gman42

I can't imagine it wouldn't be something just like this. I thought it was wacky when the dimensions leaked and some people jumped to "zomg it's gonna be a rectangle" lol. Honestly the more I think about it the more I like the idea of a hemisphere. The way they did the previous two was interesting, but there was a lot of stuff they had to cram into a small space to fit all the iconic scenes, and they sacrificed a bit of detail as a result. If this makes for some dioramas that have room to really breathe, it could be extremely cool. The only thing I can't picture is how the base/support is gonna look, it would have to be pretty funky with how the weight would be distributed.

I don't really get this particular complaint, it's clear that what Cassian was doing was rash and dangerous, but also that K2 was being too pedantic and ignoring the fact that their ship was about to be swallowed up by a debris cloud in about five seconds. His flippant "I'll make them for you" response was his way of saying "yeah I know this is like a coinflip that we die but if we don't do anything we're dead anyway". I do fully agree that the whole aspect of Galen intentionally putting in a vulnerability totally sucks and should have been changed. I'm not sure how easy it would have been to express this without too much exposition, but a better solution would be to show him poring over 'blueprints' of the station and finding the vulnerability, starting to fix the design, and then having a come-to-Jesus moment and quietly undoing the changes. Then just tell Jyn more or less that he's sitting on a dangerous secret about the vulnerability of the DS instead of having put it there. Overall I get what you're saying about RO fan service. It's hit or miss for me, Dr. Ezavan and Ponda Baba can be explained away as them being on their way to their ship to take off and they were long gone before the blast, but it's stupid and they add nothing. The brief little scene of R2 and 3PO was silly and clearly just an opportunity to say they've been in every SW movie to date. Other stuff I enjoyed more like the lost footage of Red/Gold leader in the battle over Scarif. Personally I enjoy the movie a lot, it's a flawed but very entertaining watch.