Timothy Dixon Posted March 30, 2019 Posted March 30, 2019 Out of the options we have now, Thomas is the best choice. His claim of being blocked yesterday could be true if the scum had some kind of JOAT role. But I'm not sure. I don't think Louisa and Jack can both be scum given how keen she is too lynch him today. I'm far more confident that Louisa is town than Jack. Vote: Thomas Chapman
Bob Posted March 30, 2019 Author Posted March 30, 2019 Vote Count: Thomas Chapman - 5 (Patrick, Louisa, Henry, Jack, Timothy) Jack Alden - 1 (Thomas) A majority of 5 is required to lynch.
Louisa Hammond Posted March 30, 2019 Posted March 30, 2019 3 hours ago, Timothy Dixon said: Out of the options we have now, Thomas is the best choice. His claim of being blocked yesterday could be true if the scum had some kind of JOAT role. But I'm not sure. I don't think Louisa and Jack can both be scum given how keen she is too lynch him today. I'm far more confident that Louisa is town than Jack. Vote: Thomas Chapman Come to think of it, could a JOAT have a janitor ability?
Timothy Dixon Posted March 30, 2019 Posted March 30, 2019 12 minutes ago, Louisa Hammond said: Come to think of it, could a JOAT have a janitor ability? According to the logs, a JOAT can have any one shot abilities. And since a Janitor is usually and X shot role anyway, I don't see why not.
Louisa Hammond Posted March 30, 2019 Posted March 30, 2019 42 minutes ago, Timothy Dixon said: According to the logs, a JOAT can have any one shot abilities. And since a Janitor is usually and X shot role anyway, I don't see why not. This made me think that maybe Jack could indeed be a fifth scum, but he was investigated as town along with Joseph, and both of them can't be godfathers. Unless Jack got crazy lucky and made himself a godfather the night Tom investigated him. If Malcolm and Joseph were indeed scum, and there was a fifth scum, between Jack and Tom who's more likely to be the fifth scum? Maybe we should lynch Jack instead.
Joseph Finch Posted March 30, 2019 Posted March 30, 2019 I think we should lynch Jack. I outlined my case for his being The Godfather yesterday. The janitor move and extra block make sense with scum having a JOAT of some kind. I think lynching Thomas today is a mistake. If he actually is the cop we’re screwed. Vote: Jack Alden
Louisa Hammond Posted March 30, 2019 Posted March 30, 2019 1 hour ago, Joseph Finch said: I think we should lynch Jack. I outlined my case for his being The Godfather yesterday. If Jack is scum then Tom is scum as well. That or you, Malcolm and Jack are scum in which case your the godfather and Jack is a JOAT. 1 hour ago, Joseph Finch said: The janitor move and extra block make sense with scum having a JOAT of some kind. That or Tom is scum and lied about having no result on Malcolm and further more isn't even a investigator. 1 hour ago, Joseph Finch said: I think lynching Thomas today is a mistake. If he actually is the cop we’re screwed. Unlikely. Yes it would suck but it wouldn't be the death of us.
Nigel Clayton Posted March 30, 2019 Posted March 30, 2019 Argh mateys, It been a hard couple days. Lemme get me some back reading done. This unknown party reading be bad news. The Coffin be already sealed but let me put the first shovel on the lid. VOTE: THOMAS CHAPMAN
Bob Posted March 31, 2019 Author Posted March 31, 2019 Vote Count: Thomas Chapman - 6 (Patrick, Louisa, Henry, Jack, Timothy, Nigel) Jack Alden - 2 (Thomas, Joseph) A majority of 5 is required to lynch. Around 10 hours remain in this day.
Bob Posted March 31, 2019 Author Posted March 31, 2019 Vote Count:Thomas Chapman - 6 (Patrick, Louisa, Henry, Jack, Timothy, Nigel) Jack Alden - 2 (Thomas, Joseph) With 6 votes, Thomas has been lynched. Please get your night actions in!
Recommended Posts