Product Review: Comparison of LEGO and BrickForge Berets

[Cygnet]

The Mime from Series 2 of the LEGO Collectible Minifigures has introduced a beret in the pantheon of official minifigure accessories. Did you know, however, that berets have been available for quite some time through custom house BrickForge? The objective of this review is to compare the LEGO and BrickForge versions of the beret to allow fans to choose the right product for themselves.

LEGO Beret - 360 View

We turn first to the LEGO version of the beret which comes with The Mime from set 8684, Series 2 Collectible Minifigures. As with many LEGO pieces the hat is molded in ABS and has an asymmetrical design. As pictured here, there is a broader portion around the brim which tapers as you move (facing) from right to left. The design is such that if the tapered end were turned to the front it might also resemble a flat or ivy cap popularized by the Kangol brand and the actor Samuel L Jackson. The broader rim does leave some room for the addition of decals or painted highlights. The gripping or clutching power of this piece is quite firm as it utilizes a full tube inside the cap.

This item is only available in black with no indication of further use in other sets. The Mime is an uncommon figure in the series meaning that there are only four available on average per case of 60 figures.

BrickForge Beret - 360 View

Looking at the BrickForge option, we have a more rounded design with a deeper profile when sitting on the minifigure's head. As shown, this piece has a broad, high portion around the brim which tapers as you move (facing) from right to left. The tapered end differs from the LEGO design in that it is rounded and falls against the head in a more 'natural' form. The BF beret has a broader, taller brim allowing more room for decals or painted details.

The BrickForge piece does not appear to grip as tightly to the minifigure head when compared to the LEGO beret, but maintains connection. Armothe of BrickForge states that their tests show the clutching power of this piece is comparable to that of the LEGO Star Wars clone trooper helmet.

BrickForge has a wide assortment of berets available in their store. This design is currently offered in black, blue, dark green, medium blue, orange, pink, red, tan , white, and yellow.

"Clear out, clown! Let a real man through."

Although the the art of 'mime' is all well and good, we have asked our chief of security, Sgt. Fury, to step in model these two pieces with a more military style of minifigure (see below).

In summary, the new LEGO beret provides purists with a new headgear with tight, secure connections; however, supplies and color choices are quite limited.

The BrickForge option provides a rounded design with a high profile for custom touches, available in a wide color palate. Although the clutching power seemed less than the TLG part, it remained in place and was not a significant issue.

Additional Stats - BrickForge Beret

Custom House: BrickForge

Website: www.brickforge.com

Location: United States

International Shipping: Yes (details)

Colors Available: Black, Blue, Dark Green, Medium Blue, Orange, Pink, Red, Tan , White, and Yellow

Retail Price: $1.50 USD

Additional Stats - LEGO Beret

Availability: Worldwide but in limited quantities

Colors Available: Black

Retail Price: With Series 2 Collectible Minifigure, $1.99 USD (MSRP)/ Average BrickLink price (figure) ~$4.00 USD* / Average BrickLink price (beret only) $1.90 USD*

*BrickLink prices as of 9/9/2010

This review originally appeared at the minifigure blog 'The Ugly Duckling at BrickLink' on 9/10/2010.

[prateek]

I like the Lego version better, but as for price, I'd get the BF ones, because they are cheaper and come in different colours.

[XimenaPaulina]

I'd go with the BF ones in terms of design, variety of colors and price. Maybe a mod can set-up a poll for this?

[Aanchir]

Aesthetically, I like the LEGO one better. It doesn't fall around the head in a natural sort of shape, but then again we're not dealing with a head that has a natural sort of shape.

Besides, I'm confident that parts like this beret might appear in other sets, the same way the "skater hair" appeared in the promotional Max minifigure. What sorts of other sets it might appear in remains to be seen... unlike a hair piece, it's not necessarily a good fit for many themes.