Jump to content


Lord of the Rings


16 replies to this topic

Poll: Lord of the Rings (36 member(s) have cast votes)

Do you like the books or the movies more?

  1. Books (16 votes [44.44%] - View)

    Percentage of vote: 44.44%

  2. Movies (20 votes [55.56%] - View)

    Percentage of vote: 55.56%

Vote Guests cannot vote

#1 RPGer

RPGer

    Posts: 556
    Joined: 08-February 12
    Member: 25899
    Country: USA

Posted 07 March 2012 - 03:30 PM

Well, Star Wars has one, and LOTR  is being produced by LEGO so this is in order.  Let's see what you got!   :sweet:

I'm a Christian and proud of it

Won as Scummy Rapunzel in Sandy's A Bedtime Story Mafia.

Playing as Czech Varsev, 41 year-old elvish Ranger in Heroica RPG.


#2 Sir_Basil_Ashton

Sir_Basil_Ashton

    Posts: 874
    Joined: 29-December 11
    Member: 23619
    Country: Italia

Posted 07 March 2012 - 04:52 PM

I've only seen the movies so my love of LotR stems from that.

#3 Palathadric

Palathadric

  • Makes other members' internet speeds seem ridiculously fast


    Posts: 5833
    Joined: 30-July 11
    Member: 19379
    Country: Great Unknown

Posted 07 March 2012 - 09:15 PM

Wow! This is a tough call. Would have to give it to the book though, because the "Scouring of the Shire", :wink:  was my favourite part and they left it out of the movie entirely. Well, no, that's not the only reason. I actually, believe it or not, only read the book after watching the movie. I just could never get my hands on the book before then, although I was hunting for it.
The movie was done really well though, for the most part, but there are some things that are a bit disappointing. :oh:
They that love God will never meet for the last time.
This life isn't the end. We will meet again.
Posted Image     Posted Image     Posted Image
Brickshelf Account
See my work in the Official Lego sets made in LDraw topic

#4 Lego-Freak

Lego-Freak

  • Online LEGO Store Detective


    Posts: 918
    Joined: 31-May 07
    Member: 1635
    Country: Switzerland

Posted 07 March 2012 - 10:05 PM

I've only seen the movies as well, and the Jackson trilogy is one of my favourite film franchises I have to say (besides Star Wars, Harry Potter, Indiana Jones, Nolan's Batman trilogy and so on  :wink: ) I've never read the books but I got information on most of the differences between the movies and the films, but quite frankly I don't get the outrage those caused among the diehard fans of the books  :wacko: The inclusion of the elves in the battle of helm's deep e.g. that most fans seem to detest was a nice idea IMO (and without it, we probably wouldn't get a Haldir minifig :sweet: ).
@palathadric: To be honest, I'm glad they've changed that since the placement of that chapter seems really awkward, I mean it happens after Sauron gets defeated  *huh* Imagine if in ROTJ there was still a major antagonist left to be defeated after Palpatine's death, it would feel somewhat anti-climatic... But that's just my two cents  :tongue:

P.S.: Please don't burn me as a heretic  :laugh:

#5 Palathadric

Palathadric

  • Makes other members' internet speeds seem ridiculously fast


    Posts: 5833
    Joined: 30-July 11
    Member: 19379
    Country: Great Unknown

Posted 07 March 2012 - 10:42 PM

View PostLego-Freak, on 07 March 2012 - 10:05 PM, said:

I've only seen the movies as well, and the Jackson trilogy is one of my favourite film franchises I have to say (besides Star Wars, Harry Potter, Indiana Jones, Nolan's Batman trilogy and so on  :wink: ) I've never read the books but I got information on most of the differences between the movies and the films, but quite frankly I don't get the outrage those caused among the diehard fans of the books  :wacko: The inclusion of the elves in the battle of helm's deep e.g. that most fans seem to detest was a nice idea IMO (and without it, we probably wouldn't get a Haldir minifig :sweet: ).
@palathadric: To be honest, I'm glad they've changed that since the placement of that chapter seems really awkward, I mean it happens after Sauron gets defeated  *huh* Imagine if in ROTJ there was still a major antagonist left to be defeated after Palpatine's death, it would feel somewhat anti-climatic... But that's just my two cents  :tongue:

P.S.: Please don't burn me as a heretic  :laugh:
I won't burn you out the stake, but I have a wicked mind full of other devious torture methods. :devil:
I don't mind the inclusion of the Elves at Helm's Deep, neither how Arwen plays a fairly major part in the movie, whereas in the book she is, more or less, just casually mentioned. I don't mind the big cataclysmic endings to movies, but it seems almost too normal. It's great for all the orcs and every bad thing to die when Sauron falls, but...then what? I guess I think about all these things. The Scouring of the Shire was just such a pleasant battle scene at the end of the book. The whole while they are put in the midst of these horrible battles and pull out by the skin of their teeth, but then at the end they have this sweet, simple, very shire-like battle. I honestly think though, that it would have been a bit odd to have included it in the movie since movies like to end with a "bang!"

Am I making sense in this post or does it just seem like random thoughts? :look:
They that love God will never meet for the last time.
This life isn't the end. We will meet again.
Posted Image     Posted Image     Posted Image
Brickshelf Account
See my work in the Official Lego sets made in LDraw topic

#6 Fives

Fives

  • Makes structured rants


    Posts: 2538
    Joined: 31-December 10
    Member: 15059
    Country: Canada

Posted 07 March 2012 - 11:47 PM

View PostLego-Freak, on 07 March 2012 - 10:05 PM, said:

I've only seen the movies as well, and the Jackson trilogy is one of my favourite film franchises I have to say (besides Star Wars, Harry Potter, Indiana Jones, Nolan's Batman trilogy and so on  :wink: ) I've never read the books but I got information on most of the differences between the movies and the films, but quite frankly I don't get the outrage those caused among the diehard fans of the books  :wacko: The inclusion of the elves in the battle of helm's deep e.g. that most fans seem to detest was a nice idea IMO (and without it, we probably wouldn't get a Haldir minifig :sweet: ).
@palathadric: To be honest, I'm glad they've changed that since the placement of that chapter seems really awkward, I mean it happens after Sauron gets defeated  *huh* Imagine if in ROTJ there was still a major antagonist left to be defeated after Palpatine's death, it would feel somewhat anti-climatic... But that's just my two cents  :tongue:

P.S.: Please don't burn me as a heretic  :laugh:

No, no one is gonna be burned here!

I actually agree with you on the whole "Scouring of the Shire". I, like some here, saw the movies way before I read the books. Sure, that has affected my opinion of the books, but I still love both versions of the story (Tolkien's and Jackson's). I've grown up with the films, so that is what I know best. I love the scouring of the Shire, but I do feel that it was extremely anti-climactic, and (I can't believe I'm gonna say it) I am somewhat mad atTolkien for including it. I much rather Saruman being killed at Isengard at the begining of ROTK (end of the first part of Two Towers book) because it puts some closure to that whole story line. After that, the heroes just have Sauron to deal with. In the book, Saruman is just left wandering until he ends up being a threat at the end of all things.

Even though I love the books, and without them the films would not exist, I still love the movies, and with them we get this amazing new LEGO theme!
"One Ring to rule them all, One Ring to find them, One Ring to bring them all, and in the darkness bind them!"

Posted Image

#7 Slick Willie

Slick Willie

    Posts: 45
    Joined: 23-February 12
    Member: 26870

Posted 07 March 2012 - 11:51 PM

CGI can't replace the grandeur that your mind produces while reading a good book.  

Kind of like my Lego Creations....they always look a lot better in my mind than they do when I actually build them... :hmpf_bad: :cry_sad: :sceptic:

#8 RPGer

RPGer

    Posts: 556
    Joined: 08-February 12
    Member: 25899
    Country: USA

Posted 13 March 2012 - 01:20 PM

View PostLego-Freak, on 07 March 2012 - 10:05 PM, said:

I've only seen the movies as well, and the Jackson trilogy is one of my favourite film franchises I have to say (besides Star Wars, Harry Potter, Indiana Jones, Nolan's Batman trilogy and so on  :wink: ) I've never read the books but I got information on most of the differences between the movies and the films, but quite frankly I don't get the outrage those caused among the diehard fans of the books  :wacko: The inclusion of the elves in the battle of helm's deep e.g. that most fans seem to detest was a nice idea IMO (and without it, we probably wouldn't get a Haldir minifig :sweet: ).
@palathadric: To be honest, I'm glad they've changed that since the placement of that chapter seems really awkward, I mean it happens after Sauron gets defeated  *huh* Imagine if in ROTJ there was still a major antagonist left to be defeated after Palpatine's death, it would feel somewhat anti-climatic... But that's just my two cents  :tongue:

P.S.: Please don't burn me as a heretic  :laugh:
Let's burn him!   :devil_laugh:
No, really, the books are way better than the movies.

I'm a Christian and proud of it

Won as Scummy Rapunzel in Sandy's A Bedtime Story Mafia.

Playing as Czech Varsev, 41 year-old elvish Ranger in Heroica RPG.


#9 Legocrazy81

Legocrazy81

    Posts: 4492
    Joined: 12-August 10
    Member: 12542
    Country: USA(California)

Posted 30 December 2012 - 04:29 AM

While I just started reading(FINALLY!) LotR, I got to say, as with any book/movie adaptations, books will always trump movies, as Slick Willie said above.

I must say, after rewatching Fellowship, I'm a bit irked at the exclusion of Tom Bombadil. That was such a fun part of the book, IMO. I was sad to see he wasn't even mentioned.
Clone Army-124 & counting...

#10 TheLegoDr

TheLegoDr

  • Yellow Panel Expert


    Posts: 4618
    Joined: 18-July 11
    Member: 19128
    Country: USA

Posted 30 December 2012 - 07:28 AM

The problem with being such a hardcore book fan is you'll always be disappointed with movies. I loved the Harry Potter universe, but the books had so much more detail that the movies would inevitably leave something out or change little details based on the director/screenplay writer. However, back to LOTR. I have yet to read the books (I just received them for my birthday so I will get on it soon). It's interesting that you mention Tom Bambodil, because I've only heard negative things about his inclusion. Now I won't be able to judge it until I read the books, but I was more than satisfied with the films, so the exclusion didn't affect me. Maybe I'll change my mind.

Since LEGO released LOTR sets this summer, I've watched the trilogy 3 times. I have liked them more each time, so that is all that matters to me haha.
Posted Image   Posted Image  Posted Image   Posted Image   Posted Image  Posted Image

flickr
See my collection

#11 Mr Man

Mr Man

    Posts: 3811
    Joined: 01-October 10
    Member: 13561
    Country: England

Posted 30 December 2012 - 11:23 AM

I wasn't so keen on the Tom Bombadil chapters, however I did like the hint that there is a power greater than Sauron. I did however like the Barrows and Barrow Wrights, shame that was cut.
'For over a thousand generations the Jedi Knights were the guardians of peace and justice in the Old Republic.'
Posted Image Posted Image

#12 Palathadric

Palathadric

  • Makes other members' internet speeds seem ridiculously fast


    Posts: 5833
    Joined: 30-July 11
    Member: 19379
    Country: Great Unknown

Posted 30 December 2012 - 05:36 PM

That's why it's always best to watch the movie before reading the book, because then the movie can't disappoint you...hopefully. :look:
They that love God will never meet for the last time.
This life isn't the end. We will meet again.
Posted Image     Posted Image     Posted Image
Brickshelf Account
See my work in the Official Lego sets made in LDraw topic

#13 The Legonater

The Legonater

  • Can NOT Ctrl + Alt + Delete the Past


    Posts: 4645
    Joined: 09-December 09
    Member: 8515
    Country: Canada.

Posted 30 December 2012 - 09:11 PM

View PostLegocrazy81, on 30 December 2012 - 04:29 AM, said:

While I just started reading(FINALLY!) LotR, I got to say, as with any book/movie adaptations, books will always trump movies, as Slick Willie said above.

I must say, after rewatching Fellowship, I'm a bit irked at the exclusion of Tom Bombadil. That was such a fun part of the book, IMO. I was sad to see he wasn't even mentioned.

View PostMr Man, on 30 December 2012 - 11:23 AM, said:

I wasn't so keen on the Tom Bombadil chapters, however I did like the hint that there is a power greater than Sauron. I did however like the Barrows and Barrow Wrights, shame that was cut.

I've got to agree with Mr Man, I found Bombadil tedious at best. I did like how some of the themes he brought up were echoed in Treebeard in the movie, though. That's something I love about Jackson's movies- many of the things that were left out are usually touched at, at the very least. The Barrows did seem like a pretty fun sequence, as was the whole arrows firing back and forth on the Andurin.

Memory is the Key

A Christian and not ashamed.

Posted Image
Dyric Rone, Assassin of the Light

Level 28 1/3 Assassin

Theodor Legion, 73 year old ex-Bonaparte in Cruel Angel's Thesis


#14 Anduril

Anduril

    Posts: 20
    Joined: 01-February 12
    Member: 25376

Posted 30 December 2012 - 10:35 PM

I like the books better. Mainly because you can included more backstory and information in books then you can in movies. I also really enjoy some of the characters from ROTK that we don't really see in the movie.

#15 Mr_Malfoy

Mr_Malfoy

    Posts: 535
    Joined: 03-April 11
    Member: 17027
    Country: Middle-Earth

Posted 31 December 2012 - 02:59 AM

That's a hard question. I've seen the trilogy several times, and I'm currently working on reading the books. So far, I equally like both. I've heard of the Scouring of the Shire, and I also think it's anticlimatic (the same reason it was cut out of the movies). The only two things I wish the movies had were Saruman's death and the Mouth of Sauron sequence.
I'm a Christian and proud of it! I'm also proud to be a Hunger Games, Harry Potter, Disney, Lord of the Rings, and LEGO fan too...

#16 Masked Builder

Masked Builder

  • Hoping to get it up tonight


    Posts: 8328
    Joined: 16-April 10
    Member: 10293
    Country: New York, USA

Posted 31 December 2012 - 06:22 PM

View PostMr_Malfoy, on 31 December 2012 - 02:59 AM, said:

The only two things I wish the movies had were Saruman's death and the Mouth of Sauron sequence.
Both of those are in the extended editions. :wink:
Posted Image
Alexis Fenral
Level 47 Assassin, In Heroica RPG, On Quest #125
Flickr, Bricklink Store, Facebook

#17 Legomaster34

Legomaster34

    Posts: 274
    Joined: 02-January 09
    Member: 4880
    Country: USA

Posted 01 January 2013 - 09:47 PM

I've read the books (The Hobbit and The Silmarillion too :wink: ), and I've seen the trilogy in full (sort of, saw The Two Towers extended edition, but the other two normal), once, but I've seen bits a pieces when it's on TV and I can catch a few scenes. I read the books first, and I love them, and seeing the movies I love them pretty much just as much as I love the books! I don't mind the exclusion of certain scenes too much, since I can just read the books if I want to "see" them, but I was really looking forward to seeing Tom Bombadil and the Barrow-wights; that was one of my favorite scenes in the first book. I voted for the books, but they pull ahead only by a small margin. :wink:

Edited by Legomaster34, 16 January 2013 - 02:16 PM.

ULTIMATE BIONICLE FAN!

My MoCs: Hogwarts Castle
Posted Image



Reply to this topic



  


0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users