Bixby Bunny Posted August 14, 2020 Posted August 14, 2020 Looks like Caladon probably had the rolestopper. It's not obvious who he would have used it on. We had a bunch of unsuccessful people, but all would be explained by the scum turning off investigative roles. So probably Caladon targeted one of them and his role was useless. His action would have gone thru before he was killed, correct?
Franczeska Fox Posted August 14, 2020 Posted August 14, 2020 *hic* my apologies, I didn't register the differenccee between rolewatcherr and watcherr as separate roless.
Holbrook Horse Posted August 14, 2020 Posted August 14, 2020 3 hours ago, Gilford Goat said: Me kill mouse. Me sorry. Me glad though me played it safe. Could have been worse. 1 hour ago, Parvani Poodle said: Either way, faced with the difficult task of choosing targets basically in the dark I decided to deflect whatever was thrown at Caladon towards Gilford. I certainly didn't expect Scum to target Gilford who was either 1) Scum himself or 2) a good lynch candidate on Day 2 based on the amount of votes he got yesterday. It does look like either my plan back-fired, or Scum got to Caladon before I switched him. if you switched Caladon and Gilford then Caladon got the kill that was targeted at Gilford... either you were successful or you werent, either caladon & gilford got switched or they werent. Taking Francadslfkjxzc;v and Gilford at face value, then scum tried to kill Gillyboy and that means we have a confirmed town yeah? Guess that takes the sting out of my failed investigation on Marlowe. 1 hour ago, Parvani Poodle said: It would seem that I was wrong. about as wrong as it seems you are about your own night action! mmmm hay, good to calm my nerves.
Rutherford Raccoon Posted August 14, 2020 Posted August 14, 2020 Ah! Manly Mouseketeer and Caiman Consular, to be struck down! That blade pierce your hearts - should have rather it were mine that we might still have you Among Us! May your body is drift up on Heavenly anima and find peace beyond the cosmos! With the coming of the the crepuscular hours, I held the task of compulsive rules stopper where I could Shield one fellow from any Targeting - with the coming of the Dawn I find my mind heavy and unable to remember, as if a New Soul looked out these eyes. But perhaps when my p.m. comes I shall remember. Till then I shall read and refresh my memory. 1 hour ago, Bixby Bunny said: Looks like Caladon probably had the rolestopper. It's not obvious who he would have used it on. We had a bunch of unsuccessful people, but all would be explained by the scum turning off investigative roles. So probably Caladon targeted one of them and his role was useless. His action would have gone thru before he was killed, correct? Why "probably" friend? What made you think he had it?
Parvani Poodle Posted August 14, 2020 Posted August 14, 2020 10 minutes ago, Holbrook Horse said: if you switched Caladon and Gilford then Caladon got the kill that was targeted at Gilford... either you were successful or you werent, either caladon & gilford got switched or they werent. Taking Francadslfkjxzc;v and Gilford at face value, then scum tried to kill Gillyboy and that means we have a confirmed town yeah? Guess that takes the sting out of my failed investigation on Marlowe. For what it's worth, I was told my Driving was successful. So if I managed to deflect the Scum kill away from Gilford, it does suggest that he is Town... or at least not-Scum. And for the record... Final Vote tally (Day 1) Mobley Mouse: 6 (Hyacinth Hippo, Corrina Cow, Benicia Bear, Caladon Crocodile, Bixby Bunny, Emeric Elephant)Hyacinth Hippo: 2 (Marlowe Monkey, Leatrix Lamb)Gilford Goat: 4 (Parvani Poodle, Franczeska Fox, Holbrook Horse, Shainen Sheepdog)Bartosz Bulldog: 1 (Gilford Goat)Rutherford Raccoon: 1 (Bartosz Bulldog) Non-voters: 2 (Mobley Mouse, Rutherford Raccoon)
Rutherford Raccoon Posted August 14, 2020 Posted August 14, 2020 A few moments reflection does wonders! Last night I roll stopped myself after targeting Shainon! I am still pondering the logic but why are several suddenly in agreement that Guilford is town? Has a haze of sudden Concordance descended upon us? Why has the possibility that he is a scum killer not even been raised? I suspect in all these people agreeing there's at least one scum if not more.
Parvani Poodle Posted August 14, 2020 Posted August 14, 2020 9 minutes ago, Rutherford Raccoon said: I am still pondering the logic but why are several suddenly in agreement that Guilford is town? Has a haze of sudden Concordance descended upon us? Why has the possibility that he is a scum killer not even been raised? How does that work out? If Gilford is the Scum killer, are you implying that he tried to kill himself but got switched with Caladon? Slight correction: Final Vote tally (Day 1) Mobley Mouse: 6 (Hyacinth Hippo, Corrina Cow, Benicia Bear, Caladon Crocodile, Bixby Bunny, Emeric Elephant)Hyacinth Hippo: 2 (Marlowe Monkey, Leatrix Lamb)Gilford Goat: 4 (Parvani Poodle, Franczeska Fox, Holbrook Horse, Shainen Sheepdog)Bartosz Bulldog: 1 (Gilford Goat)Rutherford Raccoon: 1 (Bartosz Bulldog) Non-voters: 2 (Mobley Mouse, Rutherford Raccoon)
Rutherford Raccoon Posted August 14, 2020 Posted August 14, 2020 31 minutes ago, Parvani Poodle said: How does that work out? If Gilford is the Scum killer, are you implying that he tried to kill himself but got switched with Caladon? Fair friend, that's not how bus-driving works! You did not switch the actions made - you switched those that targeted them - unless you have some new variant? There is no need for Guilford to attack himself, merely someone else. A vigilante or killer Attacks him and you switch to Caledon.
Leatrix Lamb Posted August 14, 2020 Posted August 14, 2020 Baaaaa. Let's first update Bartosz's overview: -------------------------------------------------- Scum get their factional kill Scum get a Switch (the switch blocks one type of role, active (Blocker, Vigilante, Protector), informative (Tracker, Watcher, Investigator, Voyeur), manipulative (Mirror, Bus Driver, Rolestopper) I believe they chose to block informative, hence my failure to track and Leatrix's failure to watch. Compulsive Tracker * Bartosz Bulldog: Tracked Benica Bear. Unsuccessful. Compulsive Watcher * Leatrix Lamb: Watched Mobley. Unsuccessful. Compulsive Investigator * Holbrook Horse: Investigated Marlowe Monkey. Unsuccessful. Compulsive Voyeur * Emeric Elephant: Voyeured Mobley Mouse. Unsuccessful. Compulsive Blocker * Marlowe Monkey: Block Shainen Sheepdog. Unsuccessful. Compulsive Vigilante * Gilfoard Goat: Killed Mobley Mouse. Successful. Compulsive Protector * Bixby Bunny: Protect Benicia Bear. Successful. Mirror * Shainen Sheepdog. Seemingly Successful in reflecting Marlowe's block and Rutherford Raccoon's rolestop. Compulsive Bus Driver * Parvani Poodle: Drove the bus on Gilford Goat and Caladon Crocodile. Successful. Compulsive Rolestopper * Rutherford Raccoon: Rolestopped Shainen Sheepdog. Successful, rolestopped himself instead. Falsifier (Can make one one-shot Action FALSE, recipient gets three options) * presumably Benicia Bear, and presumably nothing? Normalizer (reverts a falsified Action back to Normal) * Hyacinth Hippo: Corrina Cow. Role Watcher (sees which role targets a person, including if it's been falsified or not)* Franczeska Fox: Watch Mobley. Successful. Saw that he was targeted by the vig killer. Encryptor (If given to Scum, they are able to communicate during the Day) Virgin Compulsive Hooker Hated Loved Priest *indicates required, the Trickster must assign these roles20. Baby Dwagon Lullaby Corrina Cow: Benica. Successful.21. Baby Dwagon Slumber Party" Mobley. He dead fam -------------------------------------------------- With eeeeveryone but Benicia awake now, I see no glaaaaaring inconsistencies in the claims made. Seems like the baby dragon haters managed to successfully switch off inveeeeeestigative actions and Marlowe's block apparently baaaaaackfired and blocked his own block, which is backed up by Rutherford's "mirrored" rolestop on Shainen. I would appreeeeeeciate hearing a little more justificaaaaaation for some night action choices though... 10 hours ago, Marlowe Monkey said: I attempted to block Shanien Sheepdog but was unsuccessful. Why Shainen? 9 hours ago, Franczeska Fox said: *hic* I was a rolewatcher, so I decides to watch Mobley anddd see what *hic* appens, he was targeted by a compulsive vig, so sooommeeeone got reccklesss *hic* last night. Presumabbbly the *hic* loss of our loyal croc was the scuummm facction kill *hic* I assume you targeted Mobley for the same reason I did? 8 hours ago, Holbrook Horse said: I guess I'm the third to report in, I tried to investigate Marlowe in the night but was unsuccessful. Why Marlowe? 8 hours ago, Hyacinth Hippo said: I felt special, so I targeted Corrina Cow. Why Corrina? 7 hours ago, Gilford Goat said: Me kill mouse. Me sorry. Me glad though me played it safe. Why Mobley? If you suspected him of being a baby dragon haaaaaaater, why didn't you vote for him yesterdaaaaay? And if you didn't suspect him: why did you kill him? 5 hours ago, Emeric Elephant said: I was the Voyeur and also received the unsuccessful result with targeting Mobley. It's ok, we forgive you. Why Mobley? Again, I assume you had the same reasons I had. 5 hours ago, Bixby Bunny said: Looks like Caladon probably had the rolestopper. It's not obvious who he would have used it on. We had a bunch of unsuccessful people, but all would be explained by the scum turning off investigative roles. So probably Caladon targeted one of them and his role was useless. His action would have gone thru before he was killed, correct? Rolestopper stops any roles performed on the target. It's not a roleblocker. WIth Rutherford claiming rolestopper, Caladon probably haaaaaaaaad one of the non-mandatory roles. If he was a virgin, any night-kills the coming night would be blocked. Looks like that would only affeeeeect the vig though, with the scum kill being a bomb that only goes off on night three.
Gilford Goat Posted August 14, 2020 Posted August 14, 2020 2 hours ago, Leatrix Lamb said: Why Mobley? If you suspected him of being a baby dragon haaaaaaater, why didn't you vote for him yesterdaaaaay? And if you didn't suspect him: why did you kill him? I did suspect him, and it seemed like a lot of people genuinely did as well, so that's why I didn't help lynch him because I wanted to kill him. I guess I could have asked first. Remember I had to use it. Anyone else I could have killed would have had to been on my own suspect list.
Marlowe Monkey Posted August 14, 2020 Posted August 14, 2020 3 hours ago, Leatrix Lamb said: Why Shainen? Just a hunch I guess. I was going to go for Hyacinth Hippo but a gut feeling told me to go for Shainen.
Parvani Poodle Posted August 14, 2020 Posted August 14, 2020 6 hours ago, Rutherford Raccoon said: Fair friend, that's not how bus-driving works! You did not switch the actions made - you switched those that targeted them - unless you have some new variant? There is no need for Guilford to attack himself, merely someone else. A vigilante or killer Attacks him and you switch to Caledon. Let me try to understand this... You wondered whether Gilford could be the Scum killer, right? No one other than him claimed Vigilante, and we don't know if there are third parties who can kill at night. If Gilford was the Scum killer, then he killed Mobley, and Caladon was actually the Vig but didn't get to kill, but someone else actually tried to kill Gilford and ended up killing Caladon instead? It implies that Gilford knew that he was killing the Vig, so it seems rather far fetched.
Marlowe Monkey Posted August 14, 2020 Posted August 14, 2020 Let’s look at the voting pattern yesterday: On 8/9/2020 at 5:30 PM, Emeric Elephant said: Lucky! In the case of voting, I'm going with a wakeup poke vote. @Bixby Bunny. Vote: Bixby Bunny So Emeric votes first. He votes for Bixby as a poke vote as Bixby hadn’t said anything at that point. I don’t think Emeric was aware of the certificate issue at the time of voting. On 8/10/2020 at 2:24 AM, Hyacinth Hippo said: Ouch! I seem to have stubbed my toe. Please, friends, I need medical assistance! Why don't we have a doctor onboard? We need to vote. I'm going to: Vote: Mobley Mouse Because I found it a bit suspect that he said we should all claim, then backtracked on it, and then tried to say that he didn't actually say we should all claim. Next Hycainth Hippo votes for Mobley. Hyacinth hasn said much up until this point but votes anyway. On 8/10/2020 at 11:28 AM, Parvani Poodle said: Ok thanks for settling that. So it's the equivalent of being vanilla for one night. Voting is mandatory, and I don't feel there's much to go on at the moment, but if I had to choose right now I would Vote: Gilford Goat. That "we should just all claim, wouldn't if be fun" comment early on was just slightly... either devious or naive? Probably the latter but it's the only hunch I have for now, with things being quiet and players missing and all. Parvati then votes for Gilford Goat for his comment about claiming for fun. On 8/10/2020 at 12:13 PM, Marlowe Monkey said: Vote: Hyaclinth Hippo I then vote for Hippo for sitting on the fence and not taking a clear stance. On 8/10/2020 at 12:13 PM, Corrina Cow said: Vote: Mobley Mouse And then there is this. I really doubt that with enough roles to choke an entire stable, there would be additional roles created for nothing but amusement value when the host could just do those actions on their own, like all the other amusement value based pictures. The poor hippo is going to end up with a concussion, are we supposed to believe that was a daytime role for amusement value? Of course not, that's just the host taking liberties with our bodies, as hosts tend to do, no special role required. He has an STD! That was silly, but accurate! Corina votes for Mobley because of his backtracking and the fact Mobley might be lying about the true meaning of his role we also find out Mobley might have an STD. On 8/10/2020 at 6:02 PM, Franczeska Fox said: *hic* This shipp has some serwious issues with doors. So thatt's all you have for this post, just a casual suggestion*hic* that we don't lynchh anyone and take a no iinfo apppproach into day 2? We're on an extenddded day for *hic* reaasons but iff aniimals showw up *hic* we can gettt more discussionsss thann norrmal *hic* Vote: Gilforddd *hic* Goat Ohhh, itt was *hic* comedic. Uh huhhhh Fox then votes for Gifford Goat for his casual suggestion. Franczeska hasn’t said much up until this point and this vote feels somewhat bandwagon-y given Poodle has already voted. On 8/10/2020 at 6:10 PM, Leatrix Lamb said: It's a bloody shame Bixby and Rutherford are showing so little interest in our wool fur hunt for the baby dragon haters. We'll just have to wait and see if and when they show up. I agree with Marlowe's reasoning for voting Hyacinth. As also pointed out by Benicia earlier, that fence she's on is a nice comfy place in the middle (of her big hippo bum, her butt crack must hurt though). Vote: Hyacinth Hippo Leatrix then votes for Hippo for more a less the sam reasons as me. I don’t consider it as bandwagon-y as The fox since Leatrix has contributed more to the discussion. I’ll analyse the rest of the votes in a second post.
Benicia Bear Posted August 14, 2020 Posted August 14, 2020 OH DEAR OH DEAR OH DEAR! ITS SOMETHING OCLOCK IN THE MORNING AND ALL IS NOT WELL! But I look hot af in these slamming new pants and shirt! 14 hours ago, Corrina Cow said: I ended up with the Baby Dragon Lullaby, which I used on Benicia as she seems very townie to me. The role is a weak protector, giving the target 25% kill immunity. I am told it was successful, so I wasn't blocked or anything, as far as I can tell. SO THAT EXPLAINS why I was told I sang a lullaby to a baby dwagon last night, so I can confirm you did what you said you did. 14 hours ago, Marlowe Monkey said: speaking of which I had an excellent dream last night about some sherbet lemons... another time maybe... You were clearly dreaming of my bitchin' new shirt. 11 hours ago, Bixby Bunny said: Bad morning, y'all. I was successful in protecting Benicia. Also, I'm curious if Mobley was telling the truth about that slumber party.... since the lullaby had additional abiliity beyond just being for amusement. Firstly, thank you and secondly I don't think he would have lied considering he was town. Maybe it's what Corrina said about him not wanting to share an additional purpose. 11 hours ago, Corrina Cow said: In the end, the lullaby didn't even have amusement value. I was disappointed by that, I expected a little entertainment for the babies. They got entertained, I SANG THE FIRST LULLABY THAT CAME TO MY HEAD AND IT JUST SO HAPPENED TO BE THE BEST LULLABY IN THE WORLD! 7 hours ago, Rutherford Raccoon said: I am still pondering the logic but why are several suddenly in agreement that Guilford is town? Has a haze of sudden Concordance descended upon us? Why has the possibility that he is a scum killer not even been raised? 6 hours ago, Rutherford Raccoon said: There is no need for Guilford to attack himself, merely someone else. A vigilante or killer Attacks him and you switch to Caledon. If you're going to say Caladon was the vig and killed Mobley (and we know the vig killed Mobley unless Franczeska's lying), then the scum would still have been trying to kill Gilford even if that was some elaborate plan to kill Caladon. Would scum be able to give up a compulsory action like Busdriver in favor of killing? I think that's the only way it could really make sense, but Parvani seems genuine and it's a pretty far-fetched way of trying to confirm one of your own. 39 minutes ago, Gilford Goat said: I did suspect him, and it seemed like a lot of people genuinely did as well, so that's why I didn't help lynch him because I wanted to kill him. I guess I could have asked first. Remember I had to use it. Anyone else I could have killed would have had to been on my own suspect list. THAT.. that actually makes sense. So some more information on the Falsifier role I had. I could target the Investigator and make it insane, the protector nd turn it into a bodyguard and the mirror to turn it into a deflector. Not particularly sinister roles apart from the insane investigator, but I didn't see any help in using the role, which is why I was happy to stay home. And sing to BABY DWAGONS as it turns out. Everyone seems to have claimed a role and some of them have even been verified (not to say the animal has, though) for instance I am happy enough to think that Corrina wasn't off murdering Caladon as she was busy forcing me to sing (that requires the not unusual assumption that scum can only use one night action at a time).
Marlowe Monkey Posted August 14, 2020 Posted August 14, 2020 On 8/10/2020 at 7:31 PM, Holbrook Horse said: I've been stuck between Mr. No-I-Didn't-Backtrack and Mr. Pot-Calling-Kettle. But Mobley's candor of late contrasts with Gilford's lack of substantive contribution (speaking of, where's@Caladon Crocodile?) so I'll Vote: Gilford Goat Holbrook then votes for Gifford after a toss up between him and Mobley. On 8/10/2020 at 9:48 PM, Benicia Bear said: EMPHASIS mine. I am almost certain there aren't any ANIMALS here who haven't been on a boat at LEAST SIMILAR to this before. I don't think this is all that new. Second hand and recycled, really. NOT SURE I'm going to buy that you can't Englishly good when you can chat about the INTERROGATIVE, subjunctive and declarative. I'M BEARLY LITERATE MYSELF Yeah I'm proud of that joke but the the subjunctive refers to things that SHOULD HAPPEN, and perish the thought IT might not. I'M actually INCLINED TO believe you about the role YOU CLAIMED, as that was HOW I interpreted OMROM's response to me, but implying that OBVIOUSLY we were all going to claim and then blaming what you said on badly englishing when you SEEM TO KNOW a lot about it, well, that seems disingenuous to me. Never thought I'd vote for someone over grammar Vote: Mobley Mouse Benicia then votes for Mobley about the Slumber Party role thing. On 8/10/2020 at 9:52 PM, Shainen Sheepdog said: We don't always get it right on day one, but a lynch will give us information about alignment and lets us review today's interactions and posts with more information. Vote: Gilbert Goat Between first suggesting revealing roles that I really don't think should be revealed, to saying we should all reveal (conveniently now called as wanting to create a shitstorm) and being happy to point to the mouse, it feels like he is helping scum more than town. @Hinckley, I think you missed one: Why do you think so? Do you mean just for your role? Shainen then votes for Gilford. On 8/11/2020 at 3:03 AM, Bixby Bunny said: Whew. What a day already. Sorry for not being around much [real-world issues got in the way, so I appreciate the host extending the day due to circumstances] and there's so much to process. And don't believe what you hear about bunnies and carrot-eating - our eyesight SUCKS. Makes it slow to get thru all this. Bulldog, I appreciated your translation of the list! No, I don't think you're making it up. It's clearly a real thing. But I don't buy that it's a nothing/vanilla/just-for-fun role. My gut says you're hiding your real role - and that'd be a BIG gamble, hoping that no one actually got the slumber party today. Unless, of course, you're scum and a fellow scum buddy got the slumber party and y'all have the encryptor. I guess you want to hide your real ability and screw with us - and us bunnies like to screw, not be screwed with. Vote: Mobley Mouse Go check the logs of the previous boat and you'll see a distinct lack of bunnies. Also, care to explain what the "3 options" part of the falsifier role is? Might help us in the future to know what all it can do in case it falls into the wrong hands. Bixby then votes for Mobley. This is also feels like a bandwagon-y vote. Bixby hasn’t said anything so far and it feels as though he’s just jumped on the first bandwagon he saw. On 8/11/2020 at 4:51 AM, Emeric Elephant said: I'm so sorry everyone, I've been busy with the trunks all day. Unvote: Bixby Bunny Since Bixby has shown up, it's no good keeping a waste of a vote o the rabbit. We need a lynch. I'm tired from pulling my trunk all day. Vote: Mobley Mouse Emetic unvotes Bixby and then votes for Mobely. This feels very off. Again like he’s jumped on to the first bandwagon he saw. On 8/11/2020 at 12:11 PM, Gilford Goat said: Nu...not even...me??? You had me for a moment until you started down that. I still don't think we need a lynch today. What are trying to do? Cozy up to me? Why don't you tell me not to chew my cud so loud like everyone else? Vote: Bartosz Bulldog I do actually have some serious suspicions of others but they're really small things that I don't want them to pick up on. Gilford’s vote is also kind of weird. He says he has serious suspicions of others but doesn’t want to voice them because he doesn’t want them to pick up on them(?) On 8/11/2020 at 11:34 PM, Bartosz Bulldog said: For fear that I may not have time to do so before the end of the day, and a lack of desire to invoke a penalty vote, I shall Vote: Rutherford Raccoon for now. No telling if I'll have time again today to comment or if my vote will remain as it is. The garbage water bin tells me nothing about the next few hours. Finally Bartosz Bulldog votes for Rutherford. I’m not sure what my opinion is on this vote. He hasn’t just jumped on a bandwagon but he’s voted for a player who probably wouldn’t (and in the end didn’t) come online. I don’t know. Out of all of yesterday’s votes the ones that strike me the most are Emeric, Bixby, Gifford and Franceszca.
Emeric Elephant Posted August 14, 2020 Posted August 14, 2020 OH NO! Did anyone see that? That trinket fell off it's shelf! Somebody... or something... knocked it over. 4 hours ago, Leatrix Lamb said: Why Mobley? Again, I assume you had the same reasons I had. I was expecting him to get a lot of attention last night, so I wanted to see what happened o him and if it lined up with what people would say today. 3 minutes ago, Marlowe Monkey said: Emetic unvotes Bixby and then votes for Mobely. This feels very off. Again like he’s jumped on to the first bandwagon he saw. I voted for Bixby and was unaware of the certificate problem at the time. Site was working fine for me. My vote for Mobely was to get a lynch.
Hyacinth Hippo Posted August 14, 2020 Posted August 14, 2020 8 hours ago, Leatrix Lamb said: Why Corrina? Good analysis. I picked at random. My role was completely useless so I just picked off the players list. I know it wasn't a compulsary action, but I wanted to use it. Oof! I hurt myself on those stairs!
Holbrook Horse Posted August 14, 2020 Posted August 14, 2020 15 hours ago, Rutherford Raccoon said: with the coming of the Dawn I find my mind heavy and unable to remember, as if a New Soul looked out these eyes. what light through yonder window breaks! Rutherford, good to have you back from Limbo! 15 hours ago, Rutherford Raccoon said: Why has the possibility that he is a scum killer not even been raised? If we are to believe Gilford is the scum killer then we must believe some other things too, one of the following: Gilford scum-killed Mobley, so Franczeska is lying and is also scum; Gilford targeted himself and the kill got bus-driven to Caladon (wtf why); Gilford scum-killed Caladon and Parvani is lying and also scum; If Gilford is the scum killer and didn't target Mobley then we need to account for Mobley's death - so the vig must have been Caladon. And Parvani has already pointed out the following: 7 hours ago, Parvani Poodle said: t implies that Gilford knew that he was killing the Vig, so it seems rather far fetched. According to yesterday's setup, the scum didn't have a rolecop or something so if Gilford Goat had known Caladon was the vig, then someone must have told him. But Caladon was suspicious of Gilford and wouldn't have told him. So we're contriving a convoluted situation so explain how goat-face could have been the scum killer rather than the vigilante he says he was. I tend to believe him. 10 hours ago, Leatrix Lamb said: Why Marlowe? I thought I'd get the most bang for my buck by targeting someone I found suspicious who I thought wouldn't be messed with during the night - so Mobley and Gilford, being obvious targets, were right out. I had a little chat with Marlowe in the night and he came rushing out of the gates to tell me he had a block and wanted me to share my role with him, which I must say did not put me at ease. He backed off when I said I wanted to keep my role a secret until morning. Why else? His supposition that the slumber party involved a chain of blocking seemed ludicrous to me, like he was either trying to muddy the waters or else knew something he shouldn't have, before Mobley came in and gave what I thought was an unsatisfying answer (particularly in the light of Corrina's revelation of a weak protection endowed by the other Baby Dwagon action). 6 hours ago, Emeric Elephant said: OH NO! Did anyone see that? That trinket fell off it's shelf! Somebody... or something... knocked it over. No cats on board this ship I want to reconsider the votes from yesterday. I am endlessly glad that Parvani has posted a "for the record" with no commentary and that Marlowe has done a bang-up copy-paste job. Here's what we've got: On 8/11/2020 at 8:19 PM, Hinckley said: Mobley Mouse: 6 (Hyacinth Hippo, Corrina Cow, Benicia Bear, Caladon Crocodile, Bixby Bunny, Emeric Elephant)Hyacinth Hippo: 2 (Marlowe Monkey, Leatrix Lamb)Gilford Goat: 4 (Parvani Poodle, Franczeska Fox, Holbrook Horse, Shainen Sheepdog)Bartosz Bulldog: 1 (Gilford Goat)Rutherford Raccoon: 1 (Bartosz Bulldog) Non-voters: 2 (Mobley Mouse, Rutherford Raccoon) The case against Hyacinth Hippo didn't seem such a storng one to me - it went "she said there are pros and cons to claiming and she didn't take a proper position". This is true, but on the other hand we had Mobley and Gilford saying what a lark it'd be if we all blabbed our rolls. It's a weak case in my opinion, and one that Leatrix all too gladly (*ahem*) sheeped. Then we had Gilford making a BS vote for Bartosz while claiming he had real suspicions but didn't to tip his hand (pls share soon though)... and Bartosz staying out of the fray by voting for Rutherford. As far as votes for Gilford go, I shared Shainen's sentiments which he wrote in a lovely concise fashion: On 8/10/2020 at 4:52 PM, Shainen Sheepdog said: Between first suggesting revealing roles that I really don't think should be revealed, to saying we should all reveal (conveniently now called as wanting to create a shitstorm) and being happy to point to the mouse, it feels like he is helping scum more than town Then there's fly-under-the-radar Francezska, who reacted equally viscerally to the suggestion of "let's claim for the lulz" and, then Parvani, who said Gilford's claim suggestion was: On 8/10/2020 at 6:28 AM, Parvani Poodle said: That "we should just all claim, wouldn't if be fun" comment early on was just slightly... either devious or naive? Probably the latter but it's the only hunch I have for now, with things being quiet and players missing and all. Like she knew at the time it wasn't a very good vote but couldn't be bothered to think harder. Finally, the voting for Mobley started with (justified) complaints that the mouse was trying to weasel (not very mouse-like!) out of suggesting we all claimed our roles. Benicia had a similar vote, paying attention to Mobley's apparent and simultaneous difficulty and ease with the English language (which tongue has been taken to new heights by the return of our prodigal trash panda Rutherford, praise be!), and Caladon chimed in to agree. Bixby took a different tack: accusing Mobley of hiding crucial role information. Now this is an interesting one because it differs from how Bartosz and I looked at the situation: that there may be more to the slumber party than met the eye but that Mobley himself may not have been privy to that information. Emeric was the final vote for Mobley, observing that he wanted a lynch. What can I take away from yesterday's votes? That Marlowe and Leatrix tried apparently to push a wagon to nowhere and that Parvani voted for Gilford in a low-effort fashion. Others, flying largely under the radar, include Francezska and Emeric. I have strong logic to support Gilford's towniness and a feeling that Shainen is town. Rutherford? Not sure yet but I don't know why he's so keen to think Gilford was the scum killer rather than the vigilante last night. 3 hours ago, Hyacinth Hippo said: Good analysis. I picked at random. My role was completely useless so I just picked off the players list. It wasn't analysis, it was a question. The Normalizer could only have been useless if you were confident the holder of the Falsifier action (Benicia) wasn't going to do anything with it. Were Marlowe and Leatrix on to something with you? Or do I smell a bus? addendum: aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa *breath* aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa back to the barrel for me. Emeric, keep an eye out for spiders!
Hinckley Posted August 14, 2020 Author Posted August 14, 2020 You may now vote. With 14 players remaining, it takes 8 votes to achieve a lynch. 47 hours remain in Day Two.
Hyacinth Hippo Posted August 14, 2020 Posted August 14, 2020 2 hours ago, Holbrook Horse said: It wasn't analysis, it was a question. The Normalizer could only have been useless if you were confident the holder of the Falsifier action (Benicia) wasn't going to do anything with it. Were Marlowe and Leatrix on to something with you? Or do I smell a bus? I meant everything before that question was a good analysis, but I didn't think it appropriate to quote the entire post.
Franczeska Fox Posted August 14, 2020 Posted August 14, 2020 10 hours ago, Marlowe Monkey said: Fox then votes for Gifford Goat for his casual suggestion. Franczeska hasn’t said much up until this point and this vote feels somewhat bandwagon-y given Poodle has already voted. I fuuuuckking *hic* haaate mobile quotingg. Gilllfordd was the mosst sussspicious to mee at thatt point. *hic* As forrr Gillie now, I thinkk he's in the cleaar at least partially becausse hiss choice to kill Mobleyy woulddn't make sense for a *hic* scummm play. Mobley was alllready under heavvy *hic* suspicionnn, but onn top of that he didn't vote so he'ss stacked the *hic* deck againsst himself for an eassy lynchh with penalties and suspicionsss *hic* No wayyy the scumm would *hic* take out thatt.
Gilford Goat Posted August 14, 2020 Posted August 14, 2020 1 minute ago, Franczeska Fox said: No wayyy the scumm would *hic* take out thatt. Although I'm surprised they wanted to take out me. 11 hours ago, Gilford Goat said: Anyone else I could have killed would have had to been on my own suspect list. BTW I forgot but I almost killed Shainen.
Gilford Goat Posted August 14, 2020 Posted August 14, 2020 6 hours ago, Hyacinth Hippo said: Good analysis. I picked at random. My role was completely useless so I just picked off the players list. I know it wasn't a compulsary action, but I wanted to use it. Oof! I hurt myself on those stairs! Hmm.
Corrina Cow Posted August 14, 2020 Posted August 14, 2020 23 minutes ago, Gilford Goat said: Although I'm surprised they wanted to take out me. It is weird, but maybe they just figured you were a safe target, or they aren't very bright. Let's hope for the latter, but not count on it. The more likely possibilities: Did anyone else know you were the vig? Did you discuss your other suspicions with anyone who might have wanted to prevent that from going any further? Maybe they wanted to frame someone who suspected you yesterday? 27 minutes ago, Gilford Goat said: BTW I forgot but I almost killed Shainen. So that was another of your suspicions. Did anyone know?
Recommended Posts