Thack Desteck—Day 5, A Pain in the Butt

[Tameekys]

1 minute ago, Cadd said:

A thought from last night laying awake.

Araveea knew who the traveller was before Marwyyn told her. She asked me before Eeyara did how Scaboweewah learnt about the unlynch scroll. I replied I didn’t know there was one until she asked, but then rechecked PMs with Eeyara where she did tell me what the scroll was and I hadn’t paid attention to it. Her investigation result predates the possible traitor recall night two. If the investigator trusted her and brought her coralaazes scum result, she could have got in contact with scum to be recruited that night. She would have had to reveal the result, but would have argued caution, delaying the reveal as long as possible. 
oh wait, that’s what happened isn’t it? 
and the investigator is likely dead and can not confirm anything...

I actually thought the same thing as you, that Araveea was pulling some kind of grand play on us. I even said so a bit earlier in the day. Perhaps that's why Coralaaze was so content with being voted out and didn't say anything except for a cryptic message about Nancy. 

[Marwyyn]

Just now, Cadd said:

Strange. you told me in PMs that Araveea sent the day three scroll.

Who’s lying? You, the traveller or Araveea?

No one is lying because I said Araveea sent tha day Four scroll.  

[Hinckley]

Vote Tally

Tameekys: 2 (Zandder, Araveea)
Zandder: 1 (Tameekys)
Cadd: 2 (Marwyyn, Eeyara)
Eeyara: 2 (Nancy, Cadd)
Non-voters: 1 (Luxxon)

The player with the most votes will be pew-pewed. Currently, no player qualifies for the pew-pew. 7 hours remain in Day Five.

Just now, Cadd said:

vote:Eeyara

[Eeyara]

1 minute ago, Cadd said:

Who’s lying? You, the traveller or Araveea?

You. Nothing you say I'm threads and PMs matches up.

Scum splitting the vote again, just like day 1 and 2.

[Marwyyn]

Just now, Eeyara said:

You. Nothing you say I'm threads and PMs matches up.

Oh wait your right Cadd is lying. 

[Nancy]

Just now, Eeyara said:

Scum splitting the vote again, just like day 1 and 2.

The vote is split three ways and there's only one scum.

Actually, technically, four ways. 

[Tameekys]

I trust Nancy and Cadd more than anyone else. And like Nancy just said, there's only one scum left.

Unvote: Zandder 

Vote: Eeyara

Seven hours are left in the day, so I suppose I've got time to be persuaded otherwise. 

[Cadd]

Dammit. Need to read more closely. 
yes It was the day four scroll we were discussing 

apologies everyone

I will note Araveea may have known who the traveller was before getting the scroll.

[Marwyyn]

Are ya'll forgetting how much Coralaaze wanted to lynch Eeyara? What's everyone's opinion? That she's the Traitor?

[Cadd]

So assuming a player can’t receive more than one scroll (unjustified assumption, but possibly helpful)

I, Eeyara and Araveea can’t have got the day three scroll. Hence aren’t who Trav was referring to.

 

Unvote: Eeyara

Vote:Zandder

I’m sorry everyone for the chopping and changing. I do wish the traveller would simply speak up. Their silence is scummy. 

[Tameekys]

I voted for Zandder before, and nobody seemed to support me.

Unvote: Eeyara

Vote: Zandder

That will be final I think. Finally final. 

[Eeyara]

This is just rediculous. And the Traveler just sits there watching  us implode and laughing.

[Cadd]

Just now, Eeyara said:

This is just rediculous. And the Traveler just sits there watching  us implode and laughing.

If he’s laughing, they’re  not playing with town and I’ll help you lynch them.

[Eeyara]

48 minutes ago, Nancy said:

The vote is split three ways and there's only one scum.

Actually, technically, four ways. 

We don't know there's only one, there could be two if a conversion happened. Plus there is the Traveler who would want a townie lynched - not surprising he isn't voting until he finds a place it will stick.

Just now, Cadd said:

If he’s laughing, they’re  not playing with town and I’ll help you lynch them.

Obviously they are not

 

[Hinckley]

44 minutes ago, Tameekys said:

Unvote: Zandder 

Vote: Eeyara

39 minutes ago, Cadd said:

Unvote: Eeyara

Vote:Zandder

9 minutes ago, Tameekys said:

Unvote: Eeyara

Vote: Zandder

!
Vote Tally

Tameekys: 2 (Zandder, Araveea)
Cadd: 2 (Marwyyn, Eeyara)
Eeyara: 1 (Nancy)
Zandder: 2 (Cadd, Tameekys)
Non-voters: 1 (Luxxon)

The player with the most votes will be pew-pewed. Currently, no player qualifies for the pew-pew. 6 hours remain in Day Five.

[Cadd]

Just now, Eeyara said:

We don't know there's only one, there could be two if a conversion happened. Plus there is the Traveler who would want a townie lynched - not surprising he isn't voting until he finds a place it will stick.

Obviously they are not

 

We do know there’s only one. We’ve lynched two.

read night zero. 

there are two scum and a traitor. 

unless you’re suggesting something super paranoid like the day three scroll being a conversion.

And if it’s obvious they’re not laughing, why say they are?

If it’s obvious they’re not playing with town, make the case!

[Marwyyn]

Just heard from the Traveler. Nerrio was the day three scroll sender.

[Cadd]

One little mystery solved then.

please put Eeyaras mind at ease and tell us what the day three scroll is.

[Marwyyn]

They didn't say what it is but that it would cause confusion so they wouldn't use it.

You shouldn't care about lynching the Traveler because they're another player who isn't scum and can help find and lynch the last scum.  

[Cadd]

They haven’t been doing a good job of finding the last scum. They’ve haven’t contributed anything to today.

[Marwyyn]

1 minute ago, Cadd said:

They haven’t been doing a good job

Nor would you be if you lynched someone who you knew for a fact is not scum.

[Cadd]

Zandder? What facts do I know about him? What facts do you know?

or are you talking about your vote for non scum me?

[Eeyara]

27 minutes ago, Cadd said:

unless you’re suggesting something super paranoid like the day three scroll being a conversion. 

And if it’s obvious they’re not laughing, why say they are? 

God you are dense! I am not suggesting anything, I specifically said if there was a conversion then there is more than one.

My response was obviously they are not helping town.

Every post you make shows me how right I am with my vote.

[Marwyyn]

2 minutes ago, Cadd said:

Zandder? What facts do I know about him? What facts do you know?

or are you talking about your vote for non scum me?

I'm saying you'd be doing a bad job as a town member if you lynched someone you new wasn't scum, aka, the Traveler.

We were talking about the Traveler, so why would I suddenly be talking about someone else?

[Cadd]

21 minutes ago, Marwyyn said:

I'm saying you'd be doing a bad job as a town member if you lynched someone you new wasn't scum, aka, the Traveler.

We were talking about the Traveler, so why would I suddenly be talking about someone else?

Because I’m not lynching the traveller. Yet. Who knows who the fish Luxxon is voting for. He hasn’t even spoken today. You say you’ve been in contact with him. Who knows?

but the traveller is non town the fact that they’re non grogon doesn’t matter, especially if, as Eeyara suggests, they’re laughing and not working in our interests.

29 minutes ago, Eeyara said:

God you are dense! I am not suggesting anything, I specifically said if there was a conversion then there is more than one.

My response was obviously they are not helping town.

Every post you make shows me how right I am with my vote.

Obviously if they converted there is. 
my question was about HOW?
theres no mention of conversion as a power in night zero set up.

so it has to be a scroll right? 
And we know the what three of the fours scrolls do. 
so HOW could there be a conversion?

Got a suggestion for that?

 

if the traveller isn’t helping town, if you really think that, vote them.