Priella Pig Posted July 14, 2020 Posted July 14, 2020 Well, we have to vote, so I think I'm going to: Vote: Maddock Monkey I don't like that he's throwing his own poop around. Seems a bit suspicious to me. If he's doing that, what else is he doing?
Shanley Sheepdog Posted July 14, 2020 Posted July 14, 2020 8 hours ago, Hendrick Horse said: Assuming we have no investigation oneshots other nights that could make sense but the point I was trying to make whether my speculation into the makeup of the town is well reasoned or not in that particular instance (4 does sound like a lot even considering one is bound to bewrong), is that we will likely continue to see investigation abilities. I can't imagine we'd get 2.5 on day one and then none again for several days. That sounds completely ridiculous to me. -bark bark bark bark bark bark bark - I see what you mean. It feels as though an investigator role will be with us for some time. It looks as though (unless someone magically claims a sod me writing this) the second framer has unfortunately fallen into the hands of the scum - bark bark bark bark bark- meaning there’s a chance one of our sane cops could get a false positive (or negative). I still think the 1st framer (Fox) should announce who he is going to claim for the benefit of our investigators.
Caylin Cow Posted July 14, 2020 Posted July 14, 2020 2 hours ago, Fergus Fox said: I have no intention of letting that happen, but am not sure who I would target at this stage. Probably not Horsiepoo or Crazy Cow. I like the idea of having a vote on who we should frame. Who are you calling crazy? I'm not crazy. I'm stable. And genius. 1 hour ago, Hendrick Horse said: I'd love to hear back from some folks as to whether they agree on this method of determining the frame target before I cast my vote, because once any of us votes a vote tally will be made shortly thereafter considering how on top of things our lovely quadripedal pig friend is, and it's better to be in agreement on using the tally post number to determine our target before we get said post as it removes bias. That said I'm ready to vote, and so far the one person who's struck me as the most reasonable candidate is Wyeth Walrus. Literally every point he made while responding to me insinuated that he was making an effort not to appear scummy. That's practically a confession in my book, and I'm not impressed with his actions outside of that one post either. The only other thing of note that he's done today was compile extant information. This isn't a scummy behavior inherently, and this is day one, but it is a decent way of appearing more useful without actually adding to the conversation. The only thing that's dissuading me atm from being 100% sure is the swiftness with which he jumped on me after I volunteered. That was a bold move... but one filled to the brim with scummy tells. I'm not going to look you in the mouth, but after having read your posts and getting the clarification, I'm warming up to you. We currently have you with your vote on our magistrate Jamie Hyneman, and now Priella's vote on our resident poop-flinger. Vote: Priella Pig You came out of nowhere with a random vote and didn't even address Sarah Jessica Parker's vote. Even though dung tossing is gross, I haven't seen anything super scummy from the primate.
Hendrick Horse Posted July 14, 2020 Posted July 14, 2020 1 hour ago, Hendrick Horse said: I'd love to hear back from some folks as to whether they agree on this method of determining the frame target before I cast my vote... No one has even touched this. Thoughts anyone? Well anywhoo, the cherry's been popped now, and the pussy's out of the bag, so I might as well... vote: Wyeth Walrus
Lyev Lion Posted July 14, 2020 Posted July 14, 2020 1 hour ago, Priella Pig said: Well, we have to vote Indeed. Vote: Wyeth Walrus I get the strange sense you and Hendrick are playing off each other. 2 hours ago, Fergus Fox said: I purposely didn't mention what would happen if I didn't act on it By saying it was compulsive you totally did mention what would happen.
Wyeth Walrus Posted July 14, 2020 Posted July 14, 2020 Urf! Yawn. I call you out, you vote for me, predictable. Not even worth responding since you’ve not made a claim of substance. But then, this day one. A time for poke votes and other shenanigans. Vote: Evern Elephant Late to the game isn’t good play.
Caylin Cow Posted July 14, 2020 Posted July 14, 2020 2 minutes ago, Wyeth Walrus said: Urf! Yawn. I call you out, you vote for me, predictable. Not even worth responding since you’ve not made a claim of substance. But then, this day one. A time for poke votes and other shenanigans. Vote: Evern Elephant Late to the game isn’t good play. Didn't we wait to get our journey underway since Evern was sleeping?
Evren Elephant Posted July 15, 2020 Posted July 15, 2020 25 minutes ago, Wyeth Walrus said: Urf! Yawn. I call you out, you vote for me, predictable. Not even worth responding since you’ve not made a claim of substance. But then, this day one. A time for poke votes and other shenanigans. Vote: Evern Elephant Late to the game isn’t good play. My apologies for my sleepiness Mr Magistrate, thank you for not poking me with poop like our resident monkey might try to do. 2 hours ago, Priella Pig said: Well, we have to vote, so I think I'm going to: Vote: Maddock Monkey I don't like that he's throwing his own poop around. Seems a bit suspicious to me. If he's doing that, what else is he doing? I don't like this vote on principal but it's the first day so I guess it's fine for now despite the total fluff basis
Hinckley Posted July 15, 2020 Author Posted July 15, 2020 Vote tally Maddock Monkey: 1 (Priella Pig)Priella Pig: 1 (Caylin Cow)Wyeth Walrus: 2 (Hendrick Horse, Lyev Lion)Evren Elephant: 1 (Wyeth Walrus) Non-voters: 8 (Calissa Cat, Evren Elephant, Fergus Fox, Hayleigh Hippo, Keyarra Crocodile, Maddock Monkey, Pembroke Panda, Shanley Sheepdog) With 13 players, it takes 7 votes to lynch. Currently, nobody will be lynched. 24 hours remain in Day One. Reminder: Voting is mandatory. 3 hours ago, Priella Pig said: Vote: Maddock Monkey 1 hour ago, Caylin Cow said: Vote: Priella Pig 1 hour ago, Hendrick Horse said: vote: Wyeth Walrus 1 hour ago, Lyev Lion said: Vote: Wyeth Walrus 54 minutes ago, Wyeth Walrus said: Vote: Evern Elephant
Maddock Monkey Posted July 15, 2020 Posted July 15, 2020 19 hours ago, Hendrick Horse said: What makes you think we won't see a similar setup anytime soon? What makes you think we don't also just have a normal investigator on our side if we DON'T get the oneshots every night? Because Omrom announced the "setup for the day" implying it's going to be different every day and it would be weird if this Trickster person didn't have a lot of options going around. 16 hours ago, Keyarra Crocodile said: Not I, although I do wonder whether we really need to be planning the framing ahead of time? Does that help at all? If both framers are town, then they can just tell us tomorrow. If a framer is scum, then they are likely to lie about their action, whether they claim it today or tomorrow or not at all. None of this planning seems particularly helpful, honestly it is all a bit of a mess and quite the trap I feel if we try to rely too heavily on the results of all this framing and investigating ... there will be some useful information tomorrow, but with no way to tell it apart from the fake information with any degree of confidence. They don't call this person the Twizzler for nothing! This grates. "Why even fucking try to get an edge over the scum?" is not a good look so I shall Vote: Keyarra Crocodile 3 hours ago, Priella Pig said: Well, we have to vote, so I think I'm going to: Vote: Maddock Monkey I don't like that he's throwing his own poop around. Seems a bit suspicious to me. If he's doing that, what else is he doing? What kind of vote is this? Choose one: "I'll vote for Maddock because he's so handsome and obviously a townie and nobody else could rationally vote for him" "Maddock is a suspicious scum bum but I'm not going to tell anyone why" "I'm going to dogshit poke vote because I don't have anything to contribute" Other 10 hours ago, Hayleigh Hippo said: it brings up the question of why some people were tagged and not others According to my records, the people whom I tagged are those who had not posted since the Duchess of York claimed framer. I assumed everyone else who had posted, myself included, was not the framer, and would have heard about it if they had a night action. 2 hours ago, Caylin Cow said: Even though dung tossing is gross No, dung tossing is the best. Everyone should yeet a little poop from time to time! 27 minutes ago, Hinckley said: ... Nobody responded in the affirmative to my suggestion as to determining the frame target. The Captain's comment is number 3269838, which is congruent to 0 mod 13. According to my scheme, I hence nominate Calissa Cat as tonight's frame target. What does everyone else think?
Fergus Fox Posted July 15, 2020 Posted July 15, 2020 2 hours ago, Hendrick Horse said: No one has even touched this. Thoughts anyone? 18 minutes ago, Maddock Monkey said: Nobody responded in the affirmative to my suggestion as to determining the frame target. The Captain's comment is number 3269838, which is congruent to 0 mod 13. According to my scheme, I hence nominate Calissa Cat as tonight's frame target. What does everyone else think? I'm ok with this. 2 hours ago, Lyev Lion said: By saying it was compulsive you totally did mention what would happen. Just because mafiawiki says it's so, doesn't mean it has to be in practice. 18 minutes ago, Maddock Monkey said: According to my records, the people whom I tagged are those who had not posted since the Duchess of York claimed framer. That's quite the insult. I'm far more handsomer than Fergie.
Hendrick Horse Posted July 15, 2020 Posted July 15, 2020 4 hours ago, Lyev Lion said: Vote: Wyeth Walrus I get the strange sense you and Hendrick are playing off each other. OK? 4 hours ago, Wyeth Walrus said: Urf! Yawn. I call you out, you vote for me, predictable. Not even worth responding since you’ve not made a claim of substance. But then, this day one. A time for poke votes and other shenanigans. Vote: Evern Elephant Late to the game isn’t good play. You are hardly the only person to have called out my admittedly faulty reasoning earlier. You ARE however the only person who did so while explaining that you'd never do what I did because of how scummy it'd make you look. Actually... why am I paraphrasing. You literally said this: On 7/13/2020 at 9:29 PM, Wyeth Walrus said: You'll note I didn’t immediately put my hand up to not be investigated, though I could have. Why didn’t I? I thought it a pretty scummy move to ask to not be investigated. And this: On 7/13/2020 at 9:29 PM, Wyeth Walrus said: I didn’t even speculate on scum numbers, it’s a bad look. Both of these are clear signs to me that you're thinking with a scummy mindset. 2 hours ago, Maddock Monkey said: Because Omrom announced the "setup for the day" implying it's going to be different every day and it would be weird if this Trickster person didn't have a lot of options going around. This grates. "Why even fucking try to get an edge over the scum?" is not a good look so I shall Vote: Keyarra Crocodile Setup for the day implies that SOME of it COULD change not that it all would or that it would period if the Trickster likes that settup. I agree that Keyarra's post is ambivalent and wishy washy. I'd probe it further but I'm pretty sure I'm onto something with Wyeth. 3 hours ago, Maddock Monkey said: Nobody responded in the affirmative to my suggestion as to determining the frame target. The Captain's comment is number 3269838, which is congruent to 0 mod 13. According to my scheme, I hence nominate Calissa Cat as tonight's frame target. What does everyone else think? Sounds perfect. Better than me volunteering.
Shanley Sheepdog Posted July 15, 2020 Posted July 15, 2020 I'm going to Vote: Priella Pig. Her vote for Monkey Maddock seems so non committal. Despite all his contributions for today she's gone with "hes chucking poo around" there got to be more than that. - bark bark bark bark bark bark bark- There will be absolutely NO DUNG TOSSING while I am aboard. I am not wearing any pants and never will. I do not want Dung on my legs please.
Hayleigh Hippo Posted July 15, 2020 Posted July 15, 2020 Only one person has been suspicious enough for me to cast a vote for, and a lot of that has been explained away, but it's a requirement and not going to result in a lynch, I'm sure. Vote: Hendrick Horse
Fergus Fox Posted July 15, 2020 Posted July 15, 2020 Vote: Keyarra Crocodile For being the least helpful of the day, especially the post basically suggesting we shouldn't bother doing anything. Also, I wouldn't mind hearing from a few more on whether we are happy to go with Calissa as my target for tonight.
Priella Pig Posted July 15, 2020 Posted July 15, 2020 13 hours ago, Caylin Cow said: Vote: Priella Pig You came out of nowhere with a random vote and didn't even address Sarah Jessica Parker's vote. Even though dung tossing is gross, I haven't seen anything super scummy from the primate. Voting is mandatory. It's Day One. Do you have knowledge that none of us have? 10 hours ago, Maddock Monkey said: What kind of vote is this? Choose one: "I'll vote for Maddock because he's so handsome and obviously a townie and nobody else could rationally vote for him" "Maddock is a suspicious scum bum but I'm not going to tell anyone why" "I'm going to dogshit poke vote because I don't have anything to contribute" Other I'm going with other. Like I've said, it's Day One and we've got nothing to go on. Voting is mandatory and I don't want to receive penalty votes for not voting so the scum can use that as an excuse to lynch me easily. Hey, look at that, there's a nice cloud over there. It looks like an octopus! What were we talking about?
Shanley Sheepdog Posted July 15, 2020 Posted July 15, 2020 Just now, Priella Pig said: Hey, look at that, there's a nice cloud over there. It looks like an octopus! What were we talking about? - bark bark bark bark bark bark - No it doesn't. That's clearly a giraffe. Giraffe's do exist right?
Lyev Lion Posted July 15, 2020 Posted July 15, 2020 23 minutes ago, Shanley Sheepdog said: Giraffe's do exist right? Of course not silly. Everyone knows they don't and unicorns do.
Evren Elephant Posted July 15, 2020 Posted July 15, 2020 2 hours ago, Fergus Fox said: Vote: Keyarra Crocodile For being the least helpful of the day, especially the post basically suggesting we shouldn't bother doing anything. Also, I wouldn't mind hearing from a few more on whether we are happy to go with Calissa as my target for tonight. I think Calissa is a reasonable target, so I'm happy with it. Also Vote: Priella Pig just for fluffy contributions, not anything particularly scummy yet.
Caylin Cow Posted July 15, 2020 Posted July 15, 2020 2 hours ago, Priella Pig said: Voting is mandatory. It's Day One. Do you have knowledge that none of us have? I don't but you glazed over the first vote that had some actual reasoning to it.
Hendrick Horse Posted July 15, 2020 Posted July 15, 2020 Less than 12 hours and not an inch closer to a lynch. I recognize that discussing the trickster roll has eaten up much of the day's Chitter chatter but let's not put the cart before the... well... me. Unless you've got investigative powers, and honestly even then considering there's 1 insane cop and 1 unnaccounted for, more-than-likely-scum framer, then the only way for any of us to accurately determine anyone's allegiance is by lynching and analyzing voting and speech patterns. With that said, I think it's rather telling that we haven't achieved a lynch so far, indicating to me that one of the names we've tossed around may well belong to a Loyalist. I'm going to double down and propose we push harder on Wyeth, considering I haven't heard much discussion of my vote for him aside from a vague feeling that he and I are somehow "playing off eachother" I think Wyeth is a prime candidate for today's Lynch. He's been middle of the road with exception to very blatantly demonstrating a scummy mindset while criticizing me for volunteering and has since been completely dismissive of my concerns as being simple OMFGUS. 6 minutes ago, Hendrick Horse said: With that said, I think it's rather telling that we haven't achieved a lynch so far, *any sort of a bandwagon. It is too early to achieve a lynch, but usually there's more of a winnowing down of candidates by now I would assume.
Hinckley Posted July 15, 2020 Author Posted July 15, 2020 Vote tally Maddock Monkey: 1 (Priella Pig)Priella Pig: 3 (Caylin Cow, Shanley Sheepdog, Evren Elephant)Wyeth Walrus: 2 (Hendrick Horse, Lyev Lion)Evren Elephant: 1 (Wyeth Walrus)Keyarra Crocodile: 2 (Maddock Monkey, Fergus Fox)Hendrick Horse: 1 (Hayleigh Hippo) Non-voters: 3 (Calissa Cat, Keyarra Crocodile, Pembroke Panda) With 13 players, it takes 7 votes to lynch. Currently, nobody will be lynched. Approximately 9 hours remain in Day One. 14 hours ago, Maddock Monkey said: Vote: Keyarra Crocodile 6 hours ago, Shanley Sheepdog said: Vote: Priella Pig 5 hours ago, Hayleigh Hippo said: Vote: Hendrick Horse 4 hours ago, Fergus Fox said: Vote: Keyarra Crocodile 2 hours ago, Evren Elephant said: Vote: Priella Pig
Hendrick Horse Posted July 15, 2020 Posted July 15, 2020 A day 1 no-lynch puts the scum on a stronger footing. Let's not let that happen. I'll switch my vote to Kayarra for her ambivalent apathy, if need be but I feel the strongest about Wyeth.
Caylin Cow Posted July 15, 2020 Posted July 15, 2020 22 minutes ago, Hendrick Horse said: A day 1 no-lynch puts the scum on a stronger footing. Let's not let that happen. I'll switch my vote to Kayarra for her ambivalent apathy, if need be but I feel the strongest about Wyeth. Why not Priella? The most votes are currently on her.
Recommended Posts