There is certainly a quality issue with the plastic used today versus 70s and 80s...I've had way more torso cracks in new figures versus my classic castle. More than that, though, is just having something with real history versus brand new. I've seen people selling the Bricktober castle figures (red/peach quarters) as though they were the original 36 year old figures. It's an authenticity thing, and devalues the original if there is no way to tell the two apart at a glance. I'd much rather see a redesign, even if subtle, than a straight remake.