Palathadric Posted May 21, 2015 Posted May 21, 2015 Hmm I've been searching through the past day threads and I have to concede that Sarah is no longer one my top suspects. Russel has been far scummier in his actual actions, and though Sarah has rubbed me the wrong way since the beginning even when all the nonsense in the beginning was going on, there isn't a whole lot of concrete evidence that would make him convincingly scum in my mind. With Irene confirmed as scum, it makes absolutely no sense that both Russel and Sarah would be scum as well, so I would lean towards Russel. I think Greg would top my list.
Dragonfire Posted May 21, 2015 Posted May 21, 2015 I'm voting for Eric because I'm trying to cooperate with the town, and people are throwing rather convincing thoughts against him. List these "convincing thoughts". IMO, Eric is a convenience lynch, and the scum are behind the bandwagon. With Irene confirmed as scum, it makes absolutely no sense that both Russel and Sarah would be scum as well, so I would lean towards Russel. Agreed. I would also say that if Russel is scum, it is highly unlikely that you are either, simply because three scum on the Sarah wagon is just too attention-drawing, and besides, he is pushing on you today. I would like to draw everyone's attention to a more pressing issue. There is a mole in the town block. And no, I don't mean a small furry animal. I was just contacted by Al asking why I targeted him last night. I am a vanilla townie - I have no night action. So whoever gave Al this information must be lying, and therefore scum. Al obviously believes this person, so I can deduce that they are in the town block. I would strongly advise you to be wary of an infiltrator in your midst.
Piratedave84 Posted May 21, 2015 Posted May 21, 2015 List these "convincing thoughts". IMO, Eric is a convenience lynch, and the scum are behind the bandwagon. Agreed. I would also say that if Russel is scum, it is highly unlikely that you are either, simply because three scum on the Sarah wagon is just too attention-drawing, and besides, he is pushing on you today. I would like to draw everyone's attention to a more pressing issue. There is a mole in the town block. And no, I don't mean a small furry animal. I was just contacted by Al asking why I targeted him last night. I am a vanilla townie - I have no night action. So whoever gave Al this information must be lying, and therefore scum. Al obviously believes this person, so I can deduce that they are in the town block. I would strongly advise you to be wary of an infiltrator in your midst. Isn't Al the watcher? So he would have lied to himself?
Lady K Posted May 21, 2015 Posted May 21, 2015 Isn't Al the watcher? So he would have lied to himself? I have been wondering the same thing.
Dragonfire Posted May 21, 2015 Posted May 21, 2015 Isn't Al the watcher? So he would have lied to himself? According to Al, his actual role is tracker (Bob made a mistake in the role PM). There is a watcher, and it is someone else.
Piratedave84 Posted May 21, 2015 Posted May 21, 2015 According to Al, his actual role is tracker (Bob made a mistake in the role PM). There is a watcher, and it is someone else. How do you know? You need to give weight to your allegations; as of now, this only looks bad on you. There would be 2 watcher; one who's a tracker and one who's a watcher? :confused:
TrumpetKing Posted May 21, 2015 Posted May 21, 2015 Al came to me with the same question. After discussion, he told me he asked to get a better read. Seeing as he did so to other players, I can believe that claim, and for now am willing to still trust him. That doesn't mean, however, that it is unlikely there's a mole in the town block. People eagerly claiming their roles to Al is a great way to prove themselves, and what better way for the scum to hide? And, for all we know, though I don't believe this to be the case, Al could be scum himself, and this town block could be a ruse to gain more information for his team.
Palathadric Posted May 21, 2015 Posted May 21, 2015 Isn't Al the watcher? So he would have lied to himself? I have been wondering the same thing. Al's post: Also, I am the watcher. Actually, that's what I'm called, but I guess I'm more of a tracker because I can see who one person targeted each night. If you're not scum, at least try to pay attention to what people are saying.
StickFig Posted May 21, 2015 Posted May 21, 2015 That doesn't mean, however, that it is unlikely there's a mole in the town block. Heh, TPRU, do you think there's a mole in the town block? Two people have not voted today. What are you waiting for? Also, DLL and JJP, your continued insistence on candidates that no one else seems to suspect is beginning to look out of place.
Piratedave84 Posted May 21, 2015 Posted May 21, 2015 Al's post: If you're not scum, at least try to pay attention to what people are saying. Please i know this; there would still not be 2 roles called watcher. Do you not agree?
Palathadric Posted May 21, 2015 Posted May 21, 2015 Apparently there aren't: No, I'm the tracker. As I said, my role allows me to see who a player targeted at night. It just turns out I was accidentally given the wrong name in my initial PM. Although, if you're saying that Bob Almighty would not have sent out to roles both named "Watcher" then I may agree with you.
Kintobor Posted May 21, 2015 Posted May 21, 2015 Two people have not voted today. What are you waiting for? People who have not voted at this point are withholding their vote for a reason, and are scummy in my book. Eric and Al, why haven't you voted? The question is more directed towards Eric at the moment, seeing how he's under the hammer, but I still want to know Al's reason at least.
JackJonespaw Posted May 21, 2015 Posted May 21, 2015 Heh, TPRU, do you think there's a mole in the town block? Two people have not voted today. What are you waiting for? Also, DLL and JJP, your continued insistence on candidates that no one else seems to suspect is beginning to look out of place. I'm not sure if it's no one who has suspicions about Greg, but you are correct if you meant lessened suspicions. As are my suspicions. Greg's put up a pretty good defense today and I'm not so sure is he's scum anymore. Of course, I'm not at all convinced, but I'd just rather have others' opinions on this, to see what they think. But those don't see to be coming today. Unvote: Greg (Lady K) Vote: Russel (Sandy) I have no idea where the votes are at at this point, but Rus is the best choice for lynch today, withholding Greg, of course. The bandwagon on me, Day 1, seems a bit rushed, as did all three votes against me, honestly. Irene and Eric had decent-ish reasons, but Russel merely voted for me because of what I would guess would be wanting to avoid voting for a near-confirmed town. But instead of voting for Brian, he voted for me. Avoiding scum pals? His reasons for voting for yesterday and today have only been because he himself didn't want to get lynched. Desperate attempts to swim out of the spotlight. And then this second mafia family thing..not sure what that is about, but it again seems desperate. Just a weird play he's got going on here, and nothing giving of a particularly town-y vibe.
MagPiesRUs Posted May 21, 2015 Posted May 21, 2015 I would like to draw everyone's attention to a more pressing issue. There is a mole in the town block. And no, I don't mean a small furry animal. I was just contacted by Al asking why I targeted him last night. I am a vanilla townie - I have no night action. So whoever gave Al this information must be lying, and therefore scum. Al obviously believes this person, so I can deduce that they are in the town block. I would strongly advise you to be wary of an infiltrator in your midst. No one saw you target me last night - I just sent you that message to see how you'd react. Unfortunately I wasn't watched last night, but I know for a fact that at least one scum targeted me last night. Maybe even the SK. Everyone who has claimed to me has believable stories that haven't been counterclaimed, so I wouldn't be surprised if they were all telling the truth. However, I haven't given any important information to anyone who hasn't already been verified. I think we're pretty safe at the moment. I'm torn between Eric and Russell today. I think they're both good lynches. At the moment though, I think I'm leaning more towards Russell, but there's still plenty of time left in the day for him to change my mind. Vote: Russell Price (Sandy)
Dannylonglegs Posted May 22, 2015 Posted May 22, 2015 I think I missed the 24-hour mark from my last post by a few hours; my apologies. Just finished a 16-hour day at work and I have no brain cells left. From what I can tell, I like my current vote, although it does ping me that Eugene wants to ask us why no one is voting against Ace while his vote is on Russell, and his posts all seem very... blandly aligned with the majority sentiment. Or I might just be tired. I'll see you all tomorrow - unless someone gets lynched first. I think you're just tired. I voted for Ace first thing when the day started because I wanted to get my primary suspect out in the spotlight! I guess that didn't work though, and it's back to a match between Russel and Eric! so much for testing my (and poor Pamela's) suspicions today. Maybe tomorrow. Maybe never. Maybe I'm wrong. Who knows anything in this topsy turvy game of life? Get some rest, pal. Hmm I've been searching through the past day threads and I have to concede that Sarah is no longer one my top suspects. Russel has been far scummier in his actual actions, and though Sarah has rubbed me the wrong way since the beginning even when all the nonsense in the beginning was going on, there isn't a whole lot of concrete evidence that would make him convincingly scum in my mind. With Irene confirmed as scum, it makes absolutely no sense that both Russel and Sarah would be scum as well, so I would lean towards Russel. I think Greg would top my list. About damn time! I can't believe anyone still thinks Sarah's scum! What scum in their right mind would try to buss a fellow scum on day 1?! Especially when one of their own is on the frying pan?! Heh, TPRU, do you think there's a mole in the town block? Two people have not voted today. What are you waiting for? Also, DLL and JJP, your continued insistence on candidates that no one else seems to suspect is beginning to look out of place. Well sorry for paying attention to events and trying to root out the scum, mate! but yeah, I reckon it is time I weighed in on the two way split between two bandwagon hoppers. I'm going to Unvote: Ace (Kintobor) for the third (fourth) time, and Vote: Russel (Sandy), if for no other reason than to put him out of his misery as a two day lynch candidate. I do believe there's a good chance he's scum. The argument against him's sound (I should know, I made it yesterday too.) And there seems to be no better alternative. If we have nothing better to go on tomorrow, I wouldn't be averse to trying Eric too, if Russel shows up town. Hopefully we have more to go on tomorrow though. We seem to be breathing stale air into our arguments lately. If i get a chance I'll put more thought onto the lynch when I finish preparing food for the dinner rush at Chez Albert. Tonight's special is Rabbit that should have hopped faster.
Bob Posted May 22, 2015 Author Posted May 22, 2015 Vote Count: Ace Brickman (Kintobor) - 5 (penalty, penalty, penalty, penalty, penalty) Eric Foster (Palathadric) - 5 (StickFig, jamesn, Piratedave84, Sandy, Lady K) Russell Price (Sandy) - 6 (Dragonfire, Kintobor, TrumpetKing, Jackjonespaw, TinyPiesRUs, Dannylonglegs) A little under 24 hours remains in Day Three. With 12 players, seven votes are required for a lynch.
Dragonfire Posted May 22, 2015 Posted May 22, 2015 No one saw you target me last night - I just sent you that message to see how you'd react. Unfortunately I wasn't watched last night, but I know for a fact that at least one scum targeted me last night. Maybe even the SK. Everyone who has claimed to me has believable stories that haven't been counterclaimed, so I wouldn't be surprised if they were all telling the truth. However, I haven't given any important information to anyone who hasn't already been verified. I think we're pretty safe at the moment. I'm torn between Eric and Russell today. I think they're both good lynches. At the moment though, I think I'm leaning more towards Russell, but there's still plenty of time left in the day for him to change my mind. Vote: Russell Price (Sandy) Oh. Now I see your tactic - clever. Too bad that it led to me outing my role publicly - here I was, thinking that I'd possibly caught a scum So now Russel has 6 votes and Eric has 5. That's very close, and it leads me to believe that one of the two is scum and the scum are trying to save him. This will potentially help catch scum should our lynchee flip scum in the end.
MagPiesRUs Posted May 22, 2015 Posted May 22, 2015 I might not be around for the rest of the day, so good luck getting a lynch! Both options seem ok to me, as long as one of them goes. If anyone hasn't yet claimed anything to me, please PM me now. If you're a vanilla, it doesn't matter, please PM me anyway. If you're not comfortable revealing your role, please PM me and tell me you're not going to claim to me. If you need a haircut, please PM me too and I'll schedule an appointment.
Piratedave84 Posted May 22, 2015 Posted May 22, 2015 Apparently there aren't: Although, if you're saying that Bob Almighty would not have sent out to roles both named "Watcher" then I may agree with you. Why you no vote? You realize that by casting your vote you could save yourself right?
Palathadric Posted May 22, 2015 Posted May 22, 2015 I've been trying to think of the likelihood of two scum jumping on the same bandwagon so early on. It just seems somehow weird to me. Did they really think they could save Brian? Anyway, though I think Greg may be the better option, it seems obvious we won't get a vote on her, so I may as well Vote: Russel Price (Sandy). Also, I've been looking at Ace Brickman because of Eugene's obsession with him, but I have to say that I think his first vote on Day 1 against Brian, which came at a time when there wasn't much focus on Brian at all makes me lean more toward him being town, though, since then he's successfully worked himself into a more and more suspicious state. Still, I think that vote may be telling in a pro-town or at least "not scum" sort of way. It's been a busy day today, but if I can get on again, I will have more to share regarding Greg and Russel.
Sandy Posted May 22, 2015 Posted May 22, 2015 Well, now that it doesn't really matter, since my career as a scapegoat has reached it's climax, I am going to vote for the person I wanted to vote all along. Unvote: Eric Foster (Palathadric) Vote: Ace Brickman (Kintobor) Anyone up for a double lynch?
Kintobor Posted May 22, 2015 Posted May 22, 2015 Well, now that it doesn't really matter, since my career as a scapegoat has reached it's climax, I am going to vote for the person I wanted to vote all along. Unvote: Eric Foster (Palathadric) Vote: Ace Brickman (Kintobor) Anyone up for a double lynch? Unfortunately I'm still one away from a lynch. Unlike you. Anyways, I'm confident in the Russell lynch. I need to head out early, so best of luck with the lynch.
jimmynick Posted May 22, 2015 Posted May 22, 2015 Just to make sure we got Russell good: Unvote: Eric (Palathadric) Vote: Russell (Sandy)
Dragonfire Posted May 22, 2015 Posted May 22, 2015 Well, now that it doesn't really matter, since my career as a scapegoat has reached it's climax, I am going to vote for the person I wanted to vote all along. Unvote: Eric Foster (Palathadric) Vote: Ace Brickman (Kintobor) Anyone up for a double lynch? Even scummier. If you were town, you'd just accept the fact that you're going down and hope that your alignment may confirm a scum. This desperate wagon-hopping signifies your true personality: a caught scum!
Sandy Posted May 22, 2015 Posted May 22, 2015 This desperate wagon-hopping signifies your true personality: a caught scum! Oh, please! Everything I've said and done has been scummy to you. Oh boy am I going to laugh when I see your long faces tomorrow when my towniness is revealed. Except I won't be around to see it, am I? I will have joined the great Union in Heaven... I will never have to work again, and I'll have all the coffee I can drink.
Recommended Posts