KotZ Posted June 19, 2019 Posted June 19, 2019 6 minutes ago, Sandy said: I already admitted that I have nothing much to contribute. I'm not one to deeply analyze any half a word someone utters, since I know they're meaningless until we start getting some night action results. I mean, I kind of agree but night action results aren't really going to come forward Day 2 most likely. We're essentially in a holding pattern. ... do creatures fly in holding patterns?
Tariq j Posted June 19, 2019 Posted June 19, 2019 4 hours ago, Bob said: I sincerely hope that Chromeknight was not revealing himself as the detective with that comment just because I made some fluff day one comment about us needing to be detectives. If Chromeknight wanted to connect with me somehow as the detective, wouldn't it have made more sense for him to have done it through PM? We can PM in this game, right? Other people seem to be doing it, so I'd assume so. I assumed he was talking about deceives because he was role playing as his character as oppose to soft claiming. But I could be wrong. I really don’t know at this stage. 4 hours ago, Bob said: To be completely honest, I'm not sure what people expected on Day One. I picked quite possibly the weirdest reason to vote for someone because I had absolutely nothing else to go on. Why he then followed me on that lynch is beyond me. He claimed that he wanted to "achieve a lynch", yet he voted for someone that had only one vote on them with a stupid reason for it and didn't give any reason for why he felt that it was a good idea. I can’t understand why he would jump off an existing bandwagon and then try to start a new one. Aside from spreading out the voting.
Hinckley Posted June 19, 2019 Posted June 19, 2019 45 minutes ago, Sandy said: I do find it interesting that certain people are trying to find a literal reason for the scum to kill Daphne, when all it really takes to get killed is to be a semi-active player. Please, tell us more about why the Scum killed Daphne. Sounds like you've got a pretty good idea about what they might have been thinking.
Khscarymovie4 Posted June 19, 2019 Posted June 19, 2019 11 hours ago, Trekkie99 said: Again I didn't realize what time it was, and seeing it had been quiet for awhile, I decided to try to get some discussion going. And while I'll admit that the fact that there were ten players escaped me while making that post, I don't think remembering would have changed my opinion then nor does it now. Pretty sure there have been twelve player games where a lack of players didn't warrant no day one lynch. Voting with the intent to lynch shows something vs joke votes which show nothing when everyone is doing it. Whether or not you stick with a vote in search of a lynch is up to one's personal choice. As Chromeknight said, "vote early, vote often". While I can't really agree with the outcome I thank you for giving us all your reasoning. 9 hours ago, Bob said: I sincerely hope that Chromeknight was not revealing himself as the detective with that comment just because I made some fluff day one comment about us needing to be detectives. If Chromeknight wanted to connect with me somehow as the detective, wouldn't it have made more sense for him to have done it through PM? We can PM in this game, right? Other people seem to be doing it, so I'd assume so. To be completely honest, I'm not sure what people expected on Day One. I picked quite possibly the weirdest reason to vote for someone because I had absolutely nothing else to go on. Why he then followed me on that lynch is beyond me. He claimed that he wanted to "achieve a lynch", yet he voted for someone that had only one vote on them with a stupid reason for it and didn't give any reason for why he felt that it was a good idea. Yesterday was rather useless. Nothing of consequence happened which isn't good for Day One. With only ten people, perhaps it was a good thing that we didn't lynch anybody. I know in the past I'm a proponent of a Day One lynch, so perhaps that's hypocritical. Daphne voted for Tyrion yesterday, perhaps that's something to look into? Chromeknight revealing a role on day 1 feels far fetched to me. I guess its possible he was the detective but I seriously doubt he would reveal something like that for no purpose what so ever. I think we may be looking too much into a day 1 comment. Also yes, PM'ing is allowed. I'm surprised Tyrion has not sent you some wine and memes. 5 hours ago, Sandy said: I already admitted that I have nothing much to contribute. I'm not one to deeply analyze any half a word someone utters, since I know they're meaningless until we start getting some night action results. I do find it interesting that certain people are trying to find a literal reason for the scum to kill Daphne, when all it really takes to get killed is to be a semi-active player. I'm not sure what you expected to happen. We've all been in this situation before, there's no rookies blurting out their roles in public or getting into fights with each other. Of course it would be easy if there were people like that among us, but we didn't come here to have it easy, did we? I do agree about over analyzing fluff is not the best strategy, but it will probably be awhile before we start getting night actions results. Do you really want to stand around and let the scum take more of us before deciding now is a good time to start solving the problem?
Kintobor Posted June 20, 2019 Author Posted June 20, 2019 "Voting is now open! With 9 players, it takes 5 votes to secure a lynch."Current Votes: Tauriel (Hinckley): 2 votes (penalty!, penalty!) Newt (KotZ): 2 votes (penalty!, penalty!) 48 hours remain in the day.
Trekkie99 Posted June 20, 2019 Posted June 20, 2019 Vote: Raphael (Sir Stig) Do be so kind my good man as to at least give us a holler to let us know your alive. 1 hour ago, jimmynick said: Vote: Kylo Ren (Sandy) One might not condone voting without giving a reason, but I feel it's unnecessary in this particular case. Here's to you.
KotZ Posted June 20, 2019 Posted June 20, 2019 36 minutes ago, Trekkie99 said: One might not condone voting without giving a reason, but I feel it's unnecessary in this particular case. Here's to you. Eh, I suggest giving one in case. Hopefully a reason is given later.
Hinckley Posted June 20, 2019 Posted June 20, 2019 I never said Chromeknight softclaimed, nor would I ever suggest he would be stupid. What I'm saying is the Scum may have flown off their handles about him responding to the word detective. I've found Trekkie's behavior weird, I think Sandy always plays Scummy, and yes that's metagaming but the odd way Bob got to saying "detective" in the first place, a weird and almost forced list of three in order to say the word of a known Mafia role leads me to suspect him the most. Maybe that's dumb, so maybe I'm dumb. Vote: Egon Spangler (Bob)
Sandy Posted June 20, 2019 Posted June 20, 2019 9 hours ago, Hinckley said: Please, tell us more about why the Scum killed Daphne. Sounds like you've got a pretty good idea about what they might have been thinking. Haha, you're funny. 4 hours ago, Khscarymovie4 said: I do agree about over analyzing fluff is not the best strategy, but it will probably be awhile before we start getting night actions results. Do you really want to stand around and let the scum take more of us before deciding now is a good time to start solving the problem? I didn't say anything about not doing anything. I was merely answering to our elven friend who claimed I was speaking without saying anything. If I had remained silent, she still would've said I ping scummy. Tauriel is an aggressive player, with her it's damned if you do (speak) and damned if you don't (speak). So, I'm not going to hush hush, darling! Vote: Hinckley (Tauriel)
jimmynick Posted June 20, 2019 Posted June 20, 2019 I find Sandy's attitude anti-town, and saying she hopes Daphne wasn't the cop smacks almost of congratulating scum for Chromeknight's death. To reiterate for Karie's benefit: Vote: Kylo Ren (Sandy) I also find it interesting that Tyrion has tacitly endorsed my vote while instead giving a token prod to a silent cosplayer, and curious also that Tauriel has contrived to vote for Bob over the use of a single word. I mean, Tauriel could have voted for me because I used phrase "vigilante mob business", but no dice. It seems like Tyrion and Tauriel are at arm's length, pointing a great big finger but not doing anything about it.
Sandy Posted June 20, 2019 Posted June 20, 2019 37 minutes ago, jimmynick said: I find Sandy's attitude anti-town, and saying she hopes Daphne wasn't the cop smacks almost of congratulating scum for Chromeknight's death. You can vote me, sure, but I really don't understand what you're saying. If I say I hope Daphne wasn't the cop (since people pointed out she's a detective character and all), that means I'm congratulating the scum... What?!
Hinckley Posted June 20, 2019 Posted June 20, 2019 24 minutes ago, Sandy said: If I say I hope Daphne wasn't the cop (since people pointed out she's a detective character and all), that means I'm congratulating the scum... What?! I just realized that Daphne meant she's a detective in cosplay. Still, and again, it wasn't her reaction I was worried about. It was the weird fishing expedition from Bobbo that pinged me. And as far as you being damned if you speak and damned if you don't... what? First of all, I'd be much happier if you didn't speak, because you never say anything. Your Town game is always Scummy, but voting for someone because "You're damned if you speak and damned if you don't..." how would that make me Scum exactly? Annoying you doesn't make someone Scummy. Voldemort or Sirius Black or whoever the hell Sandy is, because his signature still says Admiral Piett, is pinging me twice today now. First, she gives us reasoning for why the Scum killed Daphne, now she's placed a vote because...she doesn't like my questions? Not that I'm Scummy, but that my behavior is obnoxious. Doesn't seem pro-Town...however, I've gotten him lynched in the past for similar behavior and he's turned up Town. 1 hour ago, Sandy said: Tauriel is an aggressive player, with her it's damned if you do (speak) and damned if you don't (speak). So, I'm not going to hush hush, darling! Vote: Hinckley (Tauriel) I usually find the more aggressive players Scummy, too. Wait, no I don't. And what have I done that's so "aggressive?" Questioned you? Gee, sorry I'm such a tyrant. That's more sarcasm, in case you wondered.
Khscarymovie4 Posted June 20, 2019 Posted June 20, 2019 5 hours ago, jimmynick said: Vote: Kylo Ren (Sandy) Yes, lets all just vote without reasons. Its only day 2! 4 hours ago, Trekkie99 said: Vote: Raphael (Sir Stig) Do be so kind my good man as to at least give us a holler to let us know your alive. One might not condone voting without giving a reason, but I feel it's unnecessary in this particular case. Here's to you. Yeah where is our smell ninja friend? Also why do you condone Black Canary's vote? Do you not want valid reason for anything anyone does? 2 hours ago, Sandy said: Haha, you're funny. I didn't say anything about not doing anything. I was merely answering to our elven friend who claimed I was speaking without saying anything. If I had remained silent, she still would've said I ping scummy. Tauriel is an aggressive player, with her it's damned if you do (speak) and damned if you don't (speak). So, I'm not going to hush hush, darling! Vote: Hinckley (Tauriel) Well the way you said it it seems as if you were purposely going to not analyze very much until the night actions rolled in, which would be doing very little for quite awhile. 2 hours ago, jimmynick said: I find Sandy's attitude anti-town, and saying she hopes Daphne wasn't the cop smacks almost of congratulating scum for Chromeknight's death. To reiterate for Karie's benefit: Vote: Kylo Ren (Sandy) I also find it interesting that Tyrion has tacitly endorsed my vote while instead giving a token prod to a silent cosplayer, and curious also that Tauriel has contrived to vote for Bob over the use of a single word. I mean, Tauriel could have voted for me because I used phrase "vigilante mob business", but no dice. It seems like Tyrion and Tauriel are at arm's length, pointing a great big finger but not doing anything about it. Anit-town, well that's very specific. I think voting with little reasoning or no reasoning to be very anti-town. Could you please provide some reasons of your own as to why you think Mr. Ren is anti-town? I think Black Cannery is acting a bit scary as of late. The first vote with no reasoning was odd but then she gives a reason saying nothing other then Ren is anti-town and he congratulating the scum. At the very least I want a better excuse for a vote. Tyrion's acceptance of the first vote is also super odd. This is not day 1 anymore, simply voting and accepting votes for nothing should not fly on such a day. Vote: Black Canary (jimmynick)
Trekkie99 Posted June 20, 2019 Posted June 20, 2019 7 hours ago, Sandy said: Tauriel is an aggressive player, with her it's damned if you do (speak) and damned if you don't (speak). So, I'm not going to hush hush, darling! Nani? You being hush hush is why I'm all for jimmynick's vote vote. (The "it's unnecessary to give a reason for your vote for sandy" was just a joke.)
Trekkie99 Posted June 20, 2019 Posted June 20, 2019 8 hours ago, KotZ said: Eh, I suggest giving one in case. Hopefully a reason is given later. Me's a-joking! 7 hours ago, jimmynick said: I find Sandy's attitude anti-town 7 hours ago, jimmynick said: saying she hopes Daphne wasn't the cop smacks almost of congratulating scum for Chromeknight's death. 7 hours ago, jimmynick said: I also find it interesting that Tyrion has tacitly endorsed my vote while instead giving a token prod to a silent cosplayer I'm predicting Sandy stocks will skyrocket with their recent activity, and I'm thinking on investing. 6 hours ago, Sandy said: If I say I hope Daphne wasn't the cop (since people pointed out she's a detective character and all), that means I'm congratulating the scum... What?! Yeah that was a weird thing to say. 6 hours ago, Hinckley said: Doesn't seem pro-Town...however, I've gotten him lynched in the past for similar behavior and he's turned up Town. Hmm. To lynch or not to lynch?
Trekkie99 Posted June 20, 2019 Posted June 20, 2019 5 hours ago, Khscarymovie4 said: I think Black Cannery is acting a bit scary as of late. (1) The first vote with no reasoning was odd (2) but then she gives a reason saying nothing other then Ren is anti-town (3) and he's congratulating the scum. (1) I mean it is odd, but maybe it was somewhat of a joke saying the vote was self explanatory? That's how I viewed it at first anyway. (2) While not a very detailed reason, I think it pretty much sums up Sandy's behavior. (3) IDK
Tariq j Posted June 20, 2019 Posted June 20, 2019 Anti Town is an interesting choice of phrase. Since it implies scum or third party. The latter of which we have no reason to believe exists as of yet. Note he also voted before voting had even began. He was clearly eager to get the vote in despite not giving any initial reasoning. Vote: Black Canary (jimmynick) 11 hours ago, Trekkie99 said: Vote: Raphael (Sir Stig) Do be so kind my good man as to at least give us a holler to let us know your alive. I would also like to hear from the green turtle.
Sandy Posted June 20, 2019 Posted June 20, 2019 8 hours ago, Hinckley said: Voldemort or Sirius Black or whoever the hell Sandy is, because his signature still says Admiral Piett, is pinging me twice today now. First, she gives us reasoning for why the Scum killed Daphne, now she's placed a vote because...she doesn't like my questions? Not that I'm Scummy, but that my behavior is obnoxious. Doesn't seem pro-Town...however, I've gotten him lynched in the past for similar behavior and he's turned up Town. I usually find the more aggressive players Scummy, too. Wait, no I don't. And what have I done that's so "aggressive?" Questioned you? Gee, sorry I'm such a tyrant. That's more sarcasm, in case you wondered. (Sorry, I'm browsing on mobile and signatures are disabled here, so I can neither see or edit my signature. ) With aggressive I meant pushy, and time has shown it's a perfect place for the scum to hide. Rarely do people vote out those who are pushing and prodding others since they seem to be contributing to the town's cause - but of course scum know who to push and who to not.
Hinckley Posted June 20, 2019 Posted June 20, 2019 43 minutes ago, Sandy said: With aggressive I meant pushy, and time has shown it's a perfect place for the scum to hide. Rarely do people vote out those who are pushing and prodding others since they seem to be contributing to the town's cause - but of course scum know who to push and who to not. Ah, I see. You think I'm pulling a "Scubacarrot."
KotZ Posted June 20, 2019 Posted June 20, 2019 Vote: Kylo Ren (Sandy) A whole lot has been said, but not of much substance. Although that could be said for a lot of us today.
Sir Stig Posted June 20, 2019 Posted June 20, 2019 What?! My first gut feeling was right the whole time? No, wait, @Trekkie99 are you digging a hole for your self? ATM I am very capable of calling bullsihaize 3 hours ago, Trekkie99 said: (1) I mean it is odd, but maybe it was somewhat of a joke saying the vote was self explanatory? That's how I viewed it at first anyway. (2) While not a very detailed reason, I think it pretty much sums up Sandy's behavior. (3) IDK Anyone else, call me out whenever, but please be specific on what your issues are.Vote: Tyrion Lannister (Trekkie99)
Trekkie99 Posted June 20, 2019 Posted June 20, 2019 2 minutes ago, Sir Stig said: What?! My first gut feeling was right the whole time? No, wait, @Trekkie99 are you digging a hole for your self? ATM I am very capable of calling bullsihaize Anyone else, call me out whenever, but please be specific on what your issues are.Vote: Tyrion Lannister (Trekkie99) What? 1 hour ago, Sandy said: With aggressive I meant pushy, and time has shown it's a perfect place for the scum to hide. Rarely do people vote out those who are pushing and prodding others since they seem to be contributing to the town's cause - but of course scum know who to push and who to not. IMO, despite it seeming like a great hiding spot, scum don't do this. Unless scum just conveniently started doing this now which would mean Hinckley is scum and your town, and not the other way around lol. I was planning on voting for Sandy, but now that the Stig Fig has shown up and given us this beautiful brain fart, I'ma keep my vote on our green f(r)iend.
Trekkie99 Posted June 20, 2019 Posted June 20, 2019 Heh. HAM SANDWICH!!!? More like... BRAIN FART!!! XD 38 minutes ago, KotZ said: A whole lot has been said, but not of much substance. Although that could be said for a lot of us today. I in no way relate to that. Nope. No way. Nah. Nuh-uh.
Sandy Posted June 20, 2019 Posted June 20, 2019 51 minutes ago, Trekkie99 said: IMO, despite it seeming like a great hiding spot, scum don't do this. Unless scum just conveniently started doing this now which would mean Hinckley is scum and your town, and not the other way around lol. Trust me, it's been done plenty before. I know I'm town, and I know I need to vote someone. I am ready to change my vote if a more convincing case is presented, though. I'm not known to hold back a lynch either.
Recommended Posts