Middle-Earth Madness - Ruins of Osgiliath vs The Golden Hall of Edoras

[Blakstone]

This is twelfth week of Middle-Earth Madness. Osgiliath is the new champion.

If you had to pick only one Dream set, which would it be?

Ruins of Osgiliath

OR

The Golden Hall of Edoras

Just like last week, these are dream sets so there is no hard or fast rule on what has to be included in either. Imagine you had a chance to greenlight just one LEGO Lord of the Rings set based on a simple description. Which one would you want?

Summary from previous weeks:

Week 11 - Ruins of Osgiliath defeats Minas Morgul 25 to 7

Week 10 - Minas Morgul flattens Fangorn Forest 29 to 1

Week 9 - Minas Morgul smashes the Gray Havens 30 to 5

Week 8 - Minas Morgul routes the Modor Battle Pack 25 to 16

Week 7 - Modor Battle Pack defeats Amon Hen 27 to 7

Week 6 - Modor Battle Pack defeats Lothlórien 24 to 14

Week 5 - Lothlórien defeats Prancing Pony 23 to 13

Week 4 - Lothlórien crashes Mount Doom 35 to 5

Week 3 - Mount Doom defeats the Rohan Battle Pack 14 to 11

Week 2 - Rohan Battle Pack defeats the Watcher in the Water 14 to 7

Week 1 - Rohan Battle Pack defeats The Green Dragon 23 to 4.

Have a Dream Set to nominate? Do so in this thread. I still have a bunch of sets to go.

[Moderators, can you convert this thread into a poll please?]

[Deathleech]

Ruins of Osgiliath again

[Dr.Cogg]

Ruins of Osgiliath

[Hammerhand]

Osgiliath, for the Gondor soldiers. Although I'd love an Edoras with more Rohirim.

[Alfadas]

Golden Halls of Edoras for me. Bewitched Theoden, a few Rohan soldiers, a couple of horses, lots of wood colored pieces.

[lord raphael]

Hall of Edoras and Osgiliath.Very hard choice.Osgiliath for me.

[Moexy]

Ruins of Osgiliath!

[deskp]

Osgiliath

[LegoPanda]

edoras, that is just beautiful

[AFOLguy1970]

We already have everything necessary to build the Golden Hall (parts and minifigs), so I vote Osgiliath.

[Brick Fiend]

Osgiliath again.

[Godless-Mimicry]

I say Osgiliath, but its bias on my part because I've already designed myself a Meduseld that I'm happy with.

[Blakstone]

Edoras for elderly Theoden, white clad Eowyn, Hama, and a cheaper Grima. Besides I think the build itself would be better than Osgiliath.

[Tuinman]

Golden Halls of Edoras for me. Bewitched Theoden, a few Rohan soldiers, a couple of horses, lots of wood colored pieces.

Exactly what i was thinking. So my vote goes to Edoras.

[Mahtion]

Osgiliath for Gondor!

[Cpt Rahmer]

I go with Ruins of Osgiliath!

[LegoThomas]

Osgiliath.

[skeaghshee]

Ruins of Osgiliath.

[Blazej_Holen]

Edoras

[krono111]

Golden Halls of Edoras for me. Bewitched Theoden, a few Rohan soldiers, a couple of horses, lots of wood colored pieces.

Well, like Tuinmann I think the same thing as you.

Edoras!

[Steel Tiger]

I have to say osgiliath even though Edoras was a close second.

[Brickadiergerard]

Edoras. Such an iconic location in the books and films; so many great MOCs; an official set would be fantastic.

[Brickdiction]

Golden Hall of Edoras for me, what a great build it could be.

[Yooha]

Golden Halls of Edoras over a bunch of grey bricks yet again.

[Hepitos]

Ruins of Osgiliath