Trenton Monette

Well fuck. You’ve got me. Well played town. I’m pissed that recruitment didn’t go through. *I wish I was a pirate shipwreck down in Mexico where the oceans turn to silver and the beaches turn to gold I’d make love to some senorita in that town I’d get on my boat and I’d sail the ocean round. I wish I was a pirate out there under my own flag running for no reason and no reason to run back. The salt and rum on my tongue, sails tattered and torn laughing in the devil’s face, riding out the storm. Ooh, one of these days Gonna get off this highway wake up in Sun Bay with the sunshine on my face Saint Christopher on a silver chain say a prayer and sail away I wish I was a pirate on some gold ship in the night with nothing but the stars, the moon and faith to be my guide steady as she goe with my back to the wind let a cloud of cannon smoke disappear again * Since I’m technically in charge of the firing squad I command you not to shoot me. I name Fred as my successor. He’ll inherit my position.

Thank you for understanding me! And I apologise for the confusion I caused earlier. And I love you (and your tuba) too . Here is the full conversation:

Ok, some clarification on the whole PM ruke. When I asked Bob about the rule I only asked about screenshots not quotes. So I apologise. That was an error on my wording. Now for those quotes you wanted Vincent: He sent me this first before Day One started. Essentially setting up the PM chat. Then during Day One I got this: And then this: And then he stopped communicating with me. Given he didn't say much at all for the rest of the day I'm assuming he had RL stuff. But that's all I know. Like I said I'm a mason.

I am NOT lying. I asked the host whether I can quote PMs to another player and he said I couldn’t. We can quote PMs in the day thread but not between each other. You’ve fundamentally misunderstood that Ruke Vincent If you’re so unsure of my claim PM the host and ask him whether we can share PMs we’ve had with one player with another player in private, he’ll tell you exactly the same thing he told me.

If we lynch Aiden. There are two ways it could go. He's either scum - woohoo! Or he self targets and saves himself. Good in the sense we know we haven't lost a town. But bad because it gives the scum an extra night to potentially make a kill. I see more good coming out of this lynch than bad. Vote: Aiden Leon

Again not everything is black and white. I can trust a claim and still have doubts and visa versa. I can not trust a claim but still have doubts.

You are definitely reading into this too much. Fabian was suggesting that the scum tried to kill Daniel as well as himself - but failed. And I was questioning why he would think this. Hence my suggestion of the vig and the scum killer targeting the same person and cancelling the kill - something that has happened before. Not everything is so black and white. I can question someone and still believe the claim they've made. And how is me considering his claim knowledge that he was the Vig? There were two things going through my mind when that happened. Either Daniel was lying and going nuts (like he did a lot during Day 2) or I assumed you and Aiden were another set of masons. Can there be two sets of masons in one game?

Wait, so Bill Gates isn't giving away money if you share the link?? Dam it. So Vincent is actually neutral. I'm still not sure why he lied to us in the first place. As I said earlier Remi thought there was at least one scum between the Vincent - Aiden - Daniel madness and I still believe him. To be honest I don't know what to believe. Vinecent's claim is just plain weird. Aiden's "bait and switch" plan is also bizarre. So from my understanding he wanted to unlynch a player he thought was town but was actually scum just to piss off Daniel? I don't know if I see that coming from a town perspective. Why would any townie even want to suggest that? A part of me wants to lynch Aiden because of what's come to light. But depending on what the numbers are mislynching could be catastrophic.

I apologise for not claiming earlier. Like I’m said I’m fairly new to all of this and wasn’t sure what to do when are Remi was killed.

Regardless of your alignment. That’s incredibly impressive and comical at the same time. Maybe the accusation was a bit far fetched. For what it’s worth I’m leaning town in you given your vote on the Joshua bandwagon I talked about earlier. No. All I was told was that I was town mason and Remi was my mason buddy. We’d were allowed to set up a PM and communicate during the day and night phase.

Well shit. Let’s look at what we have here. According to mafia scum wiki the bulletproof role can be town aligned or scum aligned. A big part of me believes Vincent is telling the truth here plain and simple. I’ve tried not to read too much over the mess that is Day Two but looking back at the vote count for Joshua, Vincent was the third person on him. I could see a scum reluctantly voting towards the end of a bandwagon or possibly keeping off it entirely. But not passed the start where it would be easy to kick a bandwagon off like that. On the other hand here’s what bugs me about Vincent’s hidden claim. It’s hidden so if he ever needed to use it (such as today) he could show everyone he claimed earlier in the game (as he’s done). But if he was say tracked, then he could leave the hidden claim where it is and we’d be none the wiser. How do we know the words TRACKER, BODYGUARD, VIGILANTE or INVENTOR aren’t hidden somewhere in Vincent’s many posts? How we do we know he hasn’t made various hidden claims and pulled up the one that fits his story? Aiden being a scum governor is something I’ve considered as well. But if I was a scum governor, and I was planning to save my scum buddy. I probably wouldn’t claim I governer. I would claim another passive role. This was probably going to come out sooner or later so I may as well just say it now. I am the Town Mason. Remi (was) also a town mason (RIP old friend ) and we had a masonry together. Unlike you guys who could only during the night stage. Myself and Remi were allowed to communicate during the day phase as well as the night phase. He didn’t say a lot other than he suspected a scum between Aiden, Vincent and Daniel due to the chaos they were causing on a Day One. I was glad to be parked with someone since this is my 2nd game here. So apologies if I haven’t been playing things right. But that’s all I know. Me and him were masons and sadly he was killed night 1 so no more was able to be said.

I think lynching Fabian would be be the best plan. Simply because if we hold off for today it gives the scum an extra night to make a kill. Fabian hasn't offered much of a defence. If Fabian is the scum killer does the scum kill pass on to another scum? And if so are we in a situation like Pirates and Forest Mafia where the scum can get two night actions? Either way I think Fabian is the best plan for tonight.

I'm also in agreement of the lynch Fabian block Vincent. I'm still not sure whether I trust the claim fully or not. Vote: Fabien Bellamy

I find it incredibly convenient that Fabien just happened to kill the person who was trying to block him last night. This makes me think he knew he was going to be blocked and took action before he could be stopped. Why would the scum fail? I could see two kills cancelling out one another (as has happened in a previous game). But your kill has gone through so it can't be the case.

The three blockers coordinated their targets last night. So if there was a scum blocker then the scum would’ve known who NOT to target in the case of Daniel (since he protects his target as well). Andrew said his role was a vanillaiser right? So technically he isn’t a blocker by definition but by function he serves the same purpose as one.