: 
Doctor McCoy / Umbra-Mantis - 2 (Khscarymovie4, KotZ)
Lieutenant Kyle / KotZ - 2 (CMP, jimmynick

Less than 17 hours remain in Day Two. Five votes are required to lynch. 

[Chromeknight]

3 hours ago, Umbra-Manis said:

Honestly at that point in the day, silence would have been better for your perception, as your post just seems like a weak way to confuse which voting group you were in. 

Are you attempting some sort of dagger in the mind?

There is never any reason for any Starfleet officer to be silent. Silence helps the Romulans. It would be a very boring hour of logs if the cameras turned on and we were sitting, doing our jobs and not talking. 

Think about it. I had not expressed what I thought, you wouldn’t have picked on it today, expressed a negative reason and not drawn my vote.

As it is I’m glad I spoke, I’m starting to think I was right yesterday.

vote: McCoy (Umbra-Manis)

[Khscarymovie4]

6 hours ago, KotZ said:

Vote: McCoy (Umbra-Mantis)

I've stated my reasons as such. Part of me wonders if Mallory might be town now, with just how hard of a vote he is pushing for me, Kyle. If he's scum, it's a crazy move, because if I'm voted off and turn up town, it's a massive target pn his back. And with two of the known crew being Romulans, and going into Day 3 with two dead starfleet, that doesn't look good for scum.

Not saying this clears him, but it's a thought I've had.

Yeah yesterday you stated your suspicions against McCoy, which was pretty much about his weird explanation or whatever. Is that still the reason you find him scummy enough to vote for or is it more to do with his voting and such? 

4 hours ago, Umbra-Manis said:

Well Nurse, I'm not a very pushy person, and Spock wasn't all that coherent in his responses (gifs and all) so I passed on conducting a full interrogation. I'm not entirely sure what your sentence "Could it be a scum scared of getting lynched voting for Spock just so they can survive?" means so if you could clarify that for me, I'll be happy to answer it. I'm not sure why you find two mentions of suspicions to be a low amount, given how quiet Sulu was as well as Uhura right at the end of the day. 

Honestly at that point in the day, silence would have been better for your perception, as your post just seems like a weak way to confuse which voting group you were in. 

But if you wanted an explanation form Spock why wouldn't you push a little? If you find someone suspicious you should want to see if there is some thought to what they are saying. Sitting around and saying very little about the person you want to lynch does not really give any insights to you or the person you have eyes on, thus not real helpful to the town. Were you sure that Spock was scum and felt trying to get answers was useless? To me your actions don't seem very townie. You seem to dislike Uhura's previous comment but fail to show weather you find her suspicious or not. In fact you seem to have no scummy thoughts about anybody. I must ask you who is pinging your radar right now? 

Actually thinking about it there are plenty of people who have not really called out anything particular today. Voting is open, not saying we should all rush into voting but its been open for awhile. And its hard to get a read on people who seem to have little reads on others. 

Ok now back to McCoy. "Could it be a scum scared of getting lynched voting for Spock just so they can survive?". You had 3 votes when you voted for Spock thus making you equal in votes. I am speculating here but it would make sense for a scum who has a possibility to be lynched switch over to the next best option real quick to try to get more focus over there. It's not really a question that you can answer more like a general thought that could help put a puzzle together. 

 

[Hinckley]

10 hours ago, Tariq j said:

 In all honesty I don’t think Scott helped himself at all there.

What? In what ways did I not help myself? And in what ways would I be trying to help myself by voting for who I find the most suspicious?

 

[Tariq j]

5 hours ago, Umbra-Manis said:

 

Honestly at that point in the day, silence would have been better for your perception, as your post just seems like a weak way to confuse which voting group you were in. 

Silence? Silence is what Spock was going after because he was so keen to Lynch someone so early on. 

 

55 minutes ago, Khscarymovie4 said:

Ok now back to McCoy. "Could it be a scum scared of getting lynched voting for Spock just so they can survive?". You had 3 votes when you voted for Spock thus making you equal in votes. I am speculating here but it would make sense for a scum who has a possibility to be lynched switch over to the next best option real quick to try to get more focus over there. It's not really a question that you can answer more like a general thought that could help put a puzzle together. 

 

I’ve been looking at that. Both Mallory and Scott switched their votes from Kyle to Spock. Though neither of them seem particularly scummy so far. That said, Mallory said this at the end of Day One:

On 7/19/2019 at 3:12 AM, CMP said:

Exactly this. Regardless of what your lynch might directly tell us Spock, look at all this discussion we've gotten done in the time since the McCoy bandwagon fell apart. If everyone hopped on it, we wouldn't have nearly as much to dissect in the days to come. .

In theory what he’s saying is true. The more we talk, the more we gain. But it comes across as a bit “oh hey, thank god we didn’t all go after McCoy cause that would have been a disaster, good thing everyone voted for Spock instead!” I Dunno this guy’s a tricky one. 

1 minute ago, Hinckley said:

What? In what ways did I not help myself? And in what ways would I be trying to help myself by voting for who I find the most suspicious?

 

That’s a typo. I meant to say Spock. Spock was not helping himself yesterday.

[Hinckley]

This is aggravating. This concept is going to make it very hard to find the Scum. They don't need to do anything but slide by. So who is trying to slide by? What does that even look like? I still don't like Kyle, but so much of that feeling was based on what was happening yesterday with Spock. Still, his voting position was Scummy. His reaction to my joke still pings me. Something about his general demeanor is pinging me when he's defending himself against accusations. I'm tired and very busy so I doubt I'm making sense. I have the vague recollection of thinking something he said today seemed much more of a contribution than yesterday. I'll have to go back and look.

I'm also trying to look at you looks like they're just contributing enough to slide by without being noticed. I have a list of four people that I suspect for that behavior. Which is half of us! I'm just trying to think of how I would play if I didn't have to hide anything, meaning there's no night actions, no kills, no investigations. If the Romulans fix their ship before we find the two of them among us, we all die, but they're not doing anything in the mean time but hanging out. There's no evidence. There is no evidence. I find this frustrating.

I'm aware this is hardly helpful, I'm just trying to organize my thoughts.

[jimmynick]

1 hour ago, Tariq j said:

Silence? Silence is what Spock was going after because he was so keen to Lynch someone so early on. 

Spock wasn't going after silence at all. He voted for me to begin with, and I love the sound of my own voice. Then he voted for McCoy for reasons completely unrelated to silence. This is a strange thing to say, Sulu.

[Khscarymovie4]

1 hour ago, Hinckley said:

seemed much more of a I'm also trying to look at you looks like they're just contributing enough to slide by without being noticed. I have a list of four people that I suspect for that behavior. Which is half of us! I'm just trying to think of how I would play if I didn't have to hide anything, meaning there's no night actions, no kills, no investigations. If the Romulans fix their ship before we find the two of them among us, we all die, but they're not doing anything in the mean time but hanging out. There's no evidence. There is no evidence. I find this frustrating.

I'm aware this is hardly helpful, I'm just trying to organize my thoughts.

It may be more helpful to give us the names of those you find contributing enough to slide by. Even if it's half I want to see where you stand on those 4. 

[KotZ]

3 hours ago, Khscarymovie4 said:

Yeah yesterday you stated your suspicions against McCoy, which was pretty much about his weird explanation or whatever. Is that still the reason you find him scummy enough to vote for or is it more to do with his voting and such?

Half his odd explanation, half how he's seeming to conduct himself.

1 hour ago, Hinckley said:

His reaction to my joke still pings me.

I thought I was just playing it off.

[Hinckley]

2 hours ago, Khscarymovie4 said:

It may be more helpful to give us the names of those you find contributing enough to slide by. Even if it's half I want to see where you stand on those 4. 

I was trying to avoid that until I had something more solid, but I suppose you're right. I read over what everyone said the last two days and now found a reason to suspect everyone. Seriously, everyone. Sorry. So, I'll do my best to articulate the stronger suspicions, which I admit might just be paranoia or my brain working overtime. I suppose if the Scum do end up with a night kill, I'd be a great target as I suspect everyone and then there would be nobody specific to point to as to who would want me dead and analyzing my posts would be almost futile. But here I go anyway.

I'll start by saying I still suspect Kyle and I'm surprised to see so much traction on a McCoy bandwagon again. They were both in sheepish voting positions and I understand the idea that McCoy was pushing the vote to a tie and saving himself from being lynched yesterday. That's a good point. I did find his reasons for voting solid, though. We saw Kyle on the same sheepish vote position twice yesterday. Twice. Kyle. If McCoy is lynched and comes up Scum, I'm going to look super Scummy. I'm taking that risk, though...

So, if I was to ask myself who I trust most at this point, I would say Ensign Mallory. Our analysis lined up most closely yesterday. Trusting someone in this game is bad. And that's now why I suspect Ensign Mallory. Sorry. There's almost nothing Scummy about his behavior at all. Which is suspect. If I were Scum in this setup I would want to distance myself from my buddy and Mallory has been all over Kyle. If the Romulans are Kyle/Mallory, I'd say they've done a solid job of not seeming like they're on the same team. That's what I think I might try to do if I was Scum in this setup.

On 7/19/2019 at 12:00 PM, Umbra-Manis said:

Two scum being on the same lynch seems unlikely this early in the game, but we got 6 due to a missed vote by commander scott, so that ups the percentage chance a little bit. Y

This still is a hard sentence for me to read. I meant to mention this earlier: what? Missed vote by commander Scott. What vote was missed? Where?

On 7/19/2019 at 12:00 PM, Umbra-Manis said:

 If the scum are split between voting and nonvoting camps, I think Uhura is the scummier of the two left alive from the small block, mainly because of this line:

I'm trying not to think of this arbitrary "One Scum voted for Spock, one Scum didn't" view. That's a bad place to get stuck. We have no idea what tactic they chose to place their votes on which wagon or whatever and we should stop compartmentalizing the game this way.

On 7/19/2019 at 1:25 PM, KotZ said:

I think that just might be Spock's playstyle, go for a lynch no matter the outcome and analyze later. He was like that last game if I'm not mistaken.

Four because I do suspect you. Not five because I think the hammer yesterday is mainly to keep a lynch happening rather than give scum a for sure kill.

As for ballsy scum moves, I think scum in past games have gotten much more bold with trying things, whether they fail or not, although that's a meta-discussion for another time. I wouldn't count scum being ballsy out.

Why not hammer a Townie? If you're Scum and you get a night-kill if there's no lynch but you've got a Townie on the line, why not hammer to seem Townie. You know a Townie will die either way and then you look even better for it tomorrow, knowing the Town won't have anything to work on with one dead Townie. Also, using a night-kill early in the game would've been an advantage to the Town, because we could've analyzed who the Scum chose to kill. So, no. Neither the hammer nor I should be clear in regards of voting position.

On 7/19/2019 at 3:38 PM, Tariq j said:

Well this sucks. Looking back at yesterday's vote pattern: 

Chapel places the first vote on Spock. His reasoning being that Spock has not given valid reasons as to why he voted for McCoy. 

Chekov then voted next. Based on the fact Spock didn't seem to be answering his questions. The reasoning feels a little weaker here.

Next up is McCoy. Again he votes Spock because of his floundering votes. 

Mallory comes win next. There's not a whole lot of analysis here. But he has kept to his word by going after Kyle.

Then there's myself. I'll admit there's not a whole lot of analysis from me either. However at this point Spock was all over the place his play was scummy and he seemed the best choice.

Lastly there's Scott. Who effectively guarantees the lynch (I.e. if someone had unvoted in the last few hours of the game the lynch would have still gone forward.) 

Sulu wins for "Most Under the Radar." If my theory that Scum is trying to fly down the center, I believe Sulu has the lowest post count (or that's my general impression without counting). He does a lot of summarizing which is a common Scum tactic to seem active. I mean his vote "analysis" from yesterday is Epic Fluff. He really just gave us a play-by-play of the votes. With zero analysis. He also wins "Fluffiest Fluff." Congratulations. Would you like to give a speech?

On 7/19/2019 at 5:50 PM, Khscarymovie4 said:

I find it interesting he mentions Spock hoping on a bandwagon early and then does just that. I agreed with voting for Spock but to me McCoy's vote seems rather sheepish. Just sort of repeating what others have said and carrying along. The most interesting thing I think is that this ties McCoy and Spock together with 3 votes. Could it be a scum scared of getting lynched voting for Spock just so they can survive? McCoy also only mentioned Spock once more responding to my thoughts about him yesterday. 

 

 How dare you insult one of the greatest female heroes of all time! I have my own Wikipedia page and I was voted 60th most important Star Trek character by Wired magazine. I may have to vote for you just for that.

I quoted this just to remind myself where that analysis of McCoy's vote position came from. While I'm at it, the second paragraph I left in made me laugh out loud. Thank, nurse! Laughter is truly the best medicine.

22 hours ago, Khscarymovie4 said:

It's gotten a bit quiet. I assume because some of us are into the darkness. -slaps knee-  Anyway I noticed no one has cast a vote yet. I don't find this particularly bad as rushing into a lynch is not the best idea. I would like to at least start a vote as I do have some suspicions upon our good old doctor. 

Vote: Lieutenant Commander McCoy (Umbra-Mantis)

As I said above his vote looks quite sheepish and he never seemed to bother looking for the explanation he seemed to want. I would very much like to hear from others especially Sulu seeing as how he gave us a whole lot of votes but no real insight. 

I forget why I quote this but I want to leave a pin in it, in case I remember.

22 hours ago, Chromeknight said:

I didn’t feel I had to be.

i was asking what McCoy thought I should have been doing, since he didn’t like what I did do. Which, admittedly was, not much.

It’s not like I’m some little child named miri

Here's my other top candidate for "Middle of the Road." Half his posts are ... titles of Star Trek episodes? If I was Scum and wanted to fill my posts with a little fluff to seem more active...and I was nerdy enough to know the titles of Star Trek episodes...I would totally work as many titles of Star Trek episodes into my posts as possible.

See why I wasn't sure this would be helpful? It's just suspicions thrown at everyone. My suspicions about Chekov, Chapel and McCoy are the weakest which is why I don't mention them...but now that makes me suspect them more...

McCoy and Kyle were our other two vote-getters yesterday and there's two wagons formed on them again. I don't like it, but I may end up voting for Kyle anyway. This setup seems difficult to win. I like it so far.

2 hours ago, KotZ said:

Half his odd explanation, half how he's seeming to conduct himself.

I thought I was just playing it off.

Playing it off? You mean my joke vote? I mean when you explained to me that your idea to vote for a letter of the alphabet was a joke. Of course it was a joke. I thought it was a Scummy mindset that would think my reaction, questioning your suspicion of the letter M, would not be a joke or that I would need it explained. Like you were trying to cool off what might have been a true suspicion or confrontation when it was a clear invitation to continue joking that the alphabet was after us.

Now you say you "play[ed] it off" which I assume you are referencing your response to my joke vote. That is an immensely interesting phrase for a Townie to use. "You made a joke vote against me but I played it off." I can't wrap my mind around a Townie reason to play something off. Sounds guilty.

[Hinckley]

Well, we have to vote and Kyle's last post keeps clawing around in my brain. "Played it off." I think I've voiced my suspicions of him thoroughly.

vote: Lieutenant Kyle (KotZ)

I have to admit this may be tunnel vision. When he first said "Why not M?" I admit thinking that was Scummy. Then he reacted to my reaction explaining it was a joke which I thought would've been obvious. If someone voted for me and said it was because of my behavior in a previous game, I think I would've had a strong reaction. I realize Kyle isn't me but I found his reaction timid. Is timidity Scummy? Maybe. Trying not to make ripples.

Overall, it seems to me he spends most of his time defending himself instead of truly looking into suspicions. Maybe I'm totally wrong, it's happened before. It happened with Spock. Tunnel vision it may be, but I really think the term "played it off" is sealing his coffin for me. Or his trip to the brig or whatever we're calling it this time.

[Khscarymovie4]

Right now the vote is tied 3 to 3. Who has not voted? Sulu and McCoy it seems. 

I think Scotty has a good point about scum could easily go under the radar this game and Sulu seems to be doing that quite well. Something I have noticed is that the most he has done to call someone specific out was saying Mallory is a tricky one. He posted all of the votes for Spock yet never seemed to have any suspicions about them, just sort of restating the votes. He seems to be acting a little too safe to me. And with him not giving us insight to who he finds scummy makes him hard to read, which I don't like. 

The other is McCoy! my medical buddy. At the beginning of the day you seemed to have some thoughts about Uhura and the yellow shirts. Where did your thoughts on the yellow shirts go? Do you still have them? You seemed to not like Uhrua's post and claimed it was confusing but fail to actually show weather or not you find her scummy. Bring uncommitted is a common scum trait that I find common with you today. What's more interesting is that yesterday you took no time to immediately vote for Spock because of your thoughts. But now even though it seems you may have some suspicions lingering in your mind you say "Voting? Why would others want to know what I think?". Why the sudden change in voting pace? Is it because Uhrua does not have a following like Spock did yesterday? 

As for Kyle who McCoy is tied with. I looked into him and I find his vote on McCoy to also be very bandwagony similar to how Spock's was. Other then that not much looks odd to me. I was thinking about switching to him to get a lynch but honestly having some new thoughts about McCoy make me even more suspicious about him. From the looks of it I don't think McCoy and Kyle would be on the same scum team as I don't think a scum joining a bandwagon that early on day 1 would show any benefit. If my thoughts on McCoy are right then I would find Kyle a bit more townie, which is why I'm not so eager to vote for him. If it looks all lost I may have to join just to try and keep the scum away from a free kill. 

[Tariq j]

I apologies if it seems I’ve been hiding under the radar. Been very busy navigating our course making sure we don’t bump into any asteroids. The split in the vote feels deliberate. The issue is we have no evidence or night actions. So our suspicions and votes are entirely of what people have said (or not said). At present I’m more suspicious of Kyle given his sheepish votes for McCoy both today and yesterday. He was trying to make a something out of nothing. As others have done. 

Vote: Kyle (KotZ)

If Kyle is scum then I think the last scum will be one of the three votes on McCoy for trying to prevent the Lynch. And likewise if McCoy is scum then I think one of the scum is one of the votes on Kyle. I agree with Nurse Chapman and I don’t think McCoy and Kyle are both scum but there’s a small possibility they could both be town and the scum could be on both bandwagons. Trying to stop the lynch they get a night kill.

[Chromeknight]

3 minutes ago, Tariq j said:

If Kyle is scum then I think the last scum will be one of the three votes on McCoy for trying to prevent the Lynch. And likewise if McCoy is scum then I think one of the scum is one of the votes on Kyle. I agree with Nurse Chapman and I don’t think McCoy and Kyle are both scum but there’s a small possibility they could both be town and the scum could be on both bandwagons. Trying to stop the lynch they get a night kill.

Um. No.

If both McCoy and Kyle are town the scum would have no interest in preventing the lynch. We’ve been through this. There’s no benefit to the scum to their getting a night kill, either they lynch a town during the day or kill a town at night. It’s the town that doesn’t loses out by not lunching since it guarantees a town dies, as opposed to the shot of lynching a scum.

I think we’re playing this backwards. Out there are two people who would only lynch each other if utterly pushed. I rate unlikely they’d bus each other, the risks are too high, especially with a diminishing number required for majority. Remember, there’s no investigator, no solid basis for trust, but I expect we’ll still see crew members trying to cover others, explain for them, divert suspicion and proclaim another’s townieness (or at least, comparative non-scumminess). 

In any case Sulu’s waffle above about “if someone flips scum the other must be in the other vote” is both trivial and unhelpful.

I’ve already voted McCoy, but it seems for the second day running he skates out of the lynch, so I’ll do what I didn’t do last time (which McCoy critiqued)

unvote: McCoy (Umbra-Manis)

vote:Kyle (Kotz)

And to save Scotty’s head I’m going to give up adding episode titles in.

-the town that loses out by not lynching-

[Bob]

Vote Count: 
Doctor McCoy / Umbra-Mantis - 2 (Khscarymovie4, KotZ)
Lieutenant Kyle / KotZ - 5 (CMP, jimmynick, Hinckley, Chromeknight, Tariq j)

Less than 2 hours remain in Day Two. Five votes are required to lynch. 

[Bob]

Vote Count: 
Doctor McCoy / Umbra-Mantis - 2 (Khscarymovie4, KotZ)
Lieutenant Kyle / KotZ - 5 (CMP, jimmynick, Hinckley, Chromeknight, Tariq j)
Non Voter - Doctor McCoy / Umbra-Mantis

With five votes, Lieutenant Kyle / KotZ has been lynched. 

"Oh bother." Lieutenant Kyle said.

"Well, Lieutenant. It's time to send you to the brig. Energize!"

In a matter of seconds, Lieutenant Kyle was locked on to and beamed off the bridge.

"Looks like we'll have to wait a bit longer before the transporter comes back online."

"Aye, Captain. I'll get back to work on it right away." Scotty said.

Just then, the Captain's chair beeped. 

[jimmynick]

9 hours ago, Hinckley said:

He does a lot of summarizing which is a common Scum tactic to seem active.

You'd know about that, wouldn't you? 

3 hours ago, Chromeknight said:

 so I’ll do what I didn’t do last time (which McCoy critiqued)

And here we have the hammer vote.

Not sure how I feel about this detente between the McCoy and Kyle camps suddenly resolved. We'll see tomorrow.

[Umbra-Manis]

8 hours ago, Hinckley said:

This still is a hard sentence for me to read. I meant to mention this earlier: what? Missed vote by commander Scott. What vote was missed? Where?

You said that you missed the hammer/5th vote so you initially thought that you were the 5th vote. 

14 hours ago, Khscarymovie4 said:

Ok now back to McCoy. "Could it be a scum scared of getting lynched voting for Spock just so they can survive?". You had 3 votes when you voted for Spock thus making you equal in votes. I am speculating here but it would make sense for a scum who has a possibility to be lynched switch over to the next best option real quick to try to get more focus over there. It's not really a question that you can answer more like a general thought that could help put a puzzle together. 

Oh okay, I understand what you were saying now. 

3 hours ago, Tariq j said:

I apologies if it seems I’ve been hiding under the radar. Been very busy navigating our course making sure we don’t bump into any asteroids. The split in the vote feels deliberate. The issue is we have no evidence or night actions. So our suspicions and votes are entirely of what people have said (or not said). At present I’m more suspicious of Kyle given his sheepish votes for McCoy both today and yesterday. He was trying to make a something out of nothing. As others have done. 

I don't like this, it's just an in character response and a quick hop on the wagon of Kyle. 

15 hours ago, Chromeknight said:

Are you attempting some sort of dagger in the mind?

There is never any reason for any Starfleet officer to be silent. Silence helps the Romulans. It would be a very boring hour of logs if the cameras turned on and we were sitting, doing our jobs and not talking. 

Think about it. I had not expressed what I thought, you wouldn’t have picked on it today, expressed a negative reason and not drawn my vote.

As it is I’m glad I spoke, I’m starting to think I was right yesterday.

vote: McCoy (Umbra-Manis)

You weren't silent on the day, which definitely would have helped the romulans, I was referring to the tiny end portion of the day when you'd already made your vote and the lynch of spock was secure. If you hadn't then we wouldn't be wondering about who you really wanted to lynch, since you seem to have been fine with either dying, almost as if you knew they were both townies. You're putting a lot of effort into this defense, and since I'm not really a fan of the lynch on Kyle, I'm going to put my money where my mouth is.

Vote: Uhura (Chromeknight)

[Bob]

Just now, Umbra-Manis said:

Vote: Uhura (Chromeknight)

Since you were typing while the day conclusion was going up, I'll count this vote.

Final Vote Count: 
Doctor McCoy / Umbra-Mantis - 2 (Khscarymovie4, KotZ)
Lieutenant Kyle / KotZ - 5 (CMP, jimmynick, Hinckley, Chromeknight, Tariq j)
Lieutenant Uhura / Chromeknight - 1 (Umbra-Mantis)