Catalina Kittywhisker
-
Posts
29 -
Joined
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Gallery
Everything posted by Catalina Kittywhisker
-
Well, he viewed my PM with him after I accused him in the thread, so it's pretty obvious he checked in here. I think he's just dodging the accusations at this point so you're right, we probably won't get a defense from him.
-
Wong told someone else that he was only in contact with three people, me being one of them. This person also told me that Wong told him that those three people claimed Vanilla to Wong, which is a lie. When I asked Wong who the third person he contacted was he said it was Krup, but apparently he never mentioned contacting Krup to anyone else nor did he mention to anyone else that Krup claimed Vanilla. When I told Wong about the third person he said he also was in contact with him but he never mentioned him to me at first. By the way, I'm not revealing who these people are because I'm not sure if they'd want me to. So to sum it up, he not only lied about three people claiming Vanilla to him but he also lied about him being in contact with Krup. Well, if he was in contact with Krup then he still lied, because he told me he was and he told someone else he wasn't.
-
Because he already has the most votes and there's nothing that can change that. I guess I will though, but do note that I am still suspicious of Godric. Unvote: Godric Goaty-Blather Vote: Wong Wang I now agree with the people who want to go after Krup if Wong flips Scum, which I'm sure he will.
-
Yeah, sorry, I wasn't too clear when I first posted. The second part to it's there now.
-
Alright everyone, I'm going to apologize now for unvoting Wong. I feel like a complete idiot, but he's definitely scum. He's been lying via potato message to people about who he's contacted. He's also been lying about certain people claiming Vanilla Townie to him (who the hell would claim to him anyway?). It's pointless for me to change my vote because there's no way anyone else will be lynched at this point and I still find Godric suspicious. So just for the record, he told me he contacted Krup while he told others he didn't. The other person he contacted confirmed that Wong contacted him so this means he was lying about Krup and him being in contact. So I guess this increases the chances of Krup being scum for tomorrow, too.
-
Honestly, even though I said we could get information from lynching Wong, I have to say that I'd love to turn around the vote. But I don't think it's possible at this point, there's not enough time and I don't think people will be convinced to change their votes. Other people that I think have been acting more scummy than Wong are mainly Godric and Firuz. Firuz, like I said before, has mainly only been talking when asked too and Godric seems like he knows that Wong is Town but doesn't want to say it (and when he does say it he says that he should just be lynched because of the curse). Sugarbottom is also suspicious to me because she always makes these big accusations towards Wong and then at the end of most of them she says that she's not saying he's scum. And then there's her changing opinion on Wong's affiliation too. Like I said though, I'd love to turn the vote around but I don't think we can. But it's worth a try. Unvote: Wong Wang Vote: Godric Goaty-Blather
-
Way to go over every single possibility. How about you answer this: What do you think Wong is? And no, I don't want you to explain your vote for him because of his role. What do you really think he is, because you seem to be avoiding that question.
-
After giving it some thought, I think I'm going to keep my vote on Wong because it will give us lots of new information for tomorrow. I think it'd be better to lynch him and actually get new leads rather than lynch someone else and have almost no new info. Although, like I said before, I still find Firuz, Godric, and Sugarbottom to be very odd. At least Sugarbottom's helping and expressing her opinion though, unlike Godric and Firuz who seem to only speak when asked to.
-
I agree that her aggression makes her seem more Townie. Although while we're on the subject of "I told you so" votes, she did unvote Snarky towards the end yesterday and then she was hesitant to vote off Wong today. And the more and more people are saying that they think Wong is Penis but are still voting him makes me think that they know more than others do. It's making me regret my vote for Wong even though he does still appear scummy to me.
-
And Twatty voted for Firuz Foxtail.
-
Purplonia makes a good point. If you think he's Town then why vote for him? We've already lost 3 Penises and this would just worsen the blow. Also, this isn't the only post you mentioned Wong being Town. You've said in your posts before that you believe Wong to be Town and yet you still end up voting for him. I, on the other hand, do see Wong as scummy because of the evidence people like Sugarbottom have presented. It seems like people like her have been onto Wong since yesterday, so they've been consistent with their posts, unlike you. Also, Firuz is another person that hasn't talked a lot. The only couple times he posted today was when I questioned him. I'm still voting for Wong, but I think Godric and Firuz also come off as really scummy. Vote: Wong Wang
-
It seems convenient that you thought he was Town in the night after he'd been lynched.
-
Can you tell us why they aren't on your radar anymore? And I know you weren't the only one who responded like that, and I think out of the list of people you posted Godric is another that comes off as sort of unhelpful. And there was also his random vote for Sugarbottom yesterday.
-
Someone that I noticed that didn't do much yesterday was Firuz Foxtail. Next to being inactive, he had odd, inconsistent posts. Like this one, for example: He mentions the idea of voting off Flabflom, who was killed last night and many people didn't assume to be scum yesterday. It seems like he was just following Snarky here with the whole idea of going against Flamflom but after no one else went through with that idea he dropped it. And he dropped his suspicions of Godric, too. Or he hasn't mentioned them again at least. This post is also odd to me. I know he was forced to vote for either Snarky or Wong, he seems to have voted for Snarky and never again mention his other suspicions. Also, he just popped in, put in his vote, and left. And we still haven't heard from him since then.
-
I think it would be best if you were more expressive with these kinds of thoughts. Even if you're Town we can still get lots of new information if you post who you specifically suspect. This post does come off sort of scummy to me though because of how you're trying to hide your thoughts here.
-
Eh, it works in strange ways as it is...
-
Also, we'll get something out of lynching either Wong or Snarky. If we lynch Wong and he comes up Town, which I think he might at this point, we can see who bandwagoned against him. If we vote off Snarky and he's scum we can look at who tried to vote off Wong instead. And the same goes for Wong being scum and Snarky being Town.
-
I was suspicious of him earlier, and I don't think his attitude has helped him at all. Snarky hasn't really been doing the best job in finding the Odor Eaters or posting his opinions, but then again neither has Wong Wang. But Wang's claim seems true and he'd be stupid as scum to claim it. Especially because it's Day 1. So I'll Vote: Snarky Snickerpuss
-
I'm having second thoughts about him being scum, that's why. I know what you're saying about scum making lazy defenses, but Krup's come off to me as incredibly lazy, dumfounded statements that I don't think any scum would make. When did I say I wanted Flabflom lynched? I questioned Snarky for voting for Flabflom after he made the mistake of editing his post, not Flabflom. Anyway, I'm "deflecting the attention" off of Krup because I don't seem him as scummy as I did before. I'm not going to vote for someone who I think may not be scum. If you're so certain that Krup is scum, then great, keep your vote to him, but I don't think he is. The bandwagon against him is growing anyway, and if he's lynched I'll still be curious to see what he comes up as.
-
No, I'm not unvoting him because of him acting apologetic. I'm unvoting him because he didn't seem to put up a defense that seemed like it would have been made by the scum. It seemed sort of lazy to me, and I think that the scum would try harder to make more perfected defenses. I'm not voting for Snarky yet because I don't think that there's enough evidence to do so, as opposed to Krup who I thought had enough at the time of my vote. And who said I was leaving my suspicion towards Snarky in thin air? I'm waiting for a response, and if I think it's scummy then I'll have the right amount of evidence against him that I think is worth to give him a vote.
-
After talking to Krup a little in private, I have to say that I'm feeling less and less inclined to vote for him. His suspicions make no sense and he doesn't seem to be pushing for me not to vote for him like a scum would usually do. I'm thinking he's just a completely confused Townie. I think a scum would make their defense look more perfect and I'm starting to think he contacted so many people so early because he was just a confused Townie and didn't know any better. Like others have said, contacting people so early just seems too strange for an Odor Eater to do. Unvote: Durmudgelous Krup I still think it would be great if Snarky could respond to my comment about his vote for Flabflom whenever he gets back.
-
While I think that it was pretty stupid of Flabflom to edit his post, I don't think this makes him worth a vote. I do agree it doesn't make him as valuable of a member to our cause, but does a mistake like that make him worth a vote? I don't think it does, and I think we've seen more suspicious people and activity than Flabflom's post editing. Also, Snarky, the way you voted for Flabflom, to me at least, made it seem like you were assuming he was a member of The Order of the Penis. It just seemed like you were thinking he was more unhelpful than scummy. And, like I said, there has been some scummy activity that is better to branch off than the unhelpfulness.... for now, at least. I think we could definitely look into unhelpful people later, but I don't think it would be the best lynch for day 1.
-
I agree. It almost seemed like he gave up here too. That along with him being jumpy all the time with his defenses is pushing me to vote for him. Even then, I still find him odd for accusing of that. I think he's just pulling at straws at this point. First he comes up with a poor, jumpy defense, and then he moves on to push the attention onto someone that he contacted via PM. I think I'll vote for Krup. Vote: Durmudgelous Krup
-
It is pretty quiet, especially considering it's day 1. And here I thought you all were social people. I believe the only person that hasn't spoken up yet is Dillpickle Catterweed, correct? Hopefully he'll show up soon along with more conversations from people.
-
To me, it seems like a great opportunity for Odor Eaters to try to act as leaders when members of the Order of the Penis, or even other Odor Eaters, are supposedly goofing off. Telling people to stop goofing off and trying to act like a leader like that is, in my opinion, a great way to seem helpful but not really be helpful.