Araveea Posted December 16, 2019 Posted December 16, 2019 Just now, Eeyara said: Like I already stated, I don't have anything solid to point at yet. It's like people don't even read. Well you did say something caught your eye. Oh well, thanks for your time anyway.
Eeyara Posted December 16, 2019 Posted December 16, 2019 4 hours ago, Tameekys said: Vote: Cadd As he's been a bit suspect in my eyes based off on some of the things that he's said. Such as, trying to stir up confusion about the scrolls and then trying to cause confusion about the lynching process, albeit before we knew it was mandatory. Now he's casting a "safe" vote on someone who hasn't really bothered to show up. Yes, the argument can be made that voting for someone for not coming is a valid day one strategy. After all, Scabowee did the same thing. However it's my vote and that's who I'm voting for until I can be persuaded otherwise. Exactly the same sort of thing I was thinking. Did Cadd start it all or just go along with the discussion? I was trying to keep up on my koreasea phone and it doesn't load the site well, so I'm back on a psea and rereading the whole day to figure that out.
Araveea Posted December 16, 2019 Posted December 16, 2019 I do see a pattern. People who speak up are being accused of talking rubbish on a day when there's nothing to talk about, by people who have barely opened their mouth. Going by that logic, Gorgons should just shut up and wait until the Oceanians lynch one another over silly small talk.
Eeyara Posted December 16, 2019 Posted December 16, 2019 22 minutes ago, Araveea said: I do see a pattern. People who speak up are being accused of talking rubbish on a day when there's nothing to talk about, by people who have barely opened their mouth. Going by that logic, Gorgons should just shut up and wait until the Oceanians lynch one another over silly small talk. It's day one, everyone is accused by everyone for talking or for not talking. For swimming or for not swimming. It's always the same. There's nothing to go by except who's getting overly defensive and freaking out when they get accused.
Nancy Posted December 16, 2019 Posted December 16, 2019 1 hour ago, Eeyara said: I've just been watching all the hot air around here. Really interesting how some folks got the whole day revolving around scrolls and traveler instead of talking about something useful. Out of interest, what would have been more useful topics to discuss, in your opinion? We have to vote, I see that as a good thing. If we don't vote, we don't show our opinions, and voting is not the same as lynching. If we all keep to ourselves then nothing will ever change except, our numbers will dwindle as we all die. Our vote is our weapon. I will Vote: Marwyyn. Marwyyn you seemed very concerned with trying to encourage people not to pass on any scrolls they might receive, and more interested than most in how the whole system worked, it seemed to me. With that, you also were a very negative..... negative narwhal, concerned with endgame chaos and sea-monkey wrenches being thrown into finely honed plans that are ridiculously far from being made, given that it's only day one. You asked, almost desperately, for opinions, but didn't give any yourself. It's just a vote, but you get mine.
Nerrio Posted December 16, 2019 Posted December 16, 2019 3 hours ago, Zandder said: We need to be active participants in this process if we are to root out the Gorgons and avenge the death of King Naryyus. We create information by participating. We can't (and it would be foolish) to wait until someone shares their night action results with us - it would give the Gorgons too much power over us. I’m just saying in a game type this new, it might be worth going about a no lynch day 1. We can actively participate and still reach a no lynch.
Hinckley Posted December 16, 2019 Author Posted December 16, 2019 Vote Tally Ronnan: 1 (Scabowee-wah)Araveea: 1 (Coralaaze)Eeyara: 2 (Cadd, Eeyara)Cadd: 1 (Tameekys)Marwyyn: 1 (Nancy) Non-voters: 7 (Araveea, Luxxon, Marwyyn, Mazziko, Nerrio, Ronnan, Zandder) 16 hours ago, Scabowee-wah said: Vote: Ronnan 15 hours ago, Coralaaze said: vote: Araveea. 7 hours ago, Cadd said: Vote:Eeyara 6 hours ago, Tameekys said: Vote: Cadd 2 hours ago, Eeyara said: Vote:Eeyara 35 minutes ago, Nancy said: Vote: Marwyyn. 28 hours remain in Day One.
Eeyara Posted December 16, 2019 Posted December 16, 2019 On 12/14/2019 at 11:58 PM, Araveea said: Pew pew. I'm glad we have chosen the most civilized way to deal with this crisis. I was wondering about those scrolls... How will we manage to pass them on to the Traveler? I don't suppose they will want to come out and reveal themselves, because the Gorgons will want the Traveler dead. We can also pass them on at random every night until the Traveler gets them, hoping that they don't land in Gorgon hands first. Any thoughts? Oh, no wonder you are so defensive about people being voted on for pushing scroll-focused talk. On 12/15/2019 at 8:04 AM, Marwyyn said: Odd. Just...odd. I think this is the comment that seemed strange at the start of the day and I was thinking "what a strange reaction to someone posting something at the start of the day, are they trying to imply something without saying anything?" Looking back at it, probably it's nothing. As far as for what /should/ we have been talking about? I don't know exactly, it's just a feeling I had and remember when something like this happened before - people got focused on some random role and talked about nothing else. That caused actual discussion to be buried (moreso in day 2 and on) and many townies killed because of the focus - and it was a scum that started the focus.
Ronnan Posted December 16, 2019 Posted December 16, 2019 17 hours ago, Scabowee-wah said: Vote: Ronnan because you haven't commented on the proceedings yet today, so here's a firm poke. Hee hee! That tickles! 3 hours ago, Eeyara said: Without a strong feeling against anyone, and just to make sure I don't forget to vote later, for now I vote for myself. I would feel worse killing another innocent person rather than just myself. Vote:Eeyara This is just unhelpful. Pick someone other than yourself. I'm of the opinion that discussing the traveler was a useful thing in that it gets people talking about something other than the normal "oh no! we have to lynch someone" business. Personally, I would weigh whether or not to pass on the scroll based on what's in it, but it seems like passing it on early would be less potentially dangerous than passing it along later. Plus, where's the fun in holding on to something if I can't use it? For now, I will Vote: Araveea. Araveea has spoken several times since voting was opened up, but hasn't cast a vote yet. I feel like she's waiting to see where the votes land.
Eeyara Posted December 16, 2019 Posted December 16, 2019 29 minutes ago, Ronnan said: This is just unhelpful. Pick someone other than yourself. Like I said before, I was voting for myself because there was nobody I wanted to vote on but also stuff happens and I didn't want to get a huge penalty for not voting. Jeeze.
Luxxon Posted December 16, 2019 Posted December 16, 2019 Vote: Marwyyn It's Day one, so I don't feel there is much to go on. But, it's been a while since you made this statement and I'm keen to hear your views. On 12/16/2019 at 1:49 AM, Marwyyn said: Yeah and so is voting. What are we thinking? Lynch? No lynch? C'mon I wanna hear opinions, thoughts, commentary, recipes. Gimme it all. On 12/16/2019 at 12:42 AM, Marwyyn said: Let's all remember that there could be a Gorgon Traitor who didn't get recalled. So something like the above post could be a Traitor trying to single to the other scum by acting overly scummy. I meant to say "quoted post" not "above post". This earlier post also caught my eye because she was casting suspicion on Cadd quite early. I thought this was a bold statement to make at that point and I read this as sowing the seed for a lynch candidate that would be an easy one for others to follow.
Eeyara Posted December 16, 2019 Posted December 16, 2019 I've been trying to decide between Araveea and Marwyyn for about an hour and having some real trouble. They both did some things early in the day that gave me an odd feeling. However, the fact that so many people are just piling onto an Araveea vote makes me even more uneasy about voting for her. Araveea - First to start the whole traveler/scrolls discussion, wouldn't let it drop, excessively defensive when anyone mentioned that discussion seeming scummy. Marwyyn - Strange underhanded (not sure that's the right word) not-quite-accusing Cadd after an initial post, lots of traveler discussion that seemed to centered around getting the traveler to claim or getting anyone who hands off a scroll to claim they did (thereby creating a claim of elimination). For a negotiator, I'm very bad at words and explaining my own thoughts, but that's what I've got right now. Unvote:EeyaraVote: Marwyyn 2 minutes ago, Luxxon said: This earlier post also caught my eye because she was casting suspicion on Cadd quite early. I thought this was a bold statement to make at that point and I read this as sowing the seed for a lynch candidate that would be an easy one for others to follow. How funny you posted this as I was just writing up the same thing.
Mazziko Posted December 16, 2019 Posted December 16, 2019 Apologies for the lack of activity been hit by the flu. I feel Eeyara feels like some reverse psychology thing going on him. "I'll vote for myself to make myself look town" Then again he could genuinely be town. I've seen this tactic used by a town player before although that was towards the end of the game when we were struggling who was scum.
Eeyara Posted December 16, 2019 Posted December 16, 2019 Just now, Mazziko said: Apologies for the lack of activity been hit by the flu. I feel Eeyara feels like some reverse psychology thing going on him. "I'll vote for myself to make myself look town" Then again he could genuinely be town. I've seen this tactic used by a town player before although that was towards the end of the game when we were struggling who was scum. First off, I'm a girl. Second off, I stated exactly why I was voting for myself, more than once. Third off, feel better soon.
Hinckley Posted December 16, 2019 Author Posted December 16, 2019 Vote Tally Ronnan: 1 (Scabowee-wah)Araveea: 2 (Coralaaze, Ronnan)Eeyara: 1 (Cadd)Cadd: 1 (Tameekys)Marwyyn: 3 (Nancy, Luxxon, Eeyara) Non-voters: 5 (Araveea, Marwyyn, Mazziko, Nerrio, Zandder) 24 hours remain in Day One. 9 hours ago, Ronnan said: Vote: Araveea. 8 hours ago, Luxxon said: Vote: Marwyyn 8 hours ago, Eeyara said: Vote: Marwyyn
Ronnan Posted December 16, 2019 Posted December 16, 2019 24 minutes ago, Eeyara said: I've been trying to decide between Araveea and Marwyyn for about an hour and having some real trouble. They both did some things early in the day that gave me an odd feeling. However, the fact that so many people are just piling onto an Araveea vote makes me even more uneasy about voting for her. "So many people" was and still is just 2. I added my vote, yes. 24 minutes ago, Eeyara said: I've been trying to decide between Araveea and Marwyyn for about an hour and having some real trouble. They both did some things early in the day that gave me an odd feeling. However, the fact that so many people are just piling onto an Araveea vote makes me even more uneasy about voting for her. Araveea - First to start the whole traveler/scrolls discussion, wouldn't let it drop, excessively defensive when anyone mentioned that discussion seeming scummy. Marwyyn - Strange underhanded (not sure that's the right word) not-quite-accusing Cadd after an initial post, lots of traveler discussion that seemed to centered around getting the traveler to claim or getting anyone who hands off a scroll to claim they did (thereby creating a claim of elimination). For a negotiator, I'm very bad at words and explaining my own thoughts, but that's what I've got right now. Unvote:EeyaraVote: Marwyyn Thanks for voting for someone other than yourself. Are you at all concerned about all the people piling onto Marwyyn? I mean, you're the 3rd vote here and you thought the 2 votes on Araveea were piling on...
Eeyara Posted December 16, 2019 Posted December 16, 2019 Just now, Ronnan said: Are you at all concerned about all the people piling onto Marwyyn? I mean, you're the 3rd vote here and you thought the 2 votes on Araveea were piling on... I am a bit now! When i wrote that there was only 1 vote on Marwyyn though, and the other vote was put on while I was putting mine so it was independent thought not just adding one to someone that already had votes. You're right though, it does give me cause for concern.
Nerrio Posted December 16, 2019 Posted December 16, 2019 Yeah I’m not a fan of this quick bandwagon. This smells of collusion of some sort.
Marwyyn Posted December 16, 2019 Posted December 16, 2019 5 hours ago, Eeyara said: Really interesting how some folks got the whole day revolving around scrolls and traveler instead of talking about something useful. 4 hours ago, Nancy said: Out of interest, what would have been more useful topics to discuss, in your opinion?. 3 hours ago, Eeyara said: As far as for what /should/ we have been talking about? I don't know exactly, FFS 2 hours ago, Ronnan said: Hee hee! That tickles! This is just unhelpful. Pick someone other than yourself. I'm of the opinion that discussing the traveler was a useful thing in that it gets people talking about something other than the normal "oh no! we have to lynch someone" business. Personally, I would weigh whether or not to pass on the scroll based on what's in it, but it seems like passing it on early would be less potentially dangerous than passing it along later. Plus, where's the fun in holding on to something if I can't use it? For now, I will Vote: Araveea. Araveea has spoken several times since voting was opened up, but hasn't cast a vote yet. I feel like she's waiting to see where the votes land. 5 hours ago, Araveea said: Well we didn't hear you talking about anything useful. ^ 4 hours ago, Nancy said: Vote: Marwyyn. You asked, almost desperately, for opinions, but didn't give any yourself. This just isn't true at all. 1 hour ago, Luxxon said: Vote: Marwyyn It's Day one, so I don't feel there is much to go on. But, it's been a while since you made this statement and I'm keen to hear your views. Same to you bucko.
Tameekys Posted December 16, 2019 Posted December 16, 2019 11 minutes ago, Nerrio said: Yeah I’m not a fan of this quick bandwagon. This smells of collusion of some sort. Three people doesn't exactly make a bandwagon. If everyone was suddenly switching their vote and hopping aboard, then I would see something fishy but as of now I don't think that Marwyyn is in any massive danger. Who exactly do you think is colluding? 18 minutes ago, Eeyara said: I am a bit now! When i wrote that there was only 1 vote on Marwyyn though, and the other vote was put on while I was putting mine so it was independent thought not just adding one to someone that already had votes. You're right though, it does give me cause for concern. Maybe you could go back to voting for yourself. That way nobody can claim that you're joining a bandwagon and you can keep on appearing as though you're town self-sacrificing yourself.
Marwyyn Posted December 16, 2019 Posted December 16, 2019 On 12/15/2019 at 8:42 AM, Marwyyn said: Let's all remember that there could be a Gorgon Traitor who didn't get recalled. So something like the above post could be a Traitor trying to single to the other scum by acting overly scummy. 1 hour ago, Luxxon said: This earlier post also caught my eye because she was casting suspicion on Cadd quite early. Ha. No. I was pointing out that Caster might be casting suspicion on himself. 12 minutes ago, Tameekys said: Maybe you could go back to voting for yourself. That way nobody can claim that you're joining a bandwagon and you can keep on appearing as though you're town self-sacrificing yourself. Gottem. Don't think I want a lynch, but I do want it to be clear who I'm most suspicious of ATM. Vote: Eeyara
Luxxon Posted December 16, 2019 Posted December 16, 2019 1 minute ago, Marwyyn said: Ha. No. I was pointing out that Caster might be casting suspicion on himself. Yes, as a Gorgon. Are you suggesting then that he is not Gorgon?
Marwyyn Posted December 16, 2019 Posted December 16, 2019 27 minutes ago, Luxxon said: Yes, as a Gorgon. Are you suggesting then that he is not Gorgon? No, what I'm saying is that I have a suspicion that Cadd is making himself look suspicious. Saying someone is "casting suspicion on someone" is equivalent to "I know you are but what am I?". Do you think that's a legit defense against someone's suspicion of you? "I think your suspicious, and here's why." "I think your casting suspicion on me!" 2 hours ago, Luxxon said: I thought this was a bold statement to make at that point The only thing left of your suspicions is that it was to early to be making such a "bold statement". I think it is you my friend who's looking for an easy lynch.
Recommended Posts