mostlytechnic Posted April 8, 2013 Posted April 8, 2013 Well, I'll join the crown like I said I would if the lynch is going Guster. Unvote: Chuckie Miller (-obelix-) Vote: Burton Guster (Jedi master Brick) That done, in the interest of learning here in the academy, Adriano, what better defense could Burton have made if he were town? Assuming vanilla town, what could he say other than I'm not the killer and I don't know why there was no scumkill last night? Jeanie, why don't you think the kill ability will get passed on? Seems from what everyone else says, that's the EB way to play. Since scum w/o a kill are so weak, it makes sense to me. And the "rest of the world" way to play appears to be that there's not a set killer each night, but the scum team gets to pick a target and have one scum carry it out, so effectively, they never lose the kill ability either. Just here it's kept to one player until they're gone, making it a little easier to learn and catch them. that should be crowd, not crown up there. But I can't edit (as we've been firmly taught!)
Hammerstein NWC Posted April 8, 2013 Posted April 8, 2013 What flimsy result? Burton was blocked. There was no Scum kill. No defense from Burton apart from: "They made it up!!" There is no other option than lynching him. Why are you so hesitant? Hesitant? I've voted for him and voted for a number of people you have suggested me to in the past and without being a bit mean we both know how that turned out. I thought the result found was "Burton Guster has been stopped from playing basketball tonight" - Andrew investigated Simone and found a black mesa infiltration guide and that was "solid". Sounds more flimsy to me. I'm not sure why you are picking on me voting for him when others haven't or have had to change their vote?
Esurient Posted April 8, 2013 Posted April 8, 2013 "Burton Guster has been stopped from playing basketball tonight" LegoDad, on 07 April 2013 - 12:33 AM, said: To the Blocker, was "kept from playing basketball" verbatim what was said, or is that just your way of telling us the specific person [was] blocked? Sorry for the confusion but I would be going against the rules if I am going to quote directly or post anything from another player... And what I was trying to say is what Claire said (in bold). I think that is another way of saying Burton was blocked.
-obelix- Posted April 8, 2013 Posted April 8, 2013 I think today's lynch is already a success and a done deal, and see no point in adding my vote to the pool. Therefore, I am voting for tomorrow - for the person, I feel responsible for the loss of many townies... Vote: Claire Standish (LegoDad)
Mencot Posted April 8, 2013 Posted April 8, 2013 I think today's lynch is already a success and a done deal, and see no point in adding my vote to the pool. Therefore, I am voting for tomorrow - for the person, I feel responsible for the loss of many townies... Vote: Claire Standish (LegoDad) Hey "buddy" there is no point in revenge voting, as I don´t trust her so much because of her bad calls, I don´t think she is scum. So there is no point in "voting her out just because she is responsible" because she (and not alone) made some bad decisions!
-obelix- Posted April 8, 2013 Posted April 8, 2013 If my vote was revenge motivated, don't it would go to Mary Jane? But OK, I see your point. Who do you propose I vote for? Give any argument, and I'll change my vote. I meant to say /don't you think it would go/... Boy, I need to lay off the booze...
PsyKater Posted April 8, 2013 Posted April 8, 2013 Hesitant? I've voted for him and voted for a number of people you have suggested me to in the past and without being a bit mean we both know how that turned out. I thought the result found was "Burton Guster has been stopped from playing basketball tonight" - Andrew investigated Simone and found a black mesa infiltration guide and that was "solid". Sounds more flimsy to me. I'm not sure why you are picking on me voting for him when others haven't or have had to change their vote? I still don't have any idea about Andrew's investigation result. But the blocker who claims having targeted Shawna (Scum) twice while there were no Scum kills, claimed that he targeted Burton while there was no Scum kill. Ignore the wording which has probably reworded two times (do not quote host pms, do not quote player pms). Burton was blocked he has to take responsibility for the lack of a kill. If my vote was revenge motivated, don't it would go to Mary Jane? But OK, I see your point. Who do you propose I vote for? Give any argument, and I'll change my vote. I meant to say /don't you think it would go/... Boy, I need to lay off the booze... Why change your vote when you don't want to vote for Burton anyway / think that your vote does not matter? Why do you not vote for him? Do you still hope that your scum buddy Burton gets of the hook during the next hours? Don't you think that he is scum? Tell me the reason.
-obelix- Posted April 8, 2013 Posted April 8, 2013 If you have read the whole thing, and not jump to conclusions you would have answers to all your questions. Yes I think he is scum (as in the part - today's voting will be a success), he is no buddy of mine, scum or otherwise, and he has no way of avoiding his fate. I didn't vote for him because the last time I did so I was called out for casting my vote late when it didn't matter, and labeled scummy for it. I will not do so again.
LegoDad Posted April 8, 2013 Posted April 8, 2013 I think today's lynch is already a success and a done deal, and see no point in adding my vote to the pool. Therefore, I am voting for tomorrow - for the person, I feel responsible for the loss of many townies... Vote: Claire Standish (LegoDad) I don't think anyone disputes that mistakes were made toward the beginning of the week. But continuing to hold my feet to the fire about it while about everybody else has moved on and accepted that mistakes were made is not contributing to the town. The inability to add any real substance to the conversation has been concerning to me from the beginning.
jimmynick Posted April 8, 2013 Posted April 8, 2013 I am surprised that someone was really pushing this option so hard. What does this someone say to justify this behavior? That seems to be directed at my argument with Brian. I wasn't "pushing hard" but I was trying to explain why that is not a bad option to consider, which he refused to listen to. No-one's chosen that option for another lynch candidate and the lynch has moved to Burton while I was asleep, so I'll just agree that lynching Burton is a good thing to do. Unvote: Jeanie Bueller (badboytje88) Vote: Burton Guster (Jedi master Brick)
mostlytechnic Posted April 8, 2013 Posted April 8, 2013 Summary of the day's votes (mostly for my reference, but putting it here for all): Jeanie Bueller voted Burton Bobby Busch voted Burton Andrew Clark voted Burton Lucy Emerson voted Burton Burton Guster voted Brian Mary Jane voted Chuckie then Burton Brian Johnson voted Burton Chuckie Miller voted Claire Davey Osborne voted Burton Adriano Parbritzzi voted Burton Allison Reynolds voted Jeanie then Burton Claire Standish voted Burton Current totals: Burton 11 Claire 1 Burton, anything to say before you leave the class?
Jedi master Brick Posted April 8, 2013 Posted April 8, 2013 Yes I do have something to say. You are all be manipulated. You should rethink on who to trust. Forget what has happened so far, the scum are no who you think.
mostlytechnic Posted April 8, 2013 Posted April 8, 2013 anyone in particular you want to point us at?
Jedi master Brick Posted April 8, 2013 Posted April 8, 2013 Jeanie is flying under the radar and not contributing. Despite being found town by Andrew she could could be the godfather or Andrew could be scum as well. Chuckie is also flying under the radar and suspicious
Darkdragon Posted April 8, 2013 Author Posted April 8, 2013 Burton Guster (Jedi master Brick) - 10 votes (LegoDad, Purpearljellyblob, Clanure, Esurient, badboytje88, PsyKater, Hammerstein NWC, Mencot, mostlytechnic, jamesn) Brian Johnson (Purpearljellyblob) - 1 vote (Jedi master Brick) Claire Standish (LegoDad) - 1 vote (-obelix-) There are 6 hours left in the day. A majority has voted for Burton Guster (Jedi master Brick) to be expelled. Discussion may continue, but you may no longer vote.
mostlytechnic Posted April 8, 2013 Posted April 8, 2013 Oops, my totals above I miscounted and the totals from the teachers are, of course, correct.
Darkdragon Posted April 9, 2013 Author Posted April 9, 2013 Burton Guster (Jedi master Brick) - 10 votes (LegoDad, Purpearljellyblob, Clanure, Esurient, badboytje88, PsyKater, Hammerstein NWC, Mencot, mostlytechnic, jamesn) Brian Johnson (Purpearljellyblob) - 1 vote (Jedi master Brick) Claire Standish (LegoDad) - 1 vote (-obelix-) Day 7 has ended. A majority has voted for Burton Guster (Jedi master Brick) to be expelled. The results of this expulsion will be revealed tomorrow. Day 7 is over and this post will now be locked. You have exactly 24 Hours from this post to submit your night actions. No late actions will be accepted.
Recommended Posts