Jump to content


REVIEW: 10199 Winter Toy Shop


  • Please log in to reply
11 replies to this topic

Poll: REVIEW: 10199 Winter Toy Shop (26 member(s) have cast votes)

How would you rate this [updated] set?

  1. Poor (0 votes [0.00%])

    Percentage of vote: 0.00%

  2. Below Average (0 votes [0.00%])

    Percentage of vote: 0.00%

  3. Average (1 votes [3.85%])

    Percentage of vote: 3.85%

  4. Above Average (11 votes [42.31%])

    Percentage of vote: 42.31%

  5. Outstanding (14 votes [53.85%])

    Percentage of vote: 53.85%

Vote Guests cannot vote

#1 SilentMode

SilentMode

  • A bronzie that does not endorse whipping


    Posts: 1352
    Joined: 13-May 10
    Member: 10650
    Country: UK

Posted 12 October 2011 - 10:25 PM

Posted Image

Special times ahead: not only is this my sixth EB review, but it's also my 1000th post on the site - and the gateway to a promotion (in forum rank only). I'm surprised I've lasted this long, but I appreciate it.

Cardinal Brick reviewed this set a while ago, and did a great job, but unfortunately many of the pictures in that review seem to be missing. Shout out to them.

EDIT: EB member Svelte has also reviewed this set, and the pictures are up in his review - clearly showing a difference in the minifigure heads used for two of the females. Thanks also goes to the late Gregorovich for pointing this out.

Posted Image

Winter Toy Shop
Set 10199
Release year: 2009
# of pieces: 815
# of minifigs: 7
RRP: GBP 44.99 / USD 59.99

Links: Brickset

Where do I begin with this set. Well, just under a year ago I'd wanted to get the Winter Toy Shop (over the Bakery) for myself, but the price was well out of my range. Having missed a golden opportunity to get it at half price at John Lewis, I was fortunate enough to see this set (along with the Bakery) in Lego stores a few months later, but at regular prices.

Every time I've been in a position to buy either, I've had the box in my hands, looked at the graphics on the box and felt how much the box weighed, and decided it wasn't worth it. (I don't know about you, but the box designs tend to turn me off buying a set.)
Adding to the difficulty of buying the sets were the fluctuation of prices as time went on. If I recall correctly, the Toy Shop was GBP 39.99 around this time last year, rose to 40.99 after Christmas, and has recently increased to the current price of 44.99. (Sometimes I get prices for the Toy Shop and the Bakery mixed up.) But in the end, having taken the plunge with the more expensive Winter Post Office, I decided to buy the Toy Shop first. After all, October is double VIP points month.

Before I continue, you might notice that the box shown above is different to the one displayed on BrickLink:

Posted Image

The main difference is that the name of the set is displayed on the front of the original box, just like the box art for the Grand Emporium. I was initially under the impression that the set I'd bought was a re-release, perhaps with a different assortment of parts. We'll eventually see.

Also, the official name is the Winter Toy Shop; for some reason I've been calling it the Winter Toy Workshop, or even the Winter Village Toy Workshop. Doesn't matter much.

~ The box ~

Posted Image
The back of the box shows the cast of the set at the top, as well as different scenarios with the models.

Posted Image
One of the long sides of the box confirms the set's official name.

Posted Image
The price sticker confirms the current price for this set, as well as the year(s) of release.

Posted Image
The multicultural roots of the set; China once again is involved, although I have no idea how or where.

Posted Image
Again, French light bricks come packaged with "piles". Do not douse them in water; wipe them gently with cream (sold separately).

Posted Image
Not one but two minifigures displayed next to the parts list, to demonstrate the scale we're working with.

Posted Image
And what a parts list it is. Just from this segment you can see there are quite a few pieces - almost as many as the Winter Village Post Office.


~ The contents ~

Open the box, tip the contents out, and feast your eyes on the nine bags of random bits and pieces. As with the Post Office, the bags are unnumbered and contain an assortment of similarly-sized parts.

Posted Image

Just one look at one of the bags, containing small pieces, indicates we might have a problem building this thing... Many of the pieces in this set are small.

Posted Image

And if that wasn't enough: one of the large bags gives birth to two more bags, full of more small parts!

Posted Image

Here's the light brick included in this set, still in the containing bag. The protective tab prevents it from lighting up until we're ready.

Posted Image

Posted Image
The largest plates we're going to be working with in this set are 6x10 white plates, and there's five of them. There's also a 6x6 dark tan plate.

Posted Image
Here we have most if not all of the green plates offered in the set, ranging from 2x6s to 1x1s and a couple of round 2x2s. Green is in this set what dark green was in the Post Office set.

Some of you might be wondering why I make a fuss about green elements. Well, around this time last year when I was building an MOC, I found it surprisingly difficult to get hold of certain Green elements (particularly 1x1 round plates), as well as having very few Green parts in my collection. It also appeared that Lime - an okay colour in itself - was replacing Green as the new standard green. So, whenever I see this much green in a set, it's good news.

Posted Image
Here we've got quite a selection of tiles in many different colours, but nothing out of the ordinary.

Posted Image
Many different coloured 1x1 round plates, as well as some "cheese" slopes and joysticks (levers), which I haven't seen in a long time. I've also included in this picture a couple of transparent and some dark red 1x1 plates.

~ The stars of the show ~
Posted Image
Quite a few interesting pieces can be found in this set, and here are some of my favourites.
First we have not one, not two but four trees in two different sizes, and all brand new. We also have an intriguing arch piece in white, obviously used for decorative purposes, and a brown ladder.
In terms of bricks: we have six transparent 1x2s (four in Trans Clear, two in Trans Green), which you'd be lucky to find in a PAB wall but would cost you quite a bit bought online. (GBP 0.22 a piece for Trans Clear 1x2 bricks on the online PAB.) The numerous and useful SNOT bricks (on the left) suggest there's quite a bit of SNOT work involved. As for slopes: we have this odd 1x3 double-sided slope in Light Bluish Grey, and two 2x4 slopes in Tan.

Posted Image
A quick look at some of the minifigure parts reveals the two exclusive heads (with rosy cheeks), as well as some other interesting choices for minifigure heads - including a blank white one and the classic smiley! Perhaps not such an impressive selection of torsos, but at least three of them are plain.
We also have four transparent hemispheres, which are used to build this set's lamppost. I can see these parts being really useful for future MOCs, but bear in mind that the only other set with these pieces is the Spongebob Squarepants Rocket Ride set.
Also note the presence of a Dark Bluish Grey frog (purely for decorative purposes) and a white cat with a face print.

Posted Image
Last but not least, the manual is safely packaged in its own bag with a cardboard backing. Unlike the Post Office, this set does not come with a DSS (dreaded sticker sheet).

Posted Image
The first page of the manual shows us how to activate the light brick, as well as replace the battery...

Posted Image
...before giving us a premature reprimand about battery replacement, in several different languages.


~ The minifigures ~
Posted Image
The magic seven, which includes two adult carollers, three kids and an old man. One of the kids has that scared face that many an MOCer just loves to insert into their creations.

But while the Winter Village Post Office comes with an attractive blonde, the Winter Toy Shop unfortunately contains a greedy brunette...

Posted Image
Posted Image
While the recently remarried Mrs. "Two Cloaks" Prescott gets two layers of cloakage, her divorcee husband Mr. Cholmondley-Warner gets a measly little scarf. I guess the pilot's jacket and top hat make up for it, however.


~ The models ~
Like the Post Office, The Winter Toy Workshop has four models to build, and here they are in the instruction manual order.

Model One: the snowman

Posted Image

The smallest and by far the easiest model to build, although something like this would be more suited for an advent calendar. Still, it's a good impression of an organically-built snowman - the dishes give the impression of a round body, while the red clip piece represents a scarf blowing in the breeze. This is also where the plain white minifigure head goes.

Model Two: the park bench

Posted Image

This display is occupied by the two carollers, the cheeky kid with a snowball, and the little white cat that sits on the bench. The bench is built pretty much in the same way as the one in the Post Office set, except four tap pieces are used for the legs instead of "log" bricks.

I should also show you how the lamps for the lamppost are put together, in case you're left wondering:

Posted ImagePosted Image

Be sure to tell your kids this Christmas: if they plan on attacking carollers with snowballs, or anything else for that matter, the ninja cat is going to come and get them.

Posted Image
Posted Image

Model Three: the Christmas tree
Not a festivity tree, not a pine tree and not even a green tree. This is a Christmas tree, because Snowdonia hasn't succumbed to political correctness.

Posted Image

The tree is built in several segments, as you could probably imagine from the box art. It's initially hard to see how a handful of plates could make a tree, but here it goes:

Posted Image

I was concerned about the choice of colours for the base of the tree: the combination of red and white gave the impression that it was going to do a Spin Dash.
Also, and rather strangely, the base is wobbly on its own. Much later in the tree-building stage some gold 1x1 round plates are added to the base to make it stand - but why they weren't added in the beginning is a mystery.

Before you're done with this particular model, you get to make a ladder and a single set of tree lights...

Posted Image

... as well as some gifts to go under the tree.

Posted Image
Posted Image

The construction of the jack-in-the-box is quite clever: using one of the four-way SNOT bricks with two bracket pieces creates a neat but somewhat brittle box. Also, the lid is purely for decoration; it doesn't close over the hole properly.

Posted Image

Model Four: the Toy Shop

Last but not least, this set's namesake. Persevere and you'll have one of these to add to your wintery display:

Posted Image

- step 10
Posted Image
Ten steps deep and we've got the base of the Toy Shop. We've added a small cash register at the back and the beginnings of a fireplace on the right, as well as Dark Tan floor panels. At this point I'm curious as to what purpose the black clipping piece at the front serves.
Of note: the flames are actually Trans Orange, as opposed to the Trans Neon Orange ones we're used to seeing.
Posted Image

- step 20
Posted Image
Even at step 20 of this model, we haven't even gotten halfway through the instruction manual - but we're beginning to see the shop take shape, and right now it looks more like a candy shop with the awning. We can see some neat little toys displayed in the shop windows, as well as a black front door and a white flag (representing a sign) dangling in the breeze.
The clip is now revealed to hold a little lamp, cleverly constructed using a black skeleton leg, a Trans Yellow round brick and a black 1x1 round plate.

Posted Image
A ladder hung precariously at the back of the model leads to the top floor.

Posted Image
And here we can see the beginnings of the side chimney. The use of many Dark Bluish Grey headlight pieces indicates a common SNOT technique used for creating brick textures.

Here's something I noticed on the way to this step:

Posted Image

Some of the 1x2 jumper plates had grooves at the bottom (like tiles), and some of them didn't. There currently isn't a listing on Bricklink for the grooved variation, which suggests this is a new part. Perhaps someone could confirm?

- step 30
Posted Image
Now we're getting to work on the top floor, and here we have the beginnings of a very tiny workshop, as well as the front part of the roof. From here on in most of our efforts are going to be focused on the roof itself.

Posted Image
Believe it or not, this construction is going to give the snow-covered roof its shape. I've gotta say, the Technic parts detract from the Christmassy feeling of this set - but that's how the designer chose to construct the roof.

Posted Image
Here's the part in place from the front...

Posted Image
...and from the back. You'll also see the decorative frog (which will unfortunately be concealed later on) and our famous analogue clock.

Posted Image
A rather cool feature on the right: the walls of the workshop are attached using clips and 1x1 bricks with handles. This is purely for aesthetic purposes, because you won't be able to open them up (as you'd expect) once the model is completed.

Posted Image
Before we add the roof parts, the workshop is kitted out with a workbench complete with model car. We can now see just how small this workshop is, but size isn't everything I guess.

Posted Image
Posted Image
Here's the first section of roof, along with some detailing - the addition of grey tiles - to the chimney.

Posted Image
The roof support for the smaller end of the building, which is not as Technic-like as the first, along with the second roof segment. You'll also notice some simple garland designs adorning the building.
All that's remaining at this stage is the roof pieces to go on top of this section, as well as a few trees to go outside.


~ Leftovers ~
At the end of all those builds you're rewarded with these spares - and there's quite a few:
Posted Image

Some old and some unavailable sets are being advertised in the back of the manual...

Posted Image
Posted Image
Posted Image
Posted Image

~ Lighting! ~
Posted Image
The light brick is positioned above the tiny workshop, to aid the toymaker (the old man) as he works throughout the night.
While it provides a very nice effect when switched on, I'd agree that there wasn't any real need for a light brick in this set. If anything - although I could see it being somewhat difficult - I would have thought the tree would make use of the lighting feature.

~ Fun with the set ~

Now that our Toy Shop is complete, we return to Snowdonia to check out the action.

Posted Image
A small crowd of groupies from out of town gather around the village Christmas tree, during a day-long celebration where they switch on the lights. As one of the townsfolk dutifully adds decorations in the background, some C-list celebrity steps in for Saima Gaines, who is MIA.

Posted Image
The local orphans, having gotten a pair of skis each, slide around looking for trouble.

Posted Image
"Creatures of darkness, rise!"
Even clockwork toys scared the living daylights out of these visiting schoolgirls.

Posted Image
Meanwhile, a couple of patients on a day visit are very well behaved, but impatiently wait for Bryknii's return.

Posted Image
"I've got some gay apparel you can borrow if you want..?"

Posted Image
A sorority of cheerleaders spend their respective boyfriends' money on toys from the Toy Shop, convinced they're in a real-life Bricks and the City episode. One even managed to get the exclusive "Guu" teddy bear before everybody else.

Posted Image
Toy maker: "You see son, zat is how you work ze ladies, ja?"

All of a sudden...

Posted Image
"Sir, we've been authorised to seize your lighting device until further notice."
"What is zees you are talking, I am fully paid up!"
"Step aside, sir."

Posted Image
"Zere must be some mistake, I am fully authorised!"
"We have reason to believe there is someone at this location using the device without a licence."
"Zat is rubbish, it is only me who uses... oh no..."

Posted Image
"WOO-HOO! I think I won that one!"
"Ach, mein Gott..."


~ The verdict ~
I've been looking forward to purchasing and building this set for the best part of a year, and I've finally been able to do so. Was it worth the wait, and more importantly the price?

For one, I'd have to be careful when comparing the Winter Toy Shop with the more recent Winter Village Post Office - unlike most people I bought them in reverse order, so my experience is slightly tainted. Both sets took around the same amount of time to build, and some of the same issues with the instruction manual (not being able to tell which colour some of the parts, particularly the black, grey and transparent colours) also came up. However, building either of these sets first would prepare someone for building the other. It's a bit like the educational minifigure sets, reviewed earlier this year: making a decision to buy either of them is initially very hard because of the price, but doing so softens you up for buying the next one.

As it stands, I quite like the Toy Shop as a set, and I can see it being part of a layout including the Post Office, despite their contrasting styles (i.e. the presence of Dark Green with the Post Office). The minifigures would also fit in a display including the Post Office set, although I'm curious why the instruction manual for the Post Office shows that set being combined with the Winter Village Bakery instead. The Toy Shop itself is a neat building from the exterior, and has a very nice interior on the ground floor. The tree is particularly welcome - whereas we get itty-bitty ones in advent calendars, this tree is a very healthy, minifigure-sized one.

I guess I have a few beefs with the set, the first involving some minor colour choices. I would have gone with either black or brown for the tree base, because right now it looks like it belongs in a Sonic game (as hard as it is to imagine). The garland/wreaths on the lamppost and building would probably look better in Dark Green instead of green (although the round plate isn't available in that colour).
The second would be the use of the light brick, which is the main feature of the set. As it stands it's more of a nice-to-have than a play feature - but unlike with the Post Office it's not attached very securely. I've had to put it back on the building quite a few times while operating it, which isn't easy because of the roof. As a small gripe, the order in which the light is constructed means you'll have to switch it on at least once before it's put in place, which kinda spoils the suspense.
The third is with the size of the workshop - especially since there's a light in that room you'll often want to have a minifigure in there, but to put one in will require taking the seat out. Fortunately it's not too hard to replace.

Design: 8/10
The set makes the most out of the parts available at the time (which I assume they were, as 2009 was within my dark age). The light attachment and the bareness of the tree let things down a little.

Build: 7/10
If you've built the Post Office you'll know what to expect with this set, but seeing how everything fits together is rewarding.

Parts: 8/10
Many useful and reusable parts available in this set, particularly if you like green. We even get four trees!

Playability: 5/10
More so than the Post Office, this is primarily a display set - apart from the kids on skis, and of course that workshop light.

Price: 4/10
Of all the problems I have with the set, the ever-changing price has to be the biggest one - especially since it's gone up.

Based on these scores I'd give this set a surprising 6/10, which means the Winter Village Post Office is currently my favourite Winter set so far.

Posted Image
"I should never have hired that dummkopf..."

Thank you for reading, and I will probably be back with a review of the Bakery. In the meantime here's to more Winter sets in the future!

Posted Image
What a missed opportunity for a caption contest.

Edited by Rick, 24 October 2011 - 06:53 PM.
Indexed

the infamous SilentMode
crowdfunding yet again for Project Swapfig - ends November 16 2013.
SilentMode.tv | Project Swapfig | @SilentMode1 | Brick Owl store | Flickr
"Almost everything you do will seem insignificant, but it is important that you do it." - Mahatma Gandhi

#2 Locutis

Locutis

    Posts: 246
    Joined: 11-November 10
    Member: 14165
    Country: Canada

Posted 13 October 2011 - 05:08 AM

Great review 'silentmode'.

Congratulations on your 1000th post!

Locutis
Your Lego will be assimilated with mine.  Resistance is futile!

#3 dodo

dodo

    Posts: 6
    Joined: 04-October 10
    Member: 13611

Posted 13 October 2011 - 06:13 AM

great review!
one of my favorite set. agree with you that this is more to a display set, hence not much playability.

#4 LegoSjaak

LegoSjaak

    Posts: 1178
    Joined: 17-May 10
    Member: 10715
    Country: Netherlands

Posted 13 October 2011 - 06:42 AM

Lovely review....now that i saw it, i have that christmas-felling already, and i feel the need of a winter-set as well.....!!  maybe i will order one in december...my son would love it as well..although he is only 2 years old!

Greetz, LegoSjaak
Check my latest videos (HD-quality, over 1,500,000 views) on YouTube or search for 'LegoSjaak' on Flickr for another 1000 pictures (or just click the link below)!!

http://www.flickr.co...otos/legosjaak/

http://www.youtube.c...oSjaak/featured

#5 Hewman

Hewman

  • I am Vigilance!


    Posts: 1424
    Joined: 03-April 07
    Member: 1497
    Country: ...

Posted 13 October 2011 - 07:19 AM

Thanks for the great review. I think the grooved variant of the 1 x 2 jumper plate is new and probably to allow easier removal, particularly with the new brick/tile/plate/pin separator due out soon.

I already own this set but your review makes me want to pull it out tonight rather than waiting for December when I planned to rebuild it.

#6 SilentMode

SilentMode

  • A bronzie that does not endorse whipping


    Posts: 1352
    Joined: 13-May 10
    Member: 10650
    Country: UK

Posted 13 October 2011 - 06:32 PM

Thank you folks  :classic:
the infamous SilentMode
crowdfunding yet again for Project Swapfig - ends November 16 2013.
SilentMode.tv | Project Swapfig | @SilentMode1 | Brick Owl store | Flickr
"Almost everything you do will seem insignificant, but it is important that you do it." - Mahatma Gandhi

#7 A&W

A&W

    Posts: 1
    Joined: 15-November 11
    Member: 21922

Posted 20 November 2011 - 05:52 PM

Thanks so much for the 3 reviews you made about the Winter village sets, I just commanded the 3, and your reviews convinced me that I'll love this sets.
Good job  :wink:

#8 Miss Kyle

Miss Kyle

    Posts: 851
    Joined: 10-February 11
    Member: 15926
    Country: UK

Posted 27 November 2011 - 04:20 PM

Thanks for this review, man! Now I am really tempted to get it... I have to choose something to get the free 2nd Xmas set tomorrow. And I'm sure this one will look nice on display during Christmas time.
"We've come a long way from the Prime Minister's exploding cake."

#9 Jaller8240

Jaller8240

    Posts: 59
    Joined: 11-February 10
    Member: 9525
    Country: USA

Posted 23 January 2012 - 12:39 AM

How did I forget this set?! I bought the Bakery and Post Office, and left out this one! Meh, maybe the LEGO store nearest to me will still have some in stock.

#10 just2good

just2good

  • Bothan Spy #8


    Posts: 7006
    Joined: 05-January 09
    Member: 4916
    Country: USA (Florida)

Posted 23 January 2012 - 01:11 AM

Nice review! This set has always looked gorgeous, and I put it on display every year. :classic:

#11 JackJonespaw

JackJonespaw

  • Doesn't like cherry talk


    Posts: 2724
    Joined: 12-June 11
    Member: 18405
    Country: U.S.A.

Posted 23 January 2012 - 03:24 AM

Very nice review! I wish I could have picked this one up...

My Flickr

I've done a lot of Mafia games over the years. Somehow, I haven't improved at all.

Playing as the Cook Jafar Masrani in SHIELD vs. HYDRA Mafia

Working on...another...Mafia...story...


#12 Deeks

Deeks

    Posts: 26
    Joined: 16-January 11
    Member: 15443
    Country: Canada

Posted 23 January 2012 - 05:49 PM

Such a great set my wife & I each got one for the other for Christmas




0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users