Trekkie99 Posted July 18, 2019 Posted July 18, 2019 38 minutes ago, jimmynick said: Why not leave your vote on me, misguided as it was? Because I can't trust everyone else join my wagon in time to achieve a lynch so I moved over to the next best (if not thee best at the moment) wagon. 46 minutes ago, jimmynick said: You weren't ready to vote for him earlier, but you're right on the heels of Uhura's vote. I believe it is you, Mr. Chekov, that is overstating their case.
Khscarymovie4 Posted July 18, 2019 Posted July 18, 2019 4 hours ago, Trekkie99 said: 26 hours left and we need five collective votes! Unvote: Ensign Chekov: (jimmynick) Vote: Dr. McCoy (Umbra-Manis) Sorry doctor, but many lives are at stake on this ship, as well as the entire Federation if the Romulans take possession of this vessel. Hey, I understand your want to lynch someone but do you have any reason as to why you voted? This looks quite odd to me. Why did you not vote for Kyle who also had a vote? What about Dr. McCoy do you find worthy to try and get lynched? Though if we lynch McCoy I don't have to take any medical orders from anyone besides myself. 2 hours ago, KotZ said: Vote: Dr. McCoy (Umbra-Manis) His explanation is weird, as I mentioned earlier. Just enough to be helpful, but also to generate confusion. These votes are starting to pile and I'm not sure if I like it. I can understand the need to lynch someone today but I'm not sure if McCoy's post is really lynch worthy. I do appreciate you giving a reason. 15 minutes ago, Trekkie99 said: I wouldn't be as worried as I am about getting a lynch If the day lasted 72 hours. I can understand your worriedness, but voting with no reasoning other then we need a lynch about halfway into the day is not the best strategy for us here crew. And I think you have been asked why you voted for McCoy but still no reasoning. There are now a couple of us here with votes but you still stay by he doctor. You must have a reason, what makes him scummier to you then the others with a vote? Vote: Commander Spock (Trekkie99) For basically what I said above. 1 hour ago, jimmynick said: Forgive me if I'm wrong, but the comment preceding your vote suggests your primary concern is achieving a lynch, and it doesn't much matter who gets booted off the bridge? Why McCoy? Why not leave your vote on me, misguided as it was? You say the following: I think "several" rather overstates your case, and I observe that the post in which you noted McCoy's flawed argument lacks a vote: You weren't ready to vote for him earlier, but you're right on the heels of Uhura's vote. I wonder if our replicators produce mutton? You still have your vote for a letter. You seem to now have questions for Spock but keep your vote on Q. Do you really think that's helping the town at this moment? 5 hours ago, Trekkie99 said: 26 hours left and we need five collective votes! Do we? I thought it was whoever had the highest votes would be lynch we is usually in forced lynch games. But Good o' Kirk said this 3 hours ago, Bob said: Vote Count: Lieutenant Kyle - 1 (Hinckley) Doctor McCoy - 2 (Chromeknight, Trekkie99) Just about 24 hours remain in Day One. The scum will receive a night kill. There is no lettering telling us how many votes we need to lynch so I suspected it would be the majority, but then Kirk says the scum get a kill if we don't lynch. I thought the only way of a no lynch would be if someone was tied but I may be wrong here. I'm a bit confused and I hope I don't bother you, you great captain of the greatest space vessel in the galaxy, but do we need 5 votes in order to lynch today?
jimmynick Posted July 18, 2019 Posted July 18, 2019 39 minutes ago, Trekkie99 said: I believe it is you, Mr. Chekov, that is overstating their case. Okay, so your votes are separated by four hours even though they are consecutive posts. Sue me. 15 minutes ago, Khscarymovie4 said: You still have your vote for a letter. You seem to now have questions for Spock but keep your vote on Q. Do you really think that's helping the town at this moment? I have suspicions of both Dr Spock and Lt Kyle, but I haven't decided who most deserves my vote yet. 17 minutes ago, Khscarymovie4 said: do we need 5 votes in order to lynch today? yes. Commander Bob said so when Mallory was doing the coffee run. 44 minutes ago, Trekkie99 said: Because I can't trust everyone else join my wagon in time to achieve a lynch so I moved over to the next best (if not thee best at the moment) wagon. How come McCoy was the next-best wagon? Why not Kyle? He had a vote on him at the time you changed yours.
Hinckley Posted July 18, 2019 Posted July 18, 2019 49 minutes ago, Trekkie99 said: Because I can't trust everyone else join my wagon in time to achieve a lynch so I moved over to the next best (if not thee best at the moment) wagon. Why would you look for a wagon to join instead of looking for Scummy behavior? I realize the days are shorter than previous games but we have 21 hours to reach a lynch.
Trekkie99 Posted July 18, 2019 Posted July 18, 2019 Just now, Hinckley said: Why would you look for a wagon to join instead of looking for Scummy behavior? McCoy suits both my needs matter of factly. 7 minutes ago, jimmynick said: Why not Kyle? IDK, you tell me.
jimmynick Posted July 18, 2019 Posted July 18, 2019 I don't like this flippant attitude in response to genuine questions and concerns. Vote: Spock (Trekkie99)
Umbra-Manis Posted July 18, 2019 Posted July 18, 2019 11 minutes ago, jimmynick said: How come McCoy was the next-best wagon? Why not Kyle? He had a vote on him at the time you changed yours. 5 hours ago, Trekkie99 said: 26 hours left and we need five collective votes! Unvote: Ensign Chekov: (jimmynick) Vote: Dr. McCoy (Umbra-Manis) Sorry doctor, but many lives are at stake on this ship, as well as the entire Federation if the Romulans take possession of this vessel. Quotes came in weird and they won't move. Anyway, I acknowledge the confusing appearance of my first attempt gives Uhura credence in voting, but you're just right on trying to hop on a bandwagon early as the second vote, which seems like trying to get on early instead of being caught hammering the lynch later. 1 hour ago, Trekkie99 said: I wouldn't be as worried as I am about getting a lynch If the day lasted 72 hours. I gotta say, panicking about the votes when we still had more than half the day is a little overkill. And it just clogs the discussion with perceived activity. Vote: Mr. Spock (Trekkie99)
Trekkie99 Posted July 18, 2019 Posted July 18, 2019 8 minutes ago, jimmynick said: How come McCoy was the next-best wagon? There already was a vote on him and suspicions put against him which I agreed with. Just now, jimmynick said: I don't like this flippant attitude in response to genuine questions and concerns. They're not. You've asked "why not Kyle". Why Kyle? Hinckley voted for him half as a joke and half as suspicion. 24 minutes ago, jimmynick said: I have suspicions of both Dr Spock and Lt Kyle And what are your suspicions of Lt Kyle?
Bob Posted July 18, 2019 Author Posted July 18, 2019 Vote Count: Lieutenant Kyle/KotZ - 2 (Hinckley, CMP)Doctor McCoy/Umbra-Mantis - 3 (Chromeknight, Trekkie99, KotZ)Scotty/Hinckley - 1 (Tariq j)Spock/Trekkie99 - 2 (Khscarymovie4, jimmynick, Umbra-Mantis) About 20 hours remain in Day One. 5 votes are required to lynch.
Trekkie99 Posted July 18, 2019 Posted July 18, 2019 Here's Hinckley's. Not much IMO. On 7/17/2019 at 11:14 AM, Hinckley said: Aha! It's the alphabet that's out to get us. I agree. Except I think it's Z. Vote: Z On 7/17/2019 at 11:25 AM, KotZ said: Why not M? On 7/17/2019 at 11:27 AM, Hinckley said: If you think M deserves a vote, vote for M! Why are you asking me? On 7/17/2019 at 11:48 AM, KotZ said: It was but a joke, Mr. Scott. On 7/17/2019 at 12:40 PM, Hinckley said: Unlike my reply which was a clear and serious entreaty for you to vote for a letter of the alphabet. Any reason you couldn't pick up on my joke? Defensive? Does that tone not read on your planet, Romulan? What is the name of your planet? Romulo? We cannae joke! There's not enough power!!! 13 hours ago, Hinckley said: Vote: Lieutenant Kyle because he sucker-lynched me in the last game. And he's a red shirt, so they're supposed to be fodder for the fire. This is a half-hearted vote in case I get sucked into work. I, by no means, find Kyle Scummy at this point. Except for his Romulan-like defensiveness to my joke...so I guess I actually do find him the Scummiest. But I have been incredibly busy and want to place a vote so the same shit doesn't happen to me that happened to me last time.
CMP Posted July 18, 2019 Posted July 18, 2019 1 hour ago, Trekkie99 said: Because I can't trust everyone else join my wagon in time to achieve a lynch so I moved over to the next best (if not thee best at the moment) wagon. 26 minutes ago, Trekkie99 said: McCoy suits both my needs matter of factly. Comments like these give the impression that suspicion and reasoning is secondary to getting a lynch. That's a really bad color if you're a townie. If. I'm going to Unvote: Lieutenant Kyle/KotZ and Vote: Spock/Trekkie99. But I know who to look at next if Spock comes up scum. Kyle. Kyle who hasn't shown up since he's started being seriously looked at. Drop in and come say hi when you have a chance.
Khscarymovie4 Posted July 18, 2019 Posted July 18, 2019 13 minutes ago, Trekkie99 said: McCoy suits both my needs matter of factly. I still don't understand what scummy behavior you think McCoy is showing. You have not once gave any reasoning for voting other then needing a lynch. You have been asked multiple times as a matter of fact. 15 minutes ago, jimmynick said: I don't like this flippant attitude in response to genuine questions and concerns. Vote: Spock (Trekkie99) 5 minutes ago, Umbra-Manis said: Quotes came in weird and they won't move. Anyway, I acknowledge the confusing appearance of my first attempt gives Uhura credence in voting, but you're just right on trying to hop on a bandwagon early as the second vote, which seems like trying to get on early instead of being caught hammering the lynch later. I gotta say, panicking about the votes when we still had more than half the day is a little overkill. And it just clogs the discussion with perceived activity. Vote: Mr. Spock (Trekkie99) I agree with these votes but the fact that Spock went from 0 to 3 votes in 30 minutes alarms me a bit. McCoy's vote is especially bandwagonish. The section I made bold shows him calling out Spock for bandwagoning just to do it himself. 16 minutes ago, Trekkie99 said: There already was a vote on him and suspicions put against him which I agreed with. They're not. You've asked "why not Kyle". Why Kyle? Hinckley voted for him half as a joke and half as suspicion. Why McCoy? The point I think Chekov and I are trying to make is that if you were only looking to hop on a lynch why did you choose McCoy over Kyle? Especially considering now there are votes against quite a few people and you have chosen to stay behind McCoy with no reasoning. 9 minutes ago, Bob said: Vote Count: Lieutenant Kyle/KotZ - 2 (Hinckley, CMP)Doctor McCoy/Umbra-Mantis - 3 (Chromeknight, Trekkie99, KotZ)Scotty/Hinckley - 1 (Tariq j)Spock/Trekkie99 - 2 (Khscarymovie4, jimmynick, Umbra-Mantis) About 20 hours remain in Day One. 5 votes are required to lynch. Ok so we do need 5 to lynch. Thank you oh dear Captain. (though Spock has 3 votes at the moment). And now we are at 4 votes.
KotZ Posted July 18, 2019 Posted July 18, 2019 6 minutes ago, CMP said: Comments like these give the impression that suspicion and reasoning is secondary to getting a lynch. That's a really bad color if you're a townie. If. I'm going to Unvote: Lieutenant Kyle/KotZ and Vote: Spock/Trekkie99. But I know who to look at next if Spock comes up scum. Kyle. Kyle who hasn't shown up since he's started being seriously looked at. Drop in and come say hi when you have a chance. I think you're just trying to find an easy target on me in case Spock comes up scum. And if he doesn't? You'll come after me anyway. Scotty's vote was definitely a joke vote so I'm not placing much thought to it, but you seem to have an axe to grind.
Trekkie99 Posted July 18, 2019 Posted July 18, 2019 2 minutes ago, CMP said: Comments like these give the impression that suspicion and reasoning is secondary to getting a lynch. That's a really bad color if you're a townie. It's day one, it's been 24 hours, and we need a lynch otherwise a townie will die. Actual solid suspicion and reasoning do not exist this early in the game.
Khscarymovie4 Posted July 18, 2019 Posted July 18, 2019 6 minutes ago, Trekkie99 said: Actual solid suspicion and reasoning do not exist this early in the game. uh... I think lots of us have given some sort of reasoning lately and even some on the McCoy vote gave reasoning. So that is just completely untrue.
Trekkie99 Posted July 18, 2019 Posted July 18, 2019 2 minutes ago, Khscarymovie4 said: Why McCoy? The point I think Chekov and I are trying to make is that if you were only looking to hop on a lynch why did you choose McCoy over Kyle? Because I find the existing reasons for the votes for Kyle lacking. Everyone keeps saying "why not Kyle", but doesn't give any reason why I should vote for Kyle. If you think I should vote for Kyle then why not vote for him yourself? 6 minutes ago, Khscarymovie4 said: Especially considering now there are votes against quite a few people and you have chosen to stay behind McCoy with no reasoning. No there are not. There's Kyle, McCoy, and myself. And then there's one vote for Hinckley which I like the reasoning for but it's a small wagon which might not gain enough speed in time.
Umbra-Manis Posted July 18, 2019 Posted July 18, 2019 9 minutes ago, Khscarymovie4 said: I agree with these votes but the fact that Spock went from 0 to 3 votes in 30 minutes alarms me a bit. McCoy's vote is especially bandwagonish. The section I made bold shows him calling out Spock for bandwagoning just to do it himself. Or it could be construed as a retaliatory vote to see if he has any real explanation. Either way, all he's done since is try to point the "unhelpful sign" at Hinckley 27 minutes ago, Trekkie99 said: Here's Hinckley's. Not much IMO.
Bob Posted July 18, 2019 Author Posted July 18, 2019 "Aye sirs, I've been trying my hardest to get the warp drive online. I think I can get the transporters operational at the end of every game day, whatever that is." "Ah, perfect." Kirk said. "We can beam security and medical officers up here to handle the situation." ..... "Or." Kirk started. "We can beam someone into the brig at the end of every game day and have security check them out." "Mr. Spock, are you alright?" Scott asked. "I have this smile that won't go away." --- Vote Count: Lieutenant Kyle/KotZ - 1 (Hinckley)Doctor McCoy/Umbra-Mantis - 3 (Chromeknight, Trekkie99, KotZ)Scotty/Hinckley - 1 (Tariq j)Spock/Trekkie99 - 4 (Khscarymovie4, jimmynick, Umbra-Mantis, CMP) Less than 20 hours remain in Day One. 5 votes are required to lynch.
Trekkie99 Posted July 18, 2019 Posted July 18, 2019 3 minutes ago, Khscarymovie4 said: uh... I think lots of us have given some sort of reasoning lately and even some on the McCoy vote gave reasoning. So that is just completely untrue. Yes but with very little to go on especially Kyle's which as you can see started with very crappy reasoning hence why I dislike it. 2 minutes ago, Umbra-Manis said: Either way, all he's done since is try to point the "unhelpful sign" at Hinckley What and your saying it is? 1 minute ago, Trekkie99 said: Yes but with very little to go on especially Kyle's which as you can see started with very crappy reasoning hence why I dislike it. And like my own first vote, the reasoning was crappy, which is why when something better came up I changed my vote.
CMP Posted July 18, 2019 Posted July 18, 2019 22 minutes ago, KotZ said: I think you're just trying to find an easy target on me in case Spock comes up scum. And if he doesn't? You'll come after me anyway. Scotty's vote was definitely a joke vote so I'm not placing much thought to it, but you seem to have an axe to grind. Uh, yeah. I voted for you. 3 hours ago, CMP said: Okay, this is pretty much word-for-word what you said earlier, but are you going to respond the explanation behind his logic, or did you skip that part to post more fluff? to the* 2 hours ago, CMP said: I know we need a lynch, and we have to start somewhere, but I don't like how easily this particular bandwagon is moving along based on "McCoy said lynching based on most votes would benefit scum". Kyle said it's suspicious, but waited until Uhura placed the vote to put his money where his mouth is (instead of his constant stream of fluff. Which doesn't constitute activity. Kyle. ) Also, all of this. I get that you want a lynch here Spock, but that doesn't mean you get to not think about your reasoning for more than five seconds. I'm going to Vote: Lieutenant Kyle (KotZ) for the time being, though. But I'd be careful jumping to people's defense this early, Spock. I guess you can consider that an axe to grind? You haven't even acknowledged any of this. The most defense that came about as a result of this wasn't even from you, it was from Spock. You haven't given me a reason not to look at you and have my suspicions. I suspect your lukewarm vote on McCoy, I suspect your constant fluff, and I suspect that you seem content to have let Spock speak for you. Don't roll over and cry tunnel vision, tell me why I'm wrong.
Khscarymovie4 Posted July 18, 2019 Posted July 18, 2019 32 minutes ago, Trekkie99 said: Because I find the existing reasons for the votes for Kyle lacking. Everyone keeps saying "why not Kyle", but doesn't give any reason why I should vote for Kyle. If you think I should vote for Kyle then why not vote for him yourself? I'm not saying that I find Kyle suspicious or that you should either. I'm asking if you were going to vote for somebody just to get a lynch why did you choose McCoy over Kyle? But it seems you thought the reasons for the votes were silly. I guess that's a fair point but I still have not heard a decent reason for your vote against McCoy even though you seem to have some in your head. Making your vote just as silly. 38 minutes ago, Trekkie99 said: No there are not. There's Kyle, McCoy, and myself. And then there's one vote for Hinckley which I like the reasoning for but it's a small wagon which might not gain enough speed in time. I think that's a fair amount of people. 38 minutes ago, Bob said: "Ah, perfect." Kirk said. "We can beam security and medical officers up here to handle the situation." Who nees to beam up more medical officers when you have the best nurse in the galaxy on board?
Hinckley Posted July 18, 2019 Posted July 18, 2019 1 hour ago, Trekkie99 said: Here's Hinckley's. Not much IMO. Your face is not much. 1 hour ago, KotZ said: Scotty's vote was definitely a joke vote so I'm not placing much thought to it, but you seem to have an axe to grind. I've explained twice that I delivered it in a joking and lighthearted manner but your reaction to my joke is my strongest Scum read. I wish people would stop explaining it away as a joke. It's Day One. We can't be sure of anything. I was being lighthearted about my vote since we were still kind of in jokey phase but there wasn't going to be a "voting is now open" that we're used to. You being defensive about the joke I made is why I voted for you. Plus you're a red shirt. No! That's a joke. Shame on me. 57 minutes ago, Trekkie99 said: And then there's one vote for Hinckley which I like the reasoning for but it's a small wagon which might not gain enough speed in time. Oh? You think the wagon on me should gain momentum up to a lynch? Please expound upon this. I'm curious what you find convincing about Sulu's vote on me? @Trekkie99
Trekkie99 Posted July 18, 2019 Posted July 18, 2019 9 minutes ago, Hinckley said: Your face is not much. 10 minutes ago, Hinckley said: Oh? You think the wagon on me should gain momentum up to a lynch? Please expound upon this. I'm curious what you find convincing about Sulu's vote on me? @Trekkie99 Because like both you have said, it was a joke vote which contained a small amount of suspicion. Do you still have your suspicion(s) and have they grown? Because otherwise your not helping us achieve a lynch.
Tariq j Posted July 18, 2019 Posted July 18, 2019 4 hours ago, Trekkie99 said: Because I can't trust everyone else join my wagon in time to achieve a lynch so I moved over to the next best (if not thee best at the moment) wagon. So you were basically playing the field so to speak. Rather than give a clear viewpoint you've thrown your suspicions around a bit here. You vote for Ensign, then you vote for Mcoy, then you state why scott has been unhelpful. 4 hours ago, Hinckley said: That's a joke, Sulu. The point is to vote for who you think is Scummy, not who think is too jokey. And I should vote for you for not having your character name in your signature and making me open a new window to find out who you are playing. That's a joke, too. Good thing you don't get a double vote. I'm sorry. That'll be fixed pronto. Based on his behaviour I'm going to unvote: Hinckley (Commander Scott) vote: Trekkie99 (Commander Spock)
Hinckley Posted July 18, 2019 Posted July 18, 2019 1 hour ago, Trekkie99 said: Because like both you have said, it was a joke vote which contained a small amount of suspicion. Do you still have your suspicion(s) and have they grown? Because otherwise your not helping us achieve a lynch. Well, how about I help like this? Unvote: Lieutenant Red Shirt Kyle Vote: Commander Spock (Trekkie99) Because, and this is not a joke, while your fluff and jokes seem par for the course for your gameplay, your behavior seems Scummy this time. You repeatedly mention looking at different wagons as if that's the way to hunt Scum. You're wagon-shopping like you have the knowledge of who is Town and who is Scum. That is not Town perspective. Maybe you're Town or Starfleet or whatever, but if all we have is our vote, you vocally attempting to get "on a wagon" that will end in a lynch is not pro–Starfleet, it's pro–Romulan.
Recommended Posts