Lady K

This is superb! I really love the blue round buildings! The tiles used give such a pleasing and happy feel to them. The tree is fantastic and so is all the different landscaping techniques used. Awesome, fantastic job to both of you!

No problem Mencot. This was my first time as vanilla town, I wasn't sure what to do so I thought reaching out and trusting your miller claim could start town working together. On the same thought, sorry Xenophobic Monoxide for not talikg more to you in PM. When you asked me right away what, if any, roles I had I figured you for scum. I should have talked to you a little more. Oh well, lessons learned for next time.

Thanks for the feedback. Each game I keep trying to improve and do something different. This one I was trying out more PMs to more people, but I was unintentionally quieter in the thread. We did have a three town PM going at one point, which was good. To all the newbies, just keep playing. It's worth it every time.

This is fantastic, thanks for sharing it with us. Aquazone has always been a favorite of mine! Your lore for it is great, it flows nicely. The map is done well. It's so nice to see Aquazone is not forgotten.

Awesome game! Thanks Speedy for hosting a great game. To all my fellow players I look forward to future games with you. This was a fun learning experience and I have definitely learned a lot. Congratulations Captain Settle! Cutcobra and Goliath, you kept me guessing and Stickfig I never really suspected you.

Is it possible the Confererate Officer is supposed to be the opposite of the Union Officer that came in the Lone Ranger Train set? It would make sense.

From the voting patterns I looked at both XM and Brickelodeon voted the same, usually with in one or two votes of each other. The same goes for un voting. Captain Settle voted with the majority but he didn't follow the bandwagon jumping. There for my vote is: Vote: Brickelodeon(Brickelodeon)

I asked a simple non accusatory question and you responded defensively. Admitting your suspicious. Saying I'll need evidence for it to work? Are you suggesting I should look for evidence against you?

Was there any evidence that he is scum? And your not addressing the fact that Mencot listed you as possible scum. Yes he votes with the majority, but I don't see a lot of bandwagoning in his playing style. He is quiet, that's true. However I'm concerned with the fact that a bandwagon is forming against him already. Jluck stated in post#20 above that we have places to look for evidence, not just random accusations. I believe we may have three scum, I also believe that the quiet scum have been removed. Richila was very quiet and low post, Lord Duvors posted more but still nothing of real substance. The remaining scum will be active in town. The godfather, which I believe we have, will be very strong and possibly leading the town. Lord Duvors had no chance of being saved a second time so his scum buddies sacrificed him. Brickelodean, you too are not addressing the fact that Mencot felt you were possible scum. Both you and XM responded by going after Captain Settle instead.

Wow, kinda quiet in here. Thanks Stickfig for posting the voting patterns for us. I'm sure there's some trends we should look at. I'm concerned about a couple of things. First, if we look at the above ratio of town to scum we may very we'll have three scum left instead of just two. And secondly, there is probably a scum godfather out there in amount the townies. Cutcobra, you voted for TheLazyChicken yesterday when everyone else was voting for Lord Duvors. May I ask why you kept your vote on him and never changed it?

Careful what you judge by. Those are just two factors to look at. Also look at voting trends, final vote, number of times switching vote, and helpfulness to town. Also unwillingness to answer questions is something to consider. One scum down, great....losing two townies is very bad. Also we may want to look at how many scum based on the ratio above, if we have more than four that's really bad for town. I trusted Mencot was town, but I was suspicious of Lind Whisperer due to his playing style. Both were town. I've already explained my lower daily post count. If I have something useful I will share it and post.

As for low post count today, I simply haven't had much time.

My reasons to vote for Lord Duvors haven't changed since Day 1. I kept my vote on him then and I will do so now. Vote: Lord Duvors (Lord Duvors)

In my case I haven't had the time today. As for day two, I don't believe in posting a lot of fluff. If I can't add to the conversation usefully, I won't post. I went back over the last two days and looked at posts, voting trends, and suspicions. I hope to add something useful soon. I do have a question for Lind Whisperer. Please clarify your posts #153 and #155 from Day 2 on page 7, I believe. To me both sound very anti-town and scummy.

Well we got one, but lost two. Dave confused me with how he was acting. I'm looking back now over everything the past two days. So far only a couple of things stand out. N

I know that. But we need to trust some one and start working together as a team. Why Dave do you not want us to trust Mencot's miller claim? What do you suggest we do instead? If we keep up the same pattern as now then the scum team can takes us out each day with a townie lynch and a night kill. Vote: Stinky Dave (pirateDave)

True. Except that really it benefits town more than scum. To claim miller right away is common and saves a wasted investigation night one. Also give townie someone to start trusting info to. Jamesn believed and supported the claim and he proved townie with his death. Scum could benefit but really they have other ways of getting townies to turn against each other. A good (bad for us) godfather can get all the town to trust them and turn against each other so more townies are lynched and killed , just look at Red Menece for further evidence of this. A Miller claim isnt need for a scum team succeed.

By sharing info with a trusted townie we can start to build a team effort to get rid of the scum. A miller is a trusted townie, we have to work together on this. Scum know who is who.

Well, I for one am curious about Stickfig and Lind Whisperer both switching their votes after the lynching vote for Jamesn (which was Scaevola) came in?

Well, what a bad way to start the day! Two townies is very bad. We better all look at the previous day and voting patters to do better next time. I'm getting coffee and will look at all this first chance I get.

Am I missing something or was his last post over 24hrs ago?

I agree we need a lynch. Lord Duvors does seem like he has given up. His recent post we better and he does seem more townie. Jamesn is still acting scummy, hasn't given me a good reason not to change my vote to him...and Mostlytechnic is defending him instead of him defending himself. Definite scum buddies those two. I am seriously consider a change in my vote.

Jamsn, do you see what I mean? You being very defensive without giving good reason again. Give me one good reason why I shouldn't switch my vote to you right now? I'm still waiting, and the clock is ticking...........

It's not what you did, but how you did it. Granted I could say reasons related to other games that make up my experience but really for this game against newbies you were very harsh. Yes this is a learning enviroment and attention to the rules and links by our host were not paid attention to by some....but really your responses were scummy. It's no wonder they suspect you and as for me, well, you haven't given a good defense of why we shouldn't think your scummy.

Well this is a better reason for your vote than what you posted previously. Reasons why help others understand you and help you play the game.