Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Hello everyone. I was looking through old posts trying to find a picture of the preliminary troll impulse set, the one where the troll had armor and couldn't find any pics. I was wondering if anyone still has a picture. I searched brickshelf and didn't come across any. If anyone could help, it would be great.

Posted
Found it.

I was about to place the link and you have done it. Thanks. :tongue:

I must agreed that this version is much better than the current version. Read the reviews for comparison.

Posted

Thanks guys. I couldn't remember if the cart thing was different in the prelim. Seems its the same, but they switched out the crossbow for a wonderful flick fire and took away his armor.

Posted
Thanks guys. I couldn't remember if the cart thing was different in the prelim. Seems its the same, but they switched out the crossbow for a wonderful flick fire and took away his armor.

I would have liked it better when the ORC (a troll is something totally different, but then again TLC don't seem to have read Tolkien so...) would have gotten an armor, as well as weapon or 2-3 (a sword,a club and a crossbow), but I guess we will have to do it with this set. :hmpf_bad: Just like we need an entire artillery division of Orcs...I will rather buy more Orc "wenshes", those are soo cool (I mean the Orc Queen).

Posted

IMHO, I think the prelim set work well for me, due to its useful uncommon armor and crossbow, unlike changing it to a regular orc soldier with a flick fire missile feature. :thumbdown:

This is a review which I had done earlier and explained why I don't like the flick fire missile feature. :look:

  • 5 months later...
Posted
I would have liked it better when the ORC (a troll is something totally different, but then again TLC don't seem to have read Tolkien so...) would have gotten an armor, as well as weapon or 2-3 (a sword,a club and a crossbow), but I guess we will have to do it with this set. :hmpf_bad: Just like we need an entire artillery division of Orcs...I will rather buy more Orc "wenshes", those are soo cool (I mean the Orc Queen).

I think that LEGO was probably relying more on folklore than upon Tolkien. In different European folklores, there were two types of trolls: the giant ones which also appear in Tolkien, and the more human-sized ones. Usually, when a culture had both creatures in its mythos, the larger variety was referred to as an "ogre."

Plus, Tolkien's Orcs didn't have green skin.

Posted
I think that LEGO was probably relying more on folklore than upon Tolkien. In different European folklores, there were two types of trolls: the giant ones which also appear in Tolkien, and the more human-sized ones. Usually, when a culture had both creatures in its mythos, the larger variety was referred to as an "ogre."

Actually, ogres are a variant of giants, at least in folklore. They're taller than humans and also man-eaters. Trolls on the other hand can be defined in quite a many ways depending on the culture, as you said. In Nordic folklore (LEGO is a Danish company, after all), trolls are about human-sized, hairy creatures that dwell in dark caves and forests.

So yeah, the LEGO variant looks more like an orc, but since TLG calls them trolls, that's their official name. :wink:

Plus, Tolkien's Orcs didn't have green skin.

The Dungeons & Dragons version of orcs do have green skin, and they're the version that most fantasy products use as a source. Tolkien came up with the name, though.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...