TrumpetKing

Cohost here, for all your cohost-ly needs, such as coffee brewing and cupcake baking.

I played this one. I'm almost sure of it.

Holy megabluck. I told you guys about Corny. Maybe not the towniest, thing, but I still called it. Thanks for the game Tammo, it's been one of the most enjoyable games I've played, and it ws certainly a great game to come back from hosting to. Oh, and congrats you scummos!

Thanks for having me! I had a blast!

I have time for one post before I die, and I'm basically just going to use it to address each one of you. Cebastien: I haven't noticed a lot from you. You seem to be speaking up more, now. I haven't gotten a fully solid read, but I strongly trust that you're town based off of the evidence we've seen. Kristina: I've been iffy with you, but with the current situation, I lean town with you. Don't fall for Colin, he's a tricky little bastard. Colin: I don't even think I need to go there. Candy: I think it's established that you're scum, I don't feel the need to say anything. Peter: If anybody's scummy, it's you as well. You seem to post just for the sake of posting, as if you're just there. You never add anything, and your hesitance to vote for me is even odder. Die, scummo. Priscilla: Who? Oh, yea, you, you're scum. Penelope: I don't even remember seeing you. I'd say you're town, only because I'm sure Peter, Priscilla, and Candy are the remaining scum. In case it's not clear, I feel confident in saying that Penelope, Cebastien, and Kristina are town, Colin is a Serial Killer, and Priscilla, Peter, and Candy are scum. Welp, this is it for me. I wish the Malones the best of luck. Beat the shit out of those Ferraris. Do the rest of us proud.

No, I don't. Are you saying that others who have speculated the amount of scum in previous days are scum as well? I don't see you ever accusing them, either. I'm not saying she's lying about her role, but it's possible that the scum could have a Communications Expert, so they can trick the town as well. It's a wild guess, but it's possible. Just like it's possble and likely that you're the Serial Killer. I'm not even sure if I should respond to you since you can't even bother to spell my name right. I also clearly considered that she wasn't lying about the the Communications Expert part when I specifically mentioned Cebastien being in contact with Kristina, which they both confirmed. Way to read my entire statement.

Are you even paying attention anymore? I've made it explicitly clear that I think there's 4 town, 3 scum, and a Serial Killer. Now you're just trying to point out whatever you can, even if I've clarified it.

Wait a minute... What are the chances of us having a Communications Expert, a Vig (another reason why I don't trust Colin's claim), an Investigator and a Vanilla as our living town? I'd say that's a very low chance of being true, and that Colin's bullshitting you all somehow, or Kristina is. I'm starting to wonder if both of them are. Kristina, it still doesn't explain how the person you contacted knew that the Investigator can't be killed, unless they were the Investigator themselves, which I don't recall you clarifying.

Thanks for the scummy vote, Candy. If you guys are just going to let the Serial Killer live, he'll kill you all. Just a warning. At least you've gotten Candy. All the evidence is sitting right in front of you, and ignoring me isn't going to help. I'd appreciate being listened to as well, instead of just being knocked down because Colin think's he's all-knowing and constantly right. Guess what? He's not to be trusted. Guess who suddenly just pinged me again? Kristina. How would the said person know that the investigator couldn't be killed off if nobody could claim to them saying they could? They'd either have to be the investigator themselves, another Communications Expert, or you're a lying scum, which can't be possible since we at least know you've contacted Cebastien. At least not the lying part. So what was it, Kristina? That unsettles me quite a bit. Oh, and Vote: Peter Nuticceli (Peanuts) so we don't forget him.

Excuse me for being absent, I actually had personal reasons for being gone that took over for a moment. I already know there's nothing to do at this point to save me, but I'm still going to fight for my life, as I'm town. Just let me catch up.

And I'm not going to admit to being scum because I'm not. A fictitious Serial Killer? We're warned about third parties in the rules and the numbers have enough room for a Serial Killer. Excuse me for being cautious of a Serial Killer when we're warned of them. In this game, you're right, 4-4 wouldn't be a loss, if you were a vig, but you're an SK, so it isn't even 4-4 anyways, but 1-3-4. I'm not scum, so I can't have admitted anything about numbers, as I don't know shit. Just as you speculated there were 4 scum, I speculate there's 3 and an SK, so don't megablocking accuse me for saying I think there's three scum. My theory isn't wrong just because you think you're right. In fact, it seems like you're consistently trying to convince me I'm wrong. Is it because I'm right? Why would I lie about the question I asked? What could I gain from asking a question if I were scum? I couldn't have asked who the PR's were, so do you have any better ideas on what I could have asked? What item did you take? It was the Sheriff's badge, correct?

You're right. I have no direct proof there's a Serial Killer, because you don't want to admit that you're it. 4-4 is a loss because the scum can just force a tie and kill somebody else, outnumbering them. Most games I've seen with a scum win didn't include the extra day just because there wasn't a direct outnumber. I'm not pulling the clarification out of my rear, it's the truth. You're just saying everything I say is a lie, because I'm an easy target for you. I'd suggest you stop tunneling and start actually scumhunting, because all you're doing is telling me I'm wrong because you say so. The list is something that's true. It's verified that I was able to ask a question. The only way I could have made that up is if I knew that I could have asked a question prior, meaning if I were scum a scumbuddy had told me. Considering all three objects were taken, Bernard was town, you're a liar, and we don't know who the other riddle solver was, the third must be scum for me to know, correct? Who else solved the riddle then? Surely they must be scum if I am too, no?

I can now clarify on what the Dirty Hippie meant. When I asked Tam whether the Dirty Hippie included Dexter, the response I got (paraphrased) was asking why the Hippie wouldn't have been talking about the simplest tally, so I assume that he was talking about the tally that left Dexter out. That means that either Kristina, Peter, or Cebastien is scum, and I'm leaning most towards Peter. Given the clarification, I want to say that the town is myself, Kristina, Cebastien, and substitute Peter with Penelope. I'd say Colin is still the Serial Killer, and that the scum are Priscilla, Candy, and substitute Penelope with Peter.

There was a list. Also, you say it as if I hadn't considered asking him which list he was looking at. I have considered asking him, as there's been a lot of confusion as to which tally he looked at. I've held off from asking as I figured I'd either get no clear answer, or no answer at all, but if it helps, I'll ask.

Colin, why are you so intent on trying to blame me and the two scummos for suggesting there's three scum? If there's 4 scum, we would have already lost, because it would be 4-4 or 1-3-4. There's either 3 scum and 5 town, which I doubt given your claim, or 4 town, 3 scum, and you.

If you seriously haven't established my reasoning for him being the Serial Killer, you need to do a better job reading. Who said he skipped the first opportunity? He could have been blocked. Also, the rules state that there could be a neutral player. We've seen no counter claims for his, which is a good and a bad thing. I pointed out that he could just be trying to help the town as well. Just because he's a Serial Killer doesn't automatically mean he's working against the town. He is honestly the most logical choice to be a Serial Killer looking by his claim and the predicted claims. It's sitting right in front of the town, and we need to take some form of action eventually before he kills enough of us for him to win.

I'm not sure where you're pulling out the crap you made in the second paragraph, since you're saying it has to be the second option. Sounds like you're just making a crappy attempt at trying to shove suspicion off of you. Oh, and just so you know, practically the entire suspicion based off of me was meta at first, saying I wasn't as active as my usual self, when the games I've been most active in I played as scum. Oh haha, you and Colin have the exact same thoughts, that's very funny. I don't like your change on opinion so fast, even if people are pointing out flaws in your accusation. You're scum. I'm nearly sure of it. Why am I scum? Why is my list not to be trusted? Because you say so? Dexter turned up scum, and he listed me as a suspicion, so that answers the fact that my question was legitimate. You are not the immediate decision maker for the town, and I doubt you should be, because I'm fairly sure you aren't town. I'm going to be shocked if you aren't the Serial Killer, frankly. It's also very interesting to note that the numbers are generated using previous game's basic structures with numbers. The logical setup for this game, and judging by the third party mentioned in the rules, would be 1 Serial Killer, 4 scum, and 14 town. This is our last chance. It's 1-4-3 now. Killing me will make it 1-3-3. You'll need to either lynch Candy, Penelope, or Priscilla to continue. Oh, and I'd just like to point out that the last game this God hosted had one of the SK's win conditions be living to the final 4, so we'd have to get rid of Colin soon as well, in case the win condition is the same. But that won't happen, so our chances of winning are practically diminished. You can't be serious. I'm not saying it's harder for me to be town, or act town, because I'm doing exactly what you said a town should do. Tell the truth and look for scum. You can't do that, because you are scum, but at least I'm taking your advice. I'm just saying that I haven't played town in nearly half a year, so honestly, yes, I'm going to sound jumbled, but that's just because I'm getting back into the swing of things. Nobody's confirmed town, unless Tam included Dexter as part of the list. Then you, Peter, myself, and Kristina are confirmed town. In case you aren't getting what I'm saying, I'll just clarify again that I'm very sure the scum are Candy, Priscilla, and Penelope. Oh, and that I think our supposed 'vigilante' is a Serial Killer.

I actually forgot about the list momentarily. Now that we know Dexter is scum, we need to decide whether Tam looked at the overall tally and counted Dexter If Dexter was counted, then that clears Peter, You (Kristina), and Cebastien. Since I know I'm town, that leaves Colin, Priscilla, Penelope, and Candy. Hmm... Oddly enough, that seems to fit the prediction of scum and an SK left... If he didn't include Dexter, we have a lot more work to do, and that includes looking into everybody. Clearly the first option is the easier one.

I'm trying to say that yes, I've played scum twice in a row and hosted a game since I've played as town. My last town game was in May, so forgive me for having a rough transition back to playing town. It's not that I'm not having townie thoughts, but lately I'm having a hard time expressing them into words, which is my own fault. Why claim? That's all I had to say, and there's no point in me claiming to have a role when I'm vanilla. It would be stupid of me no matter what affiliation I had to claim something that I wasn't unless I was sure that the role was dead, which would usually mean I'm scum.

Hoorah! Dexter was a Ferrarri! I'm going to apologize for being a bit out of control at the end of the day, I was admittedly tired and frustrated. Going by my previous suspicions, I'm going to guess that there's 4 of us Malones, 3 Ferrarris, and 1 Third Party or Serial Killer. I'm still wary of Colin being a Serial Killer, but he does seem to be trying to help us either way. Colin, I understand you are thinking of killing me. I want you to think about my previous gameplay, though. Have you, perhaps, noticed any reasons based on my past 2 or 3 games that might explain why I'm struggling as town? Really, think this through, let me answer any questions, and if you're still fixated on me being scum, then lynch me. My opinions have changed since I was suspicious of Kristina, and judging by what we have heard over the past few days, Kristina reads town to me currently. Kristina, is Person A still alive? If I were to pick three Ferrarris, they'd be Peter, Candy, and either Priscilla or Penelope, though I'm leaning more towards Priscilla.

Hmm, I don't know, maybe that we all be more vocal?! How do we know we haven't seen an SK? All I'm saying is it's quite possible you're the SK. From what we know, all Malones are dead, excluding the fates of Dexter, Rolfe, and Bernard. The vigilante could easily be one of those. It's like you aren't even reading my posts thoroughly. I specifically said that the time when we must lynch you is a time when we think we've nailed the Ferrarris down to one, and have an idea of who that last Ferrarri is. You also always seem to tunnel onto me when I receive a small bit of suspicion, bringing it to something bigger than it is. Don't even say that I'm trying to so confusion for trying to lynch a vigilante, because that's not true at all. The only thing townie about your claim is that there haven't been any counter claims. Yes, your targets seem to be attempts to help us, but they all have ended up town. Surely you would have been a little bit more careful with your decisions after all of your known kills have been town. I have no part in being scum, and if you are so strongly convinced that I'm scum, kill me. I dare you. It'll just be another false read, but you won't care, it's highly possible that you're an SK. You just want everybody dead. Ferrarris are our priority, as I said, so don't even say that I'm trying to get rid of you immediately. I doubt we'll catch any Ferrarris if you keep shoving words down my mouth as well, but there's little I can do about it. You'll never listen, you never have. I've given all the information I have, and whether you believe it or not is your own decision. If you choose not to, then this will be a rough game for the Malones.

No, no, that's Chillax Darth Frodo.

This one.... If Colin is a Serial Killer I do believe we should lynch him eventually, but at the same time the Ferrarris are out main worry, as we have gotten none to our knowledge. However, he does seem to be townsided at the moment so I see no use in getting rid of him now, as it's possible our vig is dead. We need the kill, and it seems no matter what that Colin is providing it for us. There will, however, come a time when lynching a suspected Serial Killer is our best option, such as when we're sure we're almost done catching the Ferrarris and have a good idea of who the final one is. Crap. Bernard is gone. We need to speak up now.

A serial killer. I believe his claim, or actually that he's at least a killer, which also leaves the possibility of a scum killer, but I'm willing to believe him about his kill targets. We've also consistently seen only two kills. It seems like there should be three, and I think there would be three. What happened to the second kill?

I actually think it's quite possible that our vig is dead. We haven't had any counter claims yet, and it seems to be said in the rules that we are likely facing a Third Party as well. This leads me to think SK, as I highly doubt there's a cult in such a small game. The one thing that leaves me confused as to his alliance are that his kills have been town-sided pretty consistently, so if he is an SK, he seems to be working with us, luckily.