Admiral Blockbeard Posted July 7, 2008 Posted July 7, 2008 I must admit you are slowly winning me over, logically argument is very persuading indeed however i still wish to know if you did anything more valuable than bonk the poor general? is any information to be gathered? As i am actionless at night, i always seek to find out how they work? it is one major flaw of my finding traitors...
Adam Posted July 7, 2008 Posted July 7, 2008 my kitty ate your chilly lizard, i am so sorry for your loss, if its any consolation she had a very big cough and drank lots of milk after that hot lizard... she suffered for an hour until a not so furry fur ball came up...although it is possible it is not your bob, how many chilly lizards are there? just so you know i think Marcus has come by already and given us some of his thoughts... Jamie Oliver has a chilli-lizard named Bob. Also, I have recieved a note that holds much wisdom: Byron has gastro-intestinal issues. Oops, wrong note . As freinds become enemies and allies become traitors, the only people we can surely trust are ourselves. You see? Not even Majiko or Dragonator or Ragnir can be trusted to some degree. When you think you know someone, they might turn into some Democratic campaign monster called Billary. Who knows? This means that Majiko's comment on making good food is pish posh. This means that what we ate this morning was pish posh, so vote: Jamie Oliver/Pish Posh. This means that everything I just said is pish posh, so unvote: whatever I just said.
Hinckley Posted July 7, 2008 Posted July 7, 2008 I must admit you are slowly winning me over, logically argument is very persuading indeed however i still wish to know if you did anything more valuable than bonk the poor general? is any information to be gathered? As i am actionless at night, i always seek to find out how they work? it is one major flaw of my finding traitors... I'm afraid that's as far as my powers go. All I know is I stopped him from doing something...Every other night I blocked someone else from doing their actions, they just wandered around and I did nothing to them. But, it can't be upon me to convince everyone that General Marcus is a traitor. You all need to make that decision on your own, before he comes after you at night...
commanderbly42 Posted July 7, 2008 Posted July 7, 2008 There's something about him being a traitor that just doesn't feel right. No person with reasonable intelligence would reveal themselves to the artist and to Kyle like that. They would have worn a disguise. Plus, I heard the General Marcus was inspecting the dungeons last night.
Hinckley Posted July 7, 2008 Posted July 7, 2008 Plus, I heard the General Marcus was inspecting the dungeons last night. And who did you hear that from?
commanderbly42 Posted July 7, 2008 Posted July 7, 2008 And who did you hear that from? I don't know. I didn't see them.
Hinckley Posted July 7, 2008 Posted July 7, 2008 I don't know. I didn't see them. Great way to make a case! It looks like the evidence is stacking up in the other direction now!
AgentRick Posted July 7, 2008 Posted July 7, 2008 (edited) (What grows in thy garden, my Lady? Perhaps you can tell us of your green thumb? I was growing some herbs for today's lunch, or do you mean metaphorically? The evidence given to us might lead to General Marcus, but what if someone produced a copy of his armor? Edited July 7, 2008 by AgentRick57
Zepher Posted July 7, 2008 Posted July 7, 2008 (edited) Mary: I have an idea! How about we ask the artist who was the killer! * Mary checks on the artist's room * Mary: Oh... he's dead as well... Now, what is all this talk of Calvin. He is dead and good riddance to him. Mary: I have advice for us all. Listen to Ritrigous... Ritgrious... Rit (I have a pet name for him?). He was the person who the killer was most likly after. He is therefore the most worried. Why would he not vote right away the obvious person who tried to kil him! Becasue he's smart! Remember, he is the only one of us to catch a traitor so far. He lead is in the killing of Lord Ash. Listen to him! Mary: In the artist chamber I found this picture. I have circled what I find suspect! Who is that? What could it mean! Where they stocking Grim? Edited July 7, 2008 by Zepher
commanderbly42 Posted July 7, 2008 Posted July 7, 2008 Mary, that's Kyle, the executioner. Great way to make a case! It looks like the evidence is stacking up in the other direction now! Sorry, the cellar door was closed and I didn't want to interrupt them or make it seem like I was spying.
Zepher Posted July 7, 2008 Posted July 7, 2008 Mary: My case, dear Celler keeper, is what was he doing there! Did he see the killer? He didn't make himself known to Grim, that's for sure. What was he doing? And can he solve the case of the killer?
Quarryman Posted July 7, 2008 Posted July 7, 2008 Mary: My case, dear Celler keeper, is what was he doing there! Did he see the killer? He didn't make himself known to Grim, that's for sure. What was he doing? And can he solve the case of the killer? He's already told us about that. So alas, he can't help us identify the killer. I'm afraid that's as far as my powers go. All I know is I stopped him from doing something...Every other night I blocked someone else from doing their actions, they just wandered around and I did nothing to them. But, it can't be upon me to convince everyone that General Marcus is a traitor. You all need to make that decision on your own, before he comes after you at night... Lord Savril, you have (for the time being anyway) convinced me at least, I vote Batbrick / General Marcus.
Zepher Posted July 7, 2008 Posted July 7, 2008 Mary: Oops, sorry! I apologize. However, I wait to see what Rit says before casting my vote.
iamded Posted July 7, 2008 Posted July 7, 2008 I suggest that we turn our efforts towards General Spencer instead. I have been watching him closely over the past few days. He and Lady Suzanne should be questioned immediately. I would be happy to answer any questions you have for me, Father.
Adam Posted July 7, 2008 Posted July 7, 2008 Sorry, the cellar door was closed and I didn't want to interrupt them or make it seem like I was spying. Well that's a good excuse . For now, though, I agree with Lord Sarvil and vote: Batbrick/General Marcus. I'm suprised he hasn't spoken up much lately, as he's been accused quite a bit. I may unvote him if he has a good alibi, but for now it's like he's letting us kill him off .
Dragonator Posted July 7, 2008 Author Posted July 7, 2008 I've just received another note. It says:You should've known the pussy would eat the snake... Wrong, just so badly wrong. Right, I must make a quick game-moderator note. Stop moaning! Could you please not edit your posts? Yes that's you Zepher and AgentRick57. It is against the rules, for whatever reason. Don't let me see it happen again. Right, there must be another reason I decided to say something? Oh no, that was me. Oh, well, er, go right ahead then. Excellent. Firstly, my rooms are out of bounds. If I see anyone near them, I'll put Ragnir onto them. Here here! And I do not turn into a monster! Really? Well, not a Democratic campaign monster anyway. Maybe that other ghastly one, but I haven't done that in years. Not since that peasant splattered mud all over your brand new cape. Those were the good times. Can we start talking about something proper now? These people are getting far to off topic as it is without you and I starting it. Good point. Ragnir would like to inform you about the building challenge. I sure do! As you all may know, I am running the official Mystery Castle Building Challenge! The entries thread is now up, and if you want to discuss anything, have any questions, or just want to check the rules, then please do that here. You've all got around 10 days, so plenty f time to get in a great entry. So, think of something funny, or serious, whatever you wish, and get building! I look forward to seeing your entries! Thanks Ragnir. Now, on with the game, and don't talk to me, 'cause I don't exist.
commanderbly42 Posted July 7, 2008 Posted July 7, 2008 Well that's a good excuse Well, what did you want me to do? You know how creaky the door is, I could have given up my chance to hear some information. Anyhow, it could have been two of the guards. They're always passing the cellar as the dungeons are nearby. Or Kyle, he's stationed nearby. Other than them, no-one regularly uses the hallway except for either Damien or Mary, and that's just in emergencies when either a guard (or prisoner) is sick or when Kyle has done his job and needs some cleaning up after. So either, Marcus is innocent or one of them were spreading rumours outside of my cellar.
Adam Posted July 7, 2008 Posted July 7, 2008 Excellent. Firstly, my rooms are out of bounds. If I see anyone near them, I'll put Ragnir onto them. Good thing Bob just crawled in! Also, I got this note: Ragnir looked like this: before plastic surgery. Uhhh... oooookkaaayyy. What does that mean ? What's plastic surgery?
WesternOutlaw Posted July 8, 2008 Posted July 8, 2008 I would be happy to answer any questions you have for me, Father. General Spencer: In the name of All Things Good, you shall speak the truth of last night regarding your wereabouts, or forever be doomed to the fiery plane of torment! I notice that you wear the same cape as General Marcus. Could you explain? How difficult would it have been for you to change your pants to those of General Marcus? Where were you last night? I don't trust you General Spencer and I will be watching you closely (looks around for shooting arrows from the sky). General Marcus: I'm sorry that I must ask you these personal questions. I believe you are a man of faith and innocent of these wrong doings. Do you take your pants off to sleep? If so, where do you place them? Do you keep your room locked? If so, who else might have a key (perhaps another General, and I don't mean Veers). Have you ever served as an alter boy? OK, strike that last one. All Generals who are guilty of wrong-doing, please take a step forward. NOT SO FAST General Spencer! At least not until you answer my questions. Early Medieval Telephone Invented by Galileo Call for General Spencer, it's for you... It's General Marcus, he wants his pants back! And Lady Suzanne: Where art thou?
Shadows Posted July 8, 2008 Posted July 8, 2008 Anyone looking to me for guidance at this point is probably going to be disappointed. I've been reviewing what we know and what we think we know and what we've been told, and it's all too contradictory. We see a picture that seems to point at General Marcus. The witness sees this figure from the front, but described the back of his cape, down to the dragon colour. Technically impossible, since we're to believe he ran like a little girl instead of sticking around to help his superior. We're told by Majiko that he wouldn't commit a murder without a disguise, thus throwing a shadow of doubt on the whole description of the killer. Lord Ash, a known traitor, and his mercenary Calvin, both accused Marcus of being a traitor, and I have a hard time believing anything they had to say. Friar Brown, once adamant about the guilt of Marcus, now defends him and wants to explore other suspects. Lord Savril whacked General Marcus in the head for some night action, but we don't know what and neither does he. Maybe Marcus could reveal his night action? General Spencer killed a loyalist and confessed to it right in the middle of all of this, so we know that he can kill people, and picks badly. How do we know he hasn't done that again? Oh, and lets go back to day 1. The doctor and the cellar keeper never did end up investigated. It's like we dropped the whole poison thing... or were we intentionally distracted? See? It's a mess. I'm not going to vote for convenience and then shrug it off if we're wrong. We can't afford to lose loyalists like that, we've lost enough already. I'm waiting for someone to come up with something conclusive that hasn't been contradicted.
WesternOutlaw Posted July 8, 2008 Posted July 8, 2008 I've been reviewing what we know and what we think we know and what we've been told, and it's all too contradictory.Friar Brown, once adamant about the guilt of Marcus, now defends him and wants to explore other suspects. Perhaps, but I have seen and heard things that I can not speak of. I would ask that you trust me and have faith in my wisdom. Let the Generals answer my questions and then decide who is lying. What else would you do given these bits of truth and deception... Rely on the insticts of Puss Cats? We also need to explore the Garden of the Lady Suzanne. I'm very interested in knowing what exactly she grows in the courtyard garden??? POISON, perhaps...
Hinckley Posted July 8, 2008 Posted July 8, 2008 General Spencer killed a loyalist and confessed to it right in the middle of all of this, so we know that he can kill people, and picks badly. How do we know he hasn't done that again? What? Who? When? Only important people can kill at night. Shouldn't we be killing him so he doesn't come and kill us?
Shadows Posted July 8, 2008 Posted July 8, 2008 Perhaps, but I have seen and heard things that I can not speak of. I would ask that you trust me and have faith in my wisdom. Let the Generals answer my questions and then decide who is lying. Sounds like a good place to start. One of them had better sell me on their story, because I'm fairly sure the other is a murderer. What else would you do given these bits of truth and deception... Rely on the insticts of Puss Cats? Just wrong. We also need to explore the Garden of the Lady Suzanne. I'm very interested in knowing what exactly she grows in the courtyard garden??? POISON, perhaps... Yes, she's another on the long list of people we haven't bothered to check out thoroughly, and having been married to Lord Ash, she definitely has some explaining to do concerning what she did and did not know of his evil plans.
WesternOutlaw Posted July 8, 2008 Posted July 8, 2008 About Puss Cats: Just wrong. LOL Wait, I'm having another .
Adam Posted July 8, 2008 Posted July 8, 2008 Anyone looking to me for guidance at this point is probably going to be disappointed. I've been reviewing what we know and what we think we know and what we've been told, and it's all too contradictory.We see a picture that seems to point at General Marcus. The witness sees this figure from the front, but described the back of his cape, down to the dragon colour. Technically impossible, since we're to believe he ran like a little girl instead of sticking around to help his superior. We're told by Majiko that he wouldn't commit a murder without a disguise, thus throwing a shadow of doubt on the whole description of the killer. Lord Ash, a known traitor, and his mercenary Calvin, both accused Marcus of being a traitor, and I have a hard time believing anything they had to say. Friar Brown, once adamant about the guilt of Marcus, now defends him and wants to explore other suspects. Lord Savril whacked General Marcus in the head for some night action, but we don't know what and neither does he. Maybe Marcus could reveal his night action? General Spencer killed a loyalist and confessed to it right in the middle of all of this, so we know that he can kill people, and picks badly. How do we know he hasn't done that again? Oh, and lets go back to day 1. The doctor and the cellar keeper never did end up investigated. It's like we dropped the whole poison thing... or were we intentionally distracted? See? It's a mess. I'm not going to vote for convenience and then shrug it off if we're wrong. We can't afford to lose loyalists like that, we've lost enough already. I'm waiting for someone to come up with something conclusive that hasn't been contradicted. What a mess . Alright then, unvote: Batbrick/General Marcus and vote: Puss Cats/Wrong. Just wrong. I Bob.
Recommended Posts