Dragonator, on 26 August 2012 - 09:32 AM, said:
Becka, why don't you hang me from the hook in our bedroom ceiling with those handcuffs you keep under the bed and rub my unmentionables with chilli powder in celebration!
Tonight Bookie, if you actually manage to stay awake, unlike last night.
At least I got some... uhm... extra business, thanks to the nice people in Gibson's pub.
Cecilie, on 26 August 2012 - 12:34 PM, said:
If we want to get anywhere today, I think we should focus on what we do know. And what is that? Well, we know that Petey was a loyal Villager. And what can we learn from that? Well, that's what I'd like to know! It seems most of those who voted for Petey yesterday did so on the grounds that it was the lynch we would learn the most from. Now, please tell me, oh wise furries: what did we learn from it?
I explained yesterday what we could learn from it:
Rick, on 23 August 2012 - 06:46 PM, said:
If we decide to lynch either Casey or Petey and they turn out to be a Cultist, it becomes more likely the other is a Cultist too (especially in the case of Casey). If Casey turns out to be a Villager, that won't tell us much about Petey's allegiance though. However, when Petey turns out to be a Villager, that makes it likely Casey is a Villager too, because a Cultist would be happy with all the attention on a Villager like Petey (unless Casey's trying really hard to appear 'Village' of course). So, ironically, while I think Casey has been acting scummier than Petey, and wouldn't mind seeing her lynched, I think we'll learn slightly more from lynching Petey.
So, as I also said earlier today, it makes it more likely that both Casey and Pennie are Villagers too. Of course we can't be sure of anything and with those crazy frogs around, I don't think we'll ever be sure. What would we have learned had we lynched Pennie, which is what you wanted, and she had come up Village? Would you have concluded Petey was a Cultist?
Theoretically, we could also learn something from knowing that Bristol was a Villager, and that Wallace was an evil Cultist, but neither of them said anything of value yesterday
. They do have one thing in common though, they were the two quiet furries Portia tried to awake
At least you come up with a good reason why the Cultists would want to kill Bristol, namely that we learn very little from her death.
Professor Flitwick, on 26 August 2012 - 12:46 PM, said:
Right from the off you were vehemently against it. Even before people had voted. At a time when people were looking more at Casey. Almost as if you knew Petey was a town member, and could claim a higher ground of morality and innocence the next day.
Scubacarrot, on 26 August 2012 - 01:01 PM, said:
Look. I find it interesting you acted like you was sure of Petey's Innocence, something only the dirty (I bet they have fleas, too) cultists would be sure of. I'm sure you will say: "But I did not say that." Face it, you acted like it.
Indeed, people strongly opposed
to Petey's lynch, as if they knew he was an innocent Villager, should be scrutinised today.