Jump to content


REVIEW: 10216 Winter Village Bakery


8 replies to this topic

Poll: REVIEW: 10216 Winter Village Bakery (26 member(s) have cast votes)

How do you rate this set?

  1. Poor (0 votes [0.00%])

    Percentage of vote: 0.00%

  2. Below Average (0 votes [0.00%])

    Percentage of vote: 0.00%

  3. Average (1 votes [3.85%])

    Percentage of vote: 3.85%

  4. Above Average (16 votes [61.54%])

    Percentage of vote: 61.54%

  5. Outstanding (9 votes [34.62%])

    Percentage of vote: 34.62%

Which Winter set has the best lamppost?

  1. Winter Toy Shop (12 votes [46.15%])

    Percentage of vote: 46.15%

  2. Winter Village Bakery (10 votes [38.46%])

    Percentage of vote: 38.46%

  3. Winter Village Post Office (4 votes [15.38%])

    Percentage of vote: 15.38%

Vote Guests cannot vote

#1 SilentMode

SilentMode

  • A bronzie that does not endorse whipping


    Posts: 1352
    Joined: 13-May 10
    Member: 10650
    Country: UK

Posted 20 October 2011 - 06:33 PM

Posted Image

Big shout out to tigerkiddo for their review of this set last year.

If you haven't already, check out my reviews for two other Winter sets, and see what you think.

Posted Image

Winter Village Bakery
Set 10216
Release year: 2010
# of pieces: 687
# of minifigs: 7
RRP: GBP 49.99 / USD 54.99

Links: Brickset

So far the Winter Village Post Office is my favourite set of the group, with the much anticipated Toy Shop suffering from a sharp price increase. How will the Bakery fare? Let's find out.


~ The box ~

Posted Image
The back of the box is similar to those of the other sets, displaying the cast of figures as well as the goings-on around the Bakery.

Posted Image
To my surprise, this set also comes with a light brick! I honestly didn't notice until I took pictures of the box.

Posted Image
And let's get the joke about French piles out of the way. (You'd think, this being a Bakery set, they'd include the cream this time.)

Posted Image
The parts in this set were brought to you by the above listed countries.

Posted Image
Sadly the Winter Village Bakery also suffered a sharp price increase as of this month. It was previously GBP 44.99 (if I remember correctly), and at one point it was even less expensive than the Toy Shop, at GBP 35.99, in a Lego store.

Posted Image
If I thought that was the worst of it, this sight really flipped my lid. 687 pieces?! That's almost 200 less than both the Toy Shop and the Post Office, which really concerned me given the new price.

Let's calm ourselves down...

Posted Image
On the long side of the box, as usual, is the list of parts in the set, along with two figures shown to represent the scale. From the outset the Bakery follows the trend of including one particularly attractive woman (sadly broken by the presence of Mrs "Two Cloaks" Prescott in the Toy Shop set).


~ The contents ~
With only 687 parts compared to the Toy Shop's 815, we'd better have a good selection. Let's take a look:

Posted Image

The box for the Bakery is about twice as big as its contents. Inside is the instruction manual, eight unnumbered bags and (surprisingly!) a small DSS (dreaded sticker sheet).

Posted Image
From the outset there are a lot of different colours involved in the building of this set; nothing particularly stands out as being prominent.

Posted Image
The light brick hides among the larger pieces in one of the bags.

Posted Image
This manual is the only one out of the three sets I've reviewed that doesn't come in its own bag, with a cardboard support. Very surprisingly it's remained relatively crisp...

Posted Image
...and so has the DSS, which was also unprotected.

Let's have a look at these parts...

Posted Image
We're going to be working with these large plates: three 6x10s, two 4x10s and two 2x12s in White, with a number of supporting plates. Bottom right shows a Reddish Brown 4x8 plate (still haven't perfected my lighting).

Posted Image
Things get interesting here: we have a number of Medium Dark Flesh bricks, including this 1x1 with a vertical hook, which almost look good enough to eat. I've also shown here the few included Green elements.

Posted Image
Just look at all this Dark Red goodness. LOOK AT IT! I don't think I've ever seen this many Dark Red elements in a set before.

Posted Image
If tiles are your thing, the Bakery set has these to offer. The 1x2s in Orange really stand out, but I'm particularly keen on the Light Bluish Grey 2x4s.

The stars of the show
Posted Image
Let's talk transparencies first. One of the biggest talking points about this set is the inclusion of two 8x8 plates in Trans Medium Blue, but we also have a 1x6x5 wall panel in Trans Clear, which tend to appear only in the most expensive of sets. We also have some very useful windows for the 1x4x6 door frames.
Two baguettes, a croissant, an apple and two Bright Light Orange ice cream parts are very welcome food parts included, as well as a camera and an ever-elusive 100 bill. A brown "Elsa" hairpiece comes in very handy, and for lovers of the snow we also have a Dark Blue parka hood.

Posted Image
A closer look at the heads shows that one of the female heads is the same new variant I had with the Toy Shop. The other head is less appealing but double-sided; the other side shows a "shrieking" expression.
We also have a jester head, where one side has a crud-eating grin, and the other sobs like a so-and-so.

Posted Image
Before you even think of building anything, sit and take a tongue-lashing about battery replacement, in no less than 21 different languages.


~ The minifigures ~

Posted Image
The Winter Village Bakery tries to make up for lost points by including two middle-aged women, and making both of the kids male.

Posted Image

Posted Image
"Watch and learn, kids - this is how you chirps women."

So now we get to the good stuff: building the models.


~ The models ~
The magic number four strikes again, as we have four separate models to build.

Model one: the tree stall
Posted Image
This stall could be many things, but in the Bakery set it's a stall where Christmas trees are sold. 100 of whatever currency you decide gets you a kid-size tree; 200 gets you a respectable man-sized tree - as is indicated by the sticker applied to the sign (which I didn't use).

Posted Image
Not a difficult build at all, and a design that could be converted to almost any use you can think of. Use it to sell cups of hot cocoa and cakes, or convert it into a dodgy stand for playing Find The Queen.

Model two: the horse and cart
Posted Image
The two double-sided slope parts (shown under "the stars of the show") go into making this very simple yet effective cart, using the locking hinges to create the sides.

Posted Image
A simple garland design (รก la Toy Shop) hangs from the back of the cart.

Posted Image
Just before the horse was added, along with a ridged black brick (to represent a harness or something), I was rather concerned about the presence of both a whip and a small axe on the cart.
Given the dog-whipping shenanigans present in the Winter Village Post Office, I guess the theory was that, if the whip wasn't effective in getting the horse to move, you'd take that axe and...

Posted Image
Ohhhhhhhhh, the axe is used for chopping down trees.
This model comes with the other handyman, responsible for picking up the trees that customers buy, along with the kid in the blue parka. The kid has a gift for the hungry horse.

Posted Image
"Here horsey horsey! Take the delicious apple!"

The kid was never seen again.

Model three: the frozen pond

Posted Image

This model was the one that really stood out when I saw it displayed in various shops; I'd always wondered how the ice was constructed, and whether a special plate was being used or not - it didn't look like any Lego colour I'd seen before.
For anyone wondering the same thing, I've broken it down for you here:

Posted Image

Posted Image

Posted Image
The bench is pretty much constructed in the same way as the one in the Post Office set.

Posted Image
No ice skating scene would be complete without a kid laughing his butt off at someone who fell into snow. The little bugger has even filmed the whole thing and uploaded it to YouTube.

Note the use of 1x1 plates with "teeth" to represent skates, and the 1x1 transparent plates underneath them to position the figures on the ice. These bits are rather fiddly and can make positioning the female figure (having moving legs) very tricky, but they do the job. Remember, this set was out before the Series 4 minifigures.

By the way: does anyone else think those lights are hanging dangerously low?


Model four: the Bakery

Ladies and gentlemen, the fight for the heavywinter championship of the world...

Posted Image

At this point there's going to be a huge chunk of instruction manual to get through, but as long as you have your parts arranged in some kind of order you'll be fine. (Oh yes, be sure to do that before you start work on any of these models.)

Step 10

Posted Image
Like with the other sets, we basically start off with the ground detail and wall foundations. The Bakery has a nice Tan and Medium Blue tiled floor, with the outside steps substituting Tan for Dark Bluish Grey.

Step 20

Posted Image
Things have really started to pick up. With creative usage of 1x1 round plates (including the flower plates), we've got a delicious assortment of cakes and pastries on display. The baguettes have gone into a basket next to the oven.

Posted Image
Behind the counter is a secret stash of pink cakes, which can be placed there or taken out at your discretion. They're not secured in place, so be careful when transporting this set or moving it around.
The oven comes equipped with a wooden paddle (which thankfully hasn't gone anywhere near the horse, that we know of).

Step 30

Posted Image
The combination of Medium Dark Flesh and Dark Red begins to work its magic, building up the walls to the Bakery. Now we know where they go, what will those hooks hold? We've also added one of the large trees.
Posted Image
You can see the big transparent wall element acting as a window pane, with the hole facing outward.

Step 40

Posted Image
Added to the building is the heavy wooden door, a lamp and the ceiling to the ground floor. The outside of the building, with the help of SNOT bricks, is also decorated with large garland designs.
Posted Image
Looking good, eh?

The roof
The rest of the instructions focuses on building the roof.

Posted Image

Posted Image
The light brick is attached to the section of roof above the cake display. It's attached using a similar mechanism to the Toy Shop, but unlike that model it's not in a fixed rotation, nor are you forced to activate the light while fitting it.

Posted Image
The first section of a snow-covered roof is added; this is created using a simple combination of white plates and hinges, leaving a large gap for something.

Posted Image
The second section is added, along with some protruding building sections with windows.
Posted Image

One side of the Bakery has a very small loft, home to a single brown box. Perfect for a hiding place!
Posted Image

And finally our trademark lamppost is added to the building. This lamppost also has a sign hanging from it, with the help of a six-way SNOT brick (one stud on each side).
Posted Image


~ The leftovers ~
After that rather pleasant build, we're left with this assortment of stud-sized pieces:

Posted Image

You know, I don't think I've seen a single Technic piece in this set. There isn't even one to aid in pushing the light brick's button!

The instruction manual also has these pages at the back, mostly advertising very large sets that may still be available.

Posted ImagePosted Image
inset: How astronauts should look.
Posted Image

~ Lighting! ~

Posted Image

The light brick basically illuminates the cake display in the shop window. You can adjust the angle of the brick to get the mood you want, although again it would be helpful if you could keep the light switched on.


~ Fun with the set ~
The bit some of you have been waiting for. What's going to happen this time? Will Sabe make another appearance? Will the Secret Service come to take away the light brick from the Bakery? What will the Jailbait have to say this time? Let's find out.

Posted Image

Posted Image

Posted Image

Posted Image

Posted Image
Val (the fleshie girl), in the absence of her partner, is being propositioned by some overconfident guy.

Posted Image

Posted Image

Posted Image

Posted ImagePosted Image
* HYSTERICAL SCREAMING *

Posted Image

Posted Image
"Okay, what have we got?"

Posted ImagePosted Image
"His name's Max, 13, spokesperson for the Lego Club. Was found buried up to his waist in a pile of snow, assuming whilst skating."
"He must have been there an awful long time for him to turn white like that."
"The coroner puts the time of death at around four weeks ago."

Posted ImagePosted Image
"You know, it shouldn't be possible for someone to turn completely white when submerged in snow; normally the subject would turn a very light blue. This subject would have had to have been exposed to bleach for this to happen.
"Look at the way his face is tensed up - there's no way he could have suffered hypothermia."

Posted ImagePosted Image
"So you're suggesting this is a homicide, staged to look like an accident?"
"Makes sense. How could anyone not see those red pants?"

Posted ImagePosted Image
"...I was just skating, and I saw those red pants just lying there, and then I figured... oh my gawd! (Is the camera on?)"
"Have you ever seen this boy skating on the pond before?"
"No, I've never seen him before in my life..."
"Are you absolutely sure?"

Posted ImagePosted Image
"Hold on, it's Garcia. What you got for me, baby girl?"
"Something that's hot and..."

Posted ImagePosted Image
"WHAT?!"
"Uh, nothing Hotch - we're just playin'! Anyway, what's happenin'?"

Posted ImagePosted Image
"I looked into the origin of those red pants, and I must have alerted the fashion police because both my computers just went down. I'm trying to get things back up, but someone obviously doesn't want me finding anything out."

Posted ImagePosted Image
"Keep us posted, some kid's about to steal some cakes."


~ The verdict ~
"Sentence first," The Red Queen once said, "verdict afterwards."

Design: 8/10
All of the models in this set are attractive and very well designed, but for me the snow-covered roof on the Bakery lets things down.

Build: 9/10
I found it much easier to build the models in this set than either the Post Office or the Toy Shop, even though there was still the issue of unnumbered bags, numerous small parts and colour interpretations. The lower part count probably contributed to this.

Parts: 7/10
The choice of Dark Red and Medium Dark Flesh parts makes this very attractive, but probably also pushes up the price. Otherwise there's a good selection of other parts, particularly food items, the transparent parts and round plates. The light brick is again a nice-to-have, but almost completely unnecessary.

Playability: 6/10
I'd argue this set is more playable than the Toy Shop as is, but it's a display set that lends itself to being extended - particularly the frozen pond. The horse and cart unfortunately loses out to the Post Office's van.

Price: 3/10
I penalised the Toy Shop because of its sharp price increase, but the Bakery deserves a bigger penalty as it's now the same price as the Post Office.

Based on these scores the winner... and still heavywinter champion of the world is the Winter Village Post Office, as the Bakery scores a respectable 7/10.

My thoughts on the Winter Village Bakery:

From the outset I'd always preferred the Toy Shop, and I couldn't figure out why the Bakery was (mostly) more expensive. I was even unenthusiastic about finally purchasing it to do a review, getting back and opening up the box to reveal the contents - right up until I began building the cart.

As things progressed, I realised this was actually a really enjoyable build - certainly compared to the other Winter sets. I'd seen this set on display so many times, and particularly when I got to the frozen pond I had a breakthrough moment, as I figured out how it was put together. (It was very mesmerising seeing this model under a shop's specially constructed lighting.)

In the context of Toy Shop vs. Bakery (which isn't an even fight to begin with): I feel the Toy Shop is a more attractive building, with the bonus of a large tree that's ripe for decorating. The Bakery has the more interesting additional models, minifigures and parts. Everything in me says that the Toy Shop is the superior set, mainly because of the building - but the Bakery has an edge in being more cohesive and enjoyable to build, which makes sense as it came out a year later. (I haven't forgotten the frustration I felt when the instructions for the Toy Shop "forced" me to switch the light brick on during construction.)

In the end, I now have the trio of Winter buildings, and I can no longer imagine having any of them without the others. In fact, I'm impatiently waiting for next year's instalment.

Thank you for listening to me babble.

Posted Image

Edited by Rick, 23 October 2011 - 08:59 PM.
Indexed

the infamous SilentMode
crowdfunding yet again for Project Swapfig - ends November 16 2013.
SilentMode.tv | Project Swapfig | @SilentMode1 | Brick Owl store | Flickr
"Almost everything you do will seem insignificant, but it is important that you do it." - Mahatma Gandhi

#2 LEGO Train 12 Volts

LEGO Train 12 Volts

    Posts: 3460
    Joined: 31-October 09
    Member: 8037
    Country: Italy

Posted 20 October 2011 - 08:10 PM

I love the hay wagon and the very big window of the shop.
Beutiful set!  :classic:
Posted Image   Posted Image

#3 fluffybunny

fluffybunny

    Posts: 67
    Joined: 20-July 10
    Member: 12108

Posted 20 October 2011 - 09:02 PM

great review, I have this set along with the other 2 winter village sets sitting in my closet waiting to be built, this set just shot up to the first one to build because of this review, love the story at the end!

#4 lightningtiger

lightningtiger

  • Doing the Chicken Dance


    Posts: 18578
    Joined: 28-October 09
    Member: 7997
    Country: Australia

Posted 20 October 2011 - 09:47 PM

Thanks 'SilentMode' for your take (review) on this set, I actually prefer this one to the toy shop one (I had more fun building the bakery). :wink:
Also a huge thanks to humour injected into too, made me chuckle a little. :laugh:
True, price/part ratio isn't the best....what is the light brick so dam expensive is it ? :wink:
Oh, well the post office I want next....now to find some importer in Oz with one ? :wink:
Keep on playing in the snow ! :laugh:

#5 Juppy

Juppy

    Posts: 40
    Joined: 05-January 11
    Member: 15187

Posted 21 October 2011 - 06:14 AM

I actually prefer the Toy Shop. The only part of this set that I liked was the frozen pond build. The building is just too meh imo.  At least the Toy Shop had a few more colors.

#6 TheLegoDr

TheLegoDr

  • Yellow Panel Expert


    Posts: 4010
    Joined: 18-July 11
    Member: 19128
    Country: USA

Posted 21 October 2011 - 06:17 PM

Very thorough and comical review. Nicely done. I have this and the Toy Shop but will have to wait until Christmas to open/build them, so I can't say I prefer one over the other. But I have always preferred the look of the Toy Shop more (love that tree), but I am liking this tree cart very much. I think the series looks great together. Lego keep 'em coming!
Posted Image   Posted Image  Posted Image   Posted Image   Posted Image  Posted Image

flickr
See my collection

#7 Sid Sidious

Sid Sidious

    Posts: 534
    Joined: 08-October 11
    Member: 20847
    Country: United States

Posted 21 October 2011 - 10:34 PM

Very nice review.  I got the toy shop for last Christmas, and my sister, who isn't a very big LEGO fan, got this set.  I wonder if my other sister will find a certain post office under the tree in a couple months...  Anyways, I personally like the toy shop better, but this is a very cool set.  The 8x8 trans-blue plates are very cool.  At the end of the holiday season, I think most of the extras from this set were "absorbed" into my collection.

#8 SilentMode

SilentMode

  • A bronzie that does not endorse whipping


    Posts: 1352
    Joined: 13-May 10
    Member: 10650
    Country: UK

Posted 24 October 2011 - 02:45 AM

Just wanted to add very quickly: the owl in my set appears to be the newer version (without moulded eyes). Allegedly it hasn't appeared in unprinted fprm in any other set. (Courtesy of Gregorovich over on Flickr.)
the infamous SilentMode
crowdfunding yet again for Project Swapfig - ends November 16 2013.
SilentMode.tv | Project Swapfig | @SilentMode1 | Brick Owl store | Flickr
"Almost everything you do will seem insignificant, but it is important that you do it." - Mahatma Gandhi

#9 rdmption2112

rdmption2112

    Posts: 1
    Joined: 25-June 12
    Member: 29377

Posted 25 June 2012 - 12:02 PM

i love your review of this set.. personally i think this is a nice and quirky set..
just wish Lego wud expand this to include other holidays..



Reply to this topic



  


0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users