simonjedi

It could be any period I don't know how much time passes during the montage. Luke and Leia are conceived in episode 22 so at least 9 months. (she gives birth to the twins like 1/2 hour in real time after order 66.)Unless there is some stupid obscure detail on space pregnancies in a book from 1994 that 'contradicts' that. Best guess is about a year, year and a half max. E: You'd think so, but no. http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Time_travel There is 'force time travelling' which is as stupid as it sounds. http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Flow_walking

Bad Writing Some other things: Nope. He's knighted and there's a montage of Anakin being cool, then the ice planet bit. (WHICH ACTUALLY CONTRADICTS LABYRINTH OF EVIL) '08 CW takes place in the montage. Only Pedantic nerds actually care about this stuff. That annoyed me. '03 Grevious is much better than '08/film Grevious anyway. ... IMO depends what it is. I'm bothered by the conflicting info about the Death Star plans, less so about the imaginary spaceship being introduced one space year earlier in a book instead of the TV show.

Yeah that's mainly it. See the 'Secret history of Star Wars' for more info [Plug] 3P0 is a completely pointless character in the PT, he's just there as fan service really (like Boba fett in AotC) The whole Vader built 3P0 thing was rubbish and really not needed at all. Actually thinking about it, Shimi and Anakin weren't actually mistreated at all when they were slaves. They had a decent house, and enough free time to build a robot (That wouldn't be that helpful) and basically a space F1 car in THEIR BACKYARD! I don't know why the republic didn't free Shimi after Naboo either.

It's because the prequels were badly written and directed, plus most of the cast were acting in a green room talking to poles that were supposed to be something. THe best actors in the PT are Ewan McGregor, because he at least had reference about how to do obi wan('You were the chosen one' was one of the best acted line in the whole thing.) and Ian McDiarmid who was mostly hamming it up and just enjoying it, but the opera scene was really good

Where? I'm sure someone would have picked up on that, although I've heard rumours that the 'real' Cybermen are back this year.

Lucas is so full of shit. Star Wars wasn't originally supposed to be 'The Saga of Anakin' In ANH Vader was just a scary looking imperial officer. He wasn't supposed to be Luke's dad (luke's dad was a separate character.) RotJ is basically 6, 7, 8 and 9 compressed into one movie. There are two many plot holes introduced in the PT to make it sync up right.

Anne Hathaway is smoking and I'm looking forward to seeing her in skin tight leather Not sure about Bane though, i don't think he fits in the 'Nolan Batverse.' I think the penguin would have been better.

This really should have been in the 'Star Wars' topic. I'm honestly surprised this is an actual debate. OT for me by miles. You wouldn't even have the CW if it wasn't for the first film. This is the best post I've ever read. Have you heard/watched the Red Letter Media reviews by the way? He mentions quite a bit about what you say. My personal star wars ranking... OT> '03 CW > Games Kotor series, X-wing/TIE Fighter ect > '08 CW >> PT

What a bunch of tools. I feel sorry for the kid.

Quite a few, Vader in IV wasn't a sith, he was just a Imperial officer/emperors right handman, look how badly he was treated in the film by leia and Tarkin. His name was actually Darth . The Emperor was just a figurehead and the regional governors like Tarkin were the ones runnning everything. The fact that no one believed the jedi/force existed after like 19 years, people like motti (Officer who gets strangled in ANH) would have been like 20ish during the CW so would know SOMETHING. Imagine Football/Soccor being banned suddenly right now. Surely in 20 years you'd remember it wouldn't you, especially if the person who banned it's right handman was a goalkeeper and carried a nike branded football. Don't forget the obvious plotholes (Leia remembering her mother, "from a certain point of view," The fact that a bit of common sense could have foiled palpatines plans. Dying of a broken heart ) But hey, blu-ray news you say? Depending on the film cgi changes i'll pick up the OT. I'll only pick up the PT if either a)I'm forced to, because thats how it's packaged. b) It's a gift or c) It has great bonus stuff.

Oh that episode called 'God, I love this war.' you know the one where Obi wan is running around with a ^_^ face. They do get injured, Anakin almost dies in one episode and Obi wan is pretty beaten up in the Geonosis episodes. It doesn't help the fact that battle droids are useless and not a threat. Ermm... Why? *Cough* Death Star *Cough* One of your main criticisms is that it doesn't include a bit of stupid obscure technobabble that 90% of the audience wouldn't care about. Star Wars Cannon gets written all the time, just check how many people stole the Death Star plans. Hell even the films don't even fit with each other.

Actually I stuck with it, and I'm actually enjoying it. Stealth is hilariously broken.

4 - 15 : No 16+ : Yes, Yes it is. However:

An irrealistic view of a series where there's planet destroying lasers, frogs with laserswords, and a 4 armed robot with breathing problems? :P Which one(s) do you hate? Tartosky CW or 3D CW? Personally i prefer them to 1,2 and 3.

Call this a hunch, but i don't think you like CW (why?) I'm going to guess Blu-ray news.

Sorry for the piracy talk, but this is an important question, because I don't quite get it. I'm not going to pirate games or use my PS3 to play a crappy homemade game of frogger. I'm not going to get my HD wiped because some bastard thinks it's funny?

Quick and dirty

Alpha Protocol isn't really that good, which is a shame, because I like Obsidian (KotOR, Fallout New Vegas) and i really like the rpg elements, the actual gunplay isn't though, and that's 80% of the game.

Yes, how dare we not like the same things as you. I wouldn't exactly say the transformer films (seen first) have an 'interesting story' or 'gripping to watch' but its not THAT bad. It's a decent enough for a 'disconnect your brain and watch giant robots beat the crap out of each other' type film. I have heard from ALMOST EVERYONE that the second one is godawful however.

Real AFOLs remove the glue using their bare hands :P I don't collect the magnets, but its nice to have the info.

Really? What did you put? 'Dear lego. A post on an internet forum told me the set was 24.99 BUT it's listed everywhere else as 35.99. Surely you've labeled it wrong'

This has to be the oddest licence for a company i've ever seen. I don't think many 4 year olds have heard of batman. Thanks for the review however.

This MoC is terrible because the red 1 film model the diameter of the astromech housing was half of what your model is. Furthermore.... :P I like what you did with it, I agree that it has a very 'OLD SKOOL' look to it, and weirdly i like the mis match of colours. It's fits in with the rebels 'used universe/salvaging what they can' theme.