Timothy Dixon

There a very few options at this stage. I'm going to vote: Jack Alden I think Jack and Louisa are the last remaining scum. I'm assuming the last scum will inherit the kill right?

Yes, I can confirm I was blocked last night hence my action not going through. I think Jack and Louisa could be scum. Night 6 Triggs said he was unsuccessful. There are few ways of explaining this other than Triggs was blocked by Louisa. Unless Jack is a commuter and left the town that night. I agree. And I definitely don’t think Louisa and Joe can be scum together. Because if Joe is scum, then that would make Malcom scum. Which would make 5 scum in total. So not a balanced game. That said, I know I’m not scum. If you lynch me the town has lost. All they need to do after that is kill one more person and they’ve won. But how do we know Louisa would actually go and do that? We still have no eveidence she blocked Joesph on Night 6 like she claimed she did. If you two are scum it would be an easy way to ensure the scum got a kill last night.

I can assure you I am not scum. You keep saying you blocked Joesph yet we have no evidence to back that claim up. I am standing up for what I believe in. I have a stronger inkling that Louisa is scum over Jack. And if we lynch the wrong player we’ve lost. Minor suspicion? You blocked me for three nights straight. Even when you knew and then I confirmed my role.

My best guess is Jack. I know I’m town and it’s not me. I know it’s not you and for reasons stated above I assume it’s not Joesph. I feel Henry has also proven himself to be Town after he made a solid case against Geoffrey. Which leaves Jack. But then who blocked Triggs last night? His result was unsuccessful and we all jumped to the conclusion it was a block. Are there any other reasons why a Jailkeeper would receive an unsuccessful result? Could Jack have some kind of commuter role that allowed him to leave the town at night?

I think Malcom is town. If Malcom was scum, then logically Joesph would also be (the presumably last) scum. But if you really blocked Joesph like you said you did then who killed Nigel last night? And more to the point, who blocked Triggs? Two scum actions went through last night, a kill and a block. And I don’t think Joesph could have carried out two night actions at once, and I don’t think there are 5 scum in this game. So for that reason I think Joesph is town.

Thats true. Forgot that you were blocked last night. In which case yes, Louisa is our best choice for today. Unvote: Joesph Finch Vote: Louisa Hammond

Surely they could be godfathers though. Since the godfather investigates as town. That said, I don’t think it is Henry since he has proven himself to be town. If we are assuming Joesph is scum, then it’s safe to assume Malcom is scum. And that Malcom was a JOAT who blocked Thomas on Night 4 and then used the Janitor action on himself when he was lynched. That’s the theory I buy the most at this point. Vote: Joesph Finch

But you blocked me on Night 4. The same night Thomas was blocked. If we assume it was a JOAT that targeted Thomas then it can’t be me because I can’t be blocked AND carry out a night action on the same night. If I was scum (which I’m not). Then I would’ve either killed Nigel or blocked him. And neither of those things happened. What other useful action could I have performed on Nigel that doesn’t have a physical effect? I did protect him that night for clarity.

Argggg! Such a shame we lost two loyal pirates last night. Thomas flipping town means his claim about being blocked Night 4 was true. Now that’s interesting. We know that there were two blocks on Night 4. One on me, one on Thomas. We know that Louisa targeted me and presumably a scum JOAT targeted Thomas. A Jack of all Trades has one shot abilities. So once the block was used on Thomas, it couldn’t have been used again. Which means that Hammond was probably the one who blocked Triggs last night. @Patrick Triggs did Hammond know in advance that you were going to target Jack last night?

According to the logs, a JOAT can have any one shot abilities. And since a Janitor is usually and X shot role anyway, I don't see why not.

Out of the options we have now, Thomas is the best choice. His claim of being blocked yesterday could be true if the scum had some kind of JOAT role. But I'm not sure. I don't think Louisa and Jack can both be scum given how keen she is too lynch him today. I'm far more confident that Louisa is town than Jack. Vote: Thomas Chapman

That’s true. But do we know if a Janitor can self target? Surely you can’t “clear up” your own body. For that reason, I’m more inclined to believe Malcom was town. If we assume there are 4 scum in the game, then the final one would have to be the scum killer. So no one would have been able to Janitor him. Nigel watched himself and saw me target him. So I couldn’t have performed two night actions in one night.

A Janitor would make a lot of sense. If Malcom is scum. Then there would have to be at least 5 scum since Joesph was blocked last night. Now Thomas said he was allegedly blocked on Night 4. And we know it wasn’t Louisa or Triggs. Last night Louisa claimed to have blocked Joesph and Triggs targeted Thomas. No one else appears to have been blocked tonight other than Thomas and Joesph. So it wouldn’t be too much of a stretch too say that Malcom had the scum blocking ability and targeted Thomas on Night 4. Which would possible leave Joesph as the Godfather. Which would explain why there was no kill last night since he was blocked by Louisa.

A quick check in the log journals tells me there’s a variation of the Godfather who is investigation immune. Meaning (I presume) an investigator will get no result on them. The issue here, is that Joesph has been investigated as Town. And I highly doubt there are TWO godfathers in one game. Maybe the scum blocker is x-shot? Which would explain why we haven’t had any evidence of a scum blocker up until now.

But even if the scum blocker did target you and Joesph. That only accounts for two of the three nights. Once the majority of the roles became public on Day Three, the scum blocker would have no reason to target a mason or a vanilla player. But so far none of the PR roles have said they've been blocked. (Other than Thomas today of course). It does seem convienet that Jack was blocked on the night he was meant to investigate Malcom. I think the lynch today is crucial as it will determine who we focus on tomorrow. Vote: Malcom Langley

This is a point. Other than myself, I don't think we have had any evidence there had been another player blocked other than Louisa targeting me. If a scum tries to target the town blocker ior Jailkeeper is there a power order that is followed to see whose block goes through? Or does it depend on who got their action in first?

But Louisa definitely targeted me last night. Which makes me believe she is town as the scum are unlikely have two blockers.

Scrap what I said about Jack. He can’t be the killer because he was confirmed town by the investigator. Argg! This game is messing with my one eyed head! Someone has to have been lying about what they did last night. If Thomas is lying, then the allegiances of Jack, Henry, Joseph, and so by extension Malcom. Will have to come into question. Since they were confirmed town by him. Nigel is lying about giving a protection to Thomas. Louisa isn’t lying because I know for a fact she blocked me.

It’s worth voting Louisa knew my role but chose to block me me anyway last night. Regardless, I’ve been looking back and have tried to narrow down who the scum killer might be based on what happened last night. It can’t be Jack or Henry (as they have been confirmed Town). It can’t be Joesph because he has been confirmed town. And then by extension it can’t be Malcom, because they are Masons. It can’t be me, because I was blocked last night, and therefore it can’t be Louisa either, because she blocked me. It can’t be Nigel, because he gave out a protection last night. And if Thomas IS telling the truth about being the investigator, then it can’t be him either. Which means either Patrick or Jack would have killed Gordon last night. This all relies on Thomas being the investigator though. If he is lying then we can’t be sure that his results are true.

I definitely agree here. I’ve mentioned it in PM that I think Thomas has flown underneath the radar for a solid two days now. He’s said very little. I’d like to hear from him more. Maybe they have a rolecop? A tracker is such a common role it seems too much of a risk too claim it outright. We know there was a scum kill last night. If we look at this as a process of elimination it might be worth seeing who did what last night? This way we can rule out who could NOT have performed the kill.

Oi! I stole that booty fair and square! The last time recruiting took place I believe the scum could only recruit vanilla townies and they couldn’t kill AND recruit on the same night. They could only do one or the other. I think it’s possible that a vanilla has been recruited and inherited an action of some sort (which would certainly explain the abundance in PR roles). Be said once and I’ll say it again: I’m not the scum killer nor am I scum. If Geoffrey really is telling the truth then I would guess the scum do have a recruit action.

But the events aren't mutually exclusive. Louisa blocking me doesn't make her less scummy. I doubt a scum would be able to fake a Jailkeeper claim. And how would tracking him have proved he was scum even if you did find him suspicious.

I'm not going to say that doesn't look scummy. But there are other possibilities too. The scum could have recruited that night. It's also possible they deliberately didn't male a kill if they knew I was being blocked too confuse the town today. My reasoning is the same as yours. I know I'm not scum.

I know I’m Town. I didn’t like Geoffrey’s reason for thinking I’m scum. It felt like a clear attempt to form a bandwagon. I think the one of the investigated players could be a godfather. It’s a possibility we can’t discard. I think it’s worth checking out Thomas as we have no information on him yet. Its clear from Nigel’s result. Geoffrey inherited the kill (or had it all along). And tried to target Triggs last night. So I’m going to Vote: Geoffrey Holton

And then factor in that the late Remy also had a PR role of some description. Something isn’t adding up here. There’s way too many roles for my liking. I don’t trust Gordon. And I don’t trust this whole inventor thing going on. Ah ok. I see I was misinterpreting what Geoffrey had say. I feel like Louisa and Geoffrey are in kahoots together as evil Imperials. Louisa blocks me. Geoffrey conveniently suggests I may be responsible for the lack of kill during the night because of the block. The whole thing just fits together so well. I’m also not sure why everyone is suddenly trusting Louisa all of a sudden. Where is the proof she is town?