I'd give the set a 3 1/2 out of 5. It needed 1 more Imperial to get a 4.
A bigger basplate would have been nice as it appears to hard to fit all the minifigs on the island.
Thanks for this great review
Your ship looks good, it has a strong resemblance of the Black Seas Barracuda.
Maybe you could remove the lifeboat thats sitting on the top of the bridge, no offence but it looks rather silly up there.
Good work though!
A very nice ship Sir The deck seems a bit bare though, maybe you should add a row boat or something.
Overall it looks great, the color scheme is reall good.
Edit: I'm really digging the Blackcoats!