Opinions Needed

[TheBeeze]

I had posted a separate topic earlier with a Poll and then was told after the fact that polls apparently are not working right now. Soooooo I need some feedback from all of you here. Please feel free to elaborate in your comments and add to the discussion, more information is always welcome. 

Which method would you prefer we use for GBW in scoring builds?

Players are given either a pass or fail on a build and awarded points based on the type of build.

Each build is judged and scored based on how it is judged.

[marvelBoy123]

I think a mix of both is probably good depending on the type of build. For free builds an individual score is probably best - a score that of course reflects quality but also gives beginners a chance to gain a few points and get some feedback. That said, on some of the larger missions, the pass or fail system has worked well to encourage a high level of building.

 

[TheBeeze]

18 hours ago, marvelBoy123 said:

I think a mix of both is probably good depending on the type of build. For free builds an individual score is probably best - a score that of course reflects quality but also gives beginners a chance to gain a few points and get some feedback. That said, on some of the larger missions, the pass or fail system has worked well to encourage a high level of building.

 

so your proposing that the smaller free builds be scored but the bigger more detailed contest builds just be pass or fail? That's a little backwards from what we had in mind and might complicate picking a winner. 

Need more feedback from others. 

[marvelBoy123]

8 minutes ago, TheBeeze said:

so your proposing that the smaller free builds be scored but the bigger more detailed contest builds just be pass or fail? That's a little backwards from what we had in mind and might complicate picking a winner. 

Need more feedback from others. 

I wasn't thinking about big contest builds being pass or fail - that would probably be unfair given how much effort goes into them .There were those mission things for certain players in the last round that worked quite well as pass and fail though.

[TheBeeze]

To give you an idea of more of what we're working on here, our discussions with regards to next game and build types goes something like this. 

Players will have certain types of small builds they can do to earn some points / money right away (Establishing a country flag = x points, introducing a commander = x points, common builds (life on base, range time, travelling, etc = x points)

Turn based builds for conquering territory = x points

Campaigns / Contest builds would be a bit more in depth

[ParmBrick]

Good evening everyone. Here is my idea for the voting system of the creations for the next phase: every creation outside the "main quests" should be evaluated with 3 criteria: originality, technique, relevance. 3 votes from 1 to 10, which make up the average final grade, with obviously the following comment. There should also be special missions to earn fictitious virtual money, and not points, that you can invest in a paid system to get special support, supplies, resources and intelligence from "black market" that you can use in the main quests. The main quests, i.e. campaigns, contests and territories conquest should be evaluated with the aforementioned criteria, plus a bonus criterion (from 1 to 10) at the discretion of the judges (which can be for example: troop deployment, stealth tactics, environmental destruction, etc.), which must be imposed and changed every few turns in the game.

[TheBeeze]

On 1/12/2021 at 10:52 AM, ParmBrick said:

All of it

We have things in the work for a money system as well. Details on that are being worked out now. We've actually reached out to the people who run the pirates game and they have been very helpful in explaining their system for how things work and things that may work well for us in GBW. 

[SATSOK]

On 1/15/2021 at 6:57 PM, TheBeeze said:

We have things in the work for a money system as well. Details on that are being worked out now. We've actually reached out to the people who run the pirates game and they have been very helpful in explaining their system for how things work and things that may work well for us in GBW. 

GREAT !!!

... i cant wait ...