Shainen Sheepdog

@Hinckley, thanks for another great game. Well played scum!

That it was all a little too convenient? Why would she have tracked Holbrook? He certainly wasn't her only suspicion yesterday. There were others looking a lot more suspicious than he was. They might want to give it to themselves if they were concerned that they had received a bomb. You do realise these are accounted for? Bolding added by me. Why bring these up? They weren't on any list until today's and so haven't come into play yet. Vote: Leatrix. I feel she has thrown a lot of things out there that are designed to create confusion, and then just latching on to whatever Benicia says to support her own position. I'm not convinced fully on Marlowe being scum and think it more likely he just made a dumb choice.

Or she just said she did. Parvani was one of the last to claim on the morning of Day 2. She could have been waiting to see how the cards fell before committing. Good point. The question about who he talked to about being vengeful is moot given a block would not prevent the vengeful action from being carried out.

Correct. I must admit that my mind also immediately went to vengeful watcher, which I think makes sense if the trickster also gave out vengeful investigator and vengeful tracker. On that, we have an accounted for block. Would that explain why we have not heard about the outcome of Rutherford's vengeful? Would a block work on a vengeful? Do we know who else Rutherford might have talked to about being vengeful? On the thief, I don't think we would have seen evidence of it yesterday, as the the target would have been chosen overnight, and their vote then stolen today (Day 4).

In what way? I thought the bomb going off would result in anyone targeting that person being killed in the explosion. Isn't that the logic he was using for why he said he targeted Hyacinth - to protect any town roles that targeted her? The flaw in his logic was thinking that she would be a target for the scum kill. Assuming anything he said was truthful, of course.

Why not? I thought the diffuser needed to target the person holding the bomb, not the person handing out the bomb. Or did I misunderstand how a diffuser works?

Did the result state they were not scum, meaning Emeric could be town or trickster?

Just to confirm, you were the vig that killed Hyacinth?

So, if I had died last night, I would have been given the opportunity to investigate someone.

Vengeful doesn't in itself kill anyone. Rather, the action they had would have been invoked if they had been lynched or killed. That is how my pm explained it, but not in those exact words of course.

You said you were the ghoul for Night 2 with Hyacinth as your target. So, you were happy for any bombs given to you on Night 2 to be passed onto Hyacinth. But last night you decided to protect the person you were happy to kill the night before?

I was the vengeful investigator. Who was your target?

Why did you think it only affected the Virgin? There is nothing in the posts from Omrom to suggest it was only limited to the effect on the Virgin. Vote: Hyacinth Hippo Not reporting this in your first post in the midst of everyone else revealing their actions and results from Night 2, and then trying to suggest it was because you wanted to see a reaction, just doesn't feel right.

The Hooker role only impacts the Virgin and does not have a blocking action on anyone else, unlike what the mafiascum wiki says. I have clarified this with Hinckley. The Hooker only has an impact if it targeted the Virgin. The impact if I had targeted the Virgin were as per the wiki - they would lose their ability and the kills the next night would proceed.

I was the compulsive hooker and successfully hooked Parvani last night.