Cadd

Hey, no worries. I didn’t read it personal. Funnily I didn’t pick you, even though time zones should have been a give away.

Thanks for having me. Go Oceanides.

Yeah. We’ve already established I’m pushy and rude. I get stuff wrong. Sue me. Can we get on with the game now instead of complaining the traveller is a jerk but not doing anything about it?

So you don’t have a suggestion for how your paranoid thought bubble could actually be fact. You’re just being unhelpful and sowing discord?

Because I’m not lynching the traveller. Yet. Who knows who the fish Luxxon is voting for. He hasn’t even spoken today. You say you’ve been in contact with him. Who knows? but the traveller is non town the fact that they’re non grogon doesn’t matter, especially if, as Eeyara suggests, they’re laughing and not working in our interests. Obviously if they converted there is. my question was about HOW? theres no mention of conversion as a power in night zero set up. so it has to be a scroll right? And we know the what three of the fours scrolls do. so HOW could there be a conversion? Got a suggestion for that? if the traveller isn’t helping town, if you really think that, vote them.

Zandder? What facts do I know about him? What facts do you know? or are you talking about your vote for non scum me?

They haven’t been doing a good job of finding the last scum. They’ve haven’t contributed anything to today.

One little mystery solved then. please put Eeyaras mind at ease and tell us what the day three scroll is.

We do know there’s only one. We’ve lynched two. read night zero. there are two scum and a traitor. unless you’re suggesting something super paranoid like the day three scroll being a conversion. And if it’s obvious they’re not laughing, why say they are? If it’s obvious they’re not playing with town, make the case!

If he’s laughing, they’re not playing with town and I’ll help you lynch them.

So assuming a player can’t receive more than one scroll (unjustified assumption, but possibly helpful) I, Eeyara and Araveea can’t have got the day three scroll. Hence aren’t who Trav was referring to. Unvote: Eeyara Vote:Zandder I’m sorry everyone for the chopping and changing. I do wish the traveller would simply speak up. Their silence is scummy.

Dammit. Need to read more closely. yes It was the day four scroll we were discussing apologies everyone I will note Araveea may have known who the traveller was before getting the scroll.

Strange. you told me in PMs that Araveea sent the day three scroll. Who’s lying? You, the traveller or Araveea?

I’m here. Watching closely. No fear about me being penalised. A thought from last night laying awake. Araveea knew who the traveller was before Marwyyn told her. She asked me before Eeyara did how Scaboweewah learnt about the unlynch scroll. I replied I didn’t know there was one until she asked, but then rechecked PMs with Eeyara where she did tell me what the scroll was and I hadn’t paid attention to it. Her investigation result predates the possible traitor recall night two. If the investigator trusted her and brought her coralaazes scum result, she could have got in contact with scum to be recruited that night. She would have had to reveal the result, but would have argued caution, delaying the reveal as long as possible. oh wait, that’s what happened isn’t it? and the investigator is likely dead and can not confirm anything... I trust Tameekys now, and I’m not going to vote for myself, so let’s vote:Eeyara Luxxon or Zandder can break the tie. They each know more than they’ve said. So vote for the day three scroll sender. make the case instead of posting memes

Bah! if I seem to have little nuggets of information, that’s deductive reasoning. sometimes I deduce things wrong, or in my keenness, make errors. I’ve espoused theories in day threads that contained missteps in reasoning. I’ve tried to be upfront about those when I’ve realised. for me, the way to avoid such missteps is to gather as much information as I can. I find low information situations incredibly frustrating and am driven to resolve them. Sometimes I can come across badly doing that. If I’ve been rude or pushy I apologise. My playstyle both in a previous life where I was evil and many good lives since, is to be talkative behind the scenes, lots of PMs a little pushy. I don’t have the history to get into meta or a supe-keen scumdar and I tend not to waste time with ‘niceities’. so yeah, I can see how it gets seen as rude. I realise your comments above aren’t directed as an ad hominem attack, that I shouldn’t take things personally, it’s a game. I’m just answering during my nap time, so I’m a little more introspective than usual. So forgive me if my reply appears solipsistic. However I’m not the leak. And still I believe finding them is the key to this.

I guess I am wrong about things and will need to wait until morning to find out where Nancy’s just fine loop causes her to actually vote.

Acting on information received. Nancy is not scum, Tameekys is not scum. Therefore unvote: Nancy and apologies. Paranoia is fun up until it keeping you awake at night.

Bah. Just Bah. proclaiming that you are hiding something is not the same as showing you have nothing to hide.

Bah lists. so here’s my state of play. all based on personal interactions with players rather than thread analysis. Araveea - helpful in pms. responsible for bringing investigation result on Coralaaze, either definitely town or ran a hard bus over a teammate. My call, town. Cadd - Bah! Do your own damn analysis ya fartbubbles! Town! der! Eeyara - could be the source of the leak about the unlynch scroll, uncleared. Luxxon - useful and helpful in PMs, so far quite townish. Not playing a grogon game. Marwyyn - Investigated by Traveller using scroll before night two. Could be traitor playing wily game, but I rate that unlikely. Which leaves her probably townish Naannccy - known power role, yet still alive? (Even with no known blocker and no active protection making missing kills) claimed inventor, which could be scum role and no one as been able to confirm an invention not on the night zero scum list. Quite untrusting, hence untrustworthy? Tameekys - floating along, playing her own game. Could possibly clear Naannccy but hasn’t yet. Insufficient interaction to evaluate. Zandder - knows something but is being coy. Committed to Tameekys’ grogonisity, otherwise paranoid and unhelpful. Much as one would expect day five, a bunch of solid reads and about the same number of fuzzy ones. At this point, a couple of people can contribute meaningful information to this analysis if they’re so inclined. In the mean time I will Vote: Nancy yes I know she’s the inventor. If I hear she’s invented something the scum couldn’t I’ll happily change.

Bah. Loops. amusingly. You, Tameekys are the only one I’ve not talked with behind the temple. I’d be interested to hear if you’ve anything worthwhile to add to the scumhunt

Bah goo. shame he had a name that was so easy to make fun of. And that he had no spine. in any case, one to go and eight pieces left on the board. The paranoia is setting in. I understand people’s reticence and playing things close to the chest, but in the end working out which information went where when will solve this.

Bah. Fishclocks Listen to the choral. They know

Bah! Timings. two hours left in the day and I’m getting messages again. Seriously people-fish. Don’t leave fartbubbles like this to the last minute. who’s around?

Bah! Wow! ‘tis a bold move piling in on penalty votes. I almost said earlier that anyone who did may as well wave a grogon flag. As for her being cleared or trusted, she hasn’t. officially. but there is corroborating evidence. If you haven’t heard then that suggests you yourself are out of the info loop. Which speaks to your trustworthiness and participation. Thank you for letting us now know she messaged you with a message, that yes, is a little suspect. That would have been much better shared earlier in the day. I can appreciate that above-waves stuff is distracting but it doesn’t help with your complaint about quietness. Also. Hey @marwyyn what’s the info you were going to share with Eeyore?

What reasons were those?