Voting thread Week 1 Guerrilla Attacks v. Week 2 Counters

[SkaForHire]

VOTING: Anyone can vote!

Which side won? Which was the best counter build?

Judging criteria: This is a straight one versus one contest. The challenger versus the best (in your opinion) counter build. So judge solely on Challenger versus best counter build. Thank you!

Zone: J13

Assassination 1 by lorddan413, on Flickr

Challenger: LordDan

What Faction can counter: Ulandus

COUNTERS:

A Life Saved! by gid617, on Flickr

BY KAI NRG

Going Somewhere? by Robert4168, on Flickr

BY GARMADON

Zone: F13

Herding 'em up! by gid617, on Flickr

Challenger: Kai NRG

What Faction can counter: Desert King

COUNTERS:

By Robuko

By Jacob Nion

Fortifying the Pasture by lorddan413, on Flickr

By LordDan

Zone: H6

Capturing the Supply Train by Robert4168, on Flickr

Challenger: Garmadon

What Faction can counter: High Council

COUNTERS:

Defending the Supplies to Messahmuk by Gideon_83, on Flickr

By Gideon

By Little John

Edited March 25, 2015 by SkaForHire

[robuko]

Garmadon's challenge pic is missing

[SkaForHire]

No it is not!!! too much post building... lol

[Umbra-Manis]

I hope Ulandus has learned not to take our cows.

[Basiliscus]

I have voted. Great entries from everyone! Well done

One comment SkaForHire: I found the voting somewhat confusing! Do we need to separate out the votes into two separate votes? (e.g. Challenger vs Best Counter builder, then choose the counter building from a separate list). This means someone could choose the challenger and someone from the other list? Is this intentional?

If we only need to decide who won can't they all go onto one vote per grid square? Or is important to decide who won out of the counter-builds?

[Kai NRG]

...If we only need to decide who won can't they all go onto one vote per grid square? Or is important to decide who won out of the counter-builds?

It's important to decide which counter won because that builder gets an additional one or two points, can't remember which.

[Adair]

It's important to decide which counter won because that builder gets an additional one or two points, can't remember which.

Garmadon's, Jacob's, and Littlejohn's.

[SkaForHire]

I have voted. Great entries from everyone! Well done

One comment SkaForHire: I found the voting somewhat confusing! Do we need to separate out the votes into two separate votes? (e.g. Challenger vs Best Counter builder, then choose the counter building from a separate list). This means someone could choose the challenger and someone from the other list? Is this intentional?

If we only need to decide who won can't they all go onto one vote per grid square? Or is important to decide who won out of the counter-builds?

Kai essentially answered this. There are two questions here -- first was the challenger better than the best counter build? Second, who was the best counter build, even if they did not beat the challenger? It is for personal points towards the ranking system that the second question is asked.

[SkaForHire]

Voting Closed. Officially, no territory changed hands.