Pretty nice set overall. Great idea the modularity: in the linear configuration it reminds a port, so the ideal, imo, is to have two sets together: the fortress (Fort sabre) and the nearby port (Port royal): superb landscape. In this context, I found also appropiate to include the merchant vessel, it is an added value consistent with the interpretative possibilities of the set.
Finishings of the walls and rooms are fine, with a clear touch of classical nostalgia.. very well done.
Being collectible, the minifigures are acceptable, in the end no one will play with them. However, going into it, it makes no sense to have 50/50 males and females in this specific set. It is out of context. I would have rather seen the governor's aunt and niece than female soldiers.
On the contrary, in the Barracuda bay the two females minifigures are a sublime homage to Anne Bonny and Mary Read, so much stuff..