55 replies to this topic

[Mister Phes]

Pirates of the Caribbean Contest - Voting

Forum Division (MOC)





Voting has closed!
Points will be tallied and the winners will be announced next weekend.








Voting will take place in the LEGO Pirates Forum between now and 11:59PM/23:59 UTC±0, July 31^st 2011.

NOTE: The Creative Critic Continues so review each entry and leave your final thoughts

The Rules
Please ensure you've read and understood the rules before for voting, visit the Voting Information thread for more information.

The Entries

Fat Tony Where's the rest of the crew? Mill set

Yatkuu Encounter at the blacksmith workshop Mill set

Sebeus Iniwum Hello Beastie Mill set

Holko The Wicked Wench. Mill set

sok117 Isla De La Muerta Mill set

Horry The song has been sung Mill set

Captain Genaro Welcome to Port Royal Mister Smith Mill set

MstrOfPppts Isla De La Muerta Mill set

Matn Tia Dalma's Shack Mill set

Bjornu "Its just a matter of good business" Mill set

HazyHunter801 "No Three Bells Were Tolled" Mill Set

Toltomeja Giant Jack Sparrow Mill set

Cecilie The Fountain of youth Mill Set

Rolli "Captain Barbossa, welcome to Singapore" Mill Set

Burman The Singapore situation Mill Set

Skrytsson Da Grande Finale - Jack vs Kraken Mill Set

George G MAELSTROM! Mill Set

hammelgeier Attack of the Kraken Mill Set

Lego lover My vessel is magnificent, and fierce, and huge-ish, and...gone. Why is Mill Set

operrier Just Good Business Mill Set

The Lego Wizard port royal invasion (no prize stated and posted in wrong forum)


NOTE: The Creative Critic Continues so review each entry and leave your final thoughts

The Questions
If you have any questions, please ask them in the Voting Information thread.

[Yatkuu]

Hi, here are my votes:
Matn - Tia Dalma's Shack - 2 points
hammelgeier - Attack of the Kraken - 2 points (I just can't believe this is your first MOC, excellent work)
Cecilie - The Fountain of youth - 1 point (nice perspective)
Good luck to all!

[Horry]

Here are my votes:

Yatkuu - Encounter at the blacksmith workshop - 2 points (this one is a great reproduction of the scene with love to detail)

Cecilie - The Fountain of youth - 2 points (I love the correction of the TLG set with grea dimensions and atmosphere)

Matn - Tia Dalma's Shack - 1 point (I've never seen so many green in the pirates section - very good reproduction of a difficult scene)

Edited by Horry, 15 July 2011 - 10:05 PM.

[Cherno]

VERY hard to decide which entries NOT to give points to  

So here goes my vote:

hammelgeier - Attack of the Kraken - 1 Point (Incredible accuracy  & detail for it's scale)
George G - MAELSTROM - 1 Point (Dynamic scene realized with two tiny micro-scale ships and some blue plates!)
Matn  - Tia Dalma's Shack - 1 Point (Captures the movie scene's atmosphere perfectly. Great detail. Tia looks kinda angry, though   )
Captain Genaro - Welcome to Port Royal Mister Smith - 1 Point (Great movie scene captured in an instantly recognizable way)
Yatkuu - Encounter at the blacksmith workshop - 1 Point (Another very dynamic scene with the added bonus of a great floor technique)

I wish I had more points to give, there were many more MOCs that would have deserved them! Sorry!

Edited by Cherno, 15 July 2011 - 10:15 PM.

[KristofBD]

Some excellent entries!  One stands out in my humble opinion:

Matn Tia Dalma's Shack Mill set - 2 points

The following three other MOCS stood out as well:

Cecilie The Fountain of youth Mill Set
hammelgeier Attack of the Kraken Mill Set
Yatkuu Encounter at the blacksmith workshop Mill set

Each of them gets one of my remainder points.
Good luck!

[Mr_Malfoy]

Here's my vote:
Matn's Tia Dalma's Shack-5 points (the detail= )

[MCNwakeboard]

Here are my votes:
Yatkuu - Encounter at the blacksmith workshop - 1 point
Hammelgeier - Attack of the Kraken - 2 points (I love how the whole ship has the feeling of being split in two and the long tentacles add to for the effect)
Cecilie - The Fountain of youth - 1 point
Matn - Tia Dalma's Shack - 1 point

[simplefig]

Fat Tony Where's the rest of the crew? Mill set > 1 point
Encounter at the blacksmith workshop > 2 point
Tia Dalma's Shack > 2 point

[mobricki]

Matn - Tia Dalma's Shack - 5 points I got to hand it to Matn this is hands down the best moc in this contest. The details with the water and the scenery were amazing. It almost made you wonder if the water was even made of lego.

Edited by mobricki, 16 July 2011 - 04:52 PM.

[22kane]

Ok, here goes...

Matn's Tia Dalmas shack gets 4 points. Outstanding work
Lego Lover's My vessel is magnificent... Gets 1 point. Why not?

I would just like to say excellent work to all of the other entries but these are the two that stood out the most for me.

[comicon]

I love all the entries, but in the end, you have to cast a vote...

"Tia Dalma's Schack" by Matn - 2 points
"Isla de la Muerta" bu sok117 - 1 point
"Where's the rest of the crew?" by Fat Tony - 1 point
"Attack of the Kraken" by hammelgeier - 1 point

[On Stranger Tides]

well here goes...

hammelgeier Attack of the Kraken i give 2 points!

Yatkuu Encounter at the blacksmith workshop gets my remaining 3 points. in my opinion it is by far the best!!!

[Sebeus I]

My scores:

Fat Tony Where's the rest of the crew?  1 point
Yatkuu Encounter at the blacksmith workshop 1 point
Sebeus Iniwum Hello Beastie 2 (bonus) points (so I have atleast some points on my own entry :S)
MstrOfPppts Isla De La Muerta 1 point
Matn Tia Dalma's Shack 1 point
Cecilie The Fountain of youth 1 point

That's it, now I hope this is an eligable voting otherwise I might have misread the rules on that :S

Edited by Sebeus Iniwum, 17 July 2011 - 12:30 PM.

[Scorpiox]

So many stunning entries, so little points to give!  

Without further ado these are my votes:

1.hammelgeier: Attack of the Kraken -2 points + 1 bonus point
Your first MOC? This is like something people would spend months on!  

2.Matn: Tia Dalma's Shack - 2 points
The sheer detail is jaw-dropping!

3.Cecilie: The Fountain of youth - 1 point
The way it is made is lovely, feels like your looking through Jack's eyes!

Good luck to all

Edited by Scorpiox, 17 July 2011 - 03:13 PM.

[operrier]

It was hard to choose amongst all these great MOCs, but here are my votes:

"Just Good Business" by operrier - 1 point
"Encounter at the blacksmith workshop" by Yatkuu - 1 point
"Tia Dalma's Shack" by Matn - 1 point
"Fountain of Youth" by Cecilie - 1 point
"Attack of the Kraken" by hammelgeier - 1 point

[bricklayer]

All mine go to:

Hello Beastie by Sebeus Iniwum - 5 points

Too many details not to win!

Edited by bricklayer, 16 July 2011 - 07:56 PM.

[iElkie]

"Where's the rest of the crew?" by Fat Tony: 2 points
"Tia Dalma's Shack" by Matn: 2 points
"Encounter at the blacksmith workshop" by Yatkuu: 1 point

[Pellaeon]

Great entries! I'm sad I didn't have time to enter the contest... I still hope to do a POTC MOC or two later this year.  

Anyway, points:

hammelgeier - Attack of the Kraken - 4 pts
Wonderful entry! Love the scale, love the action... and both the ship and the kraken are full of great details. A few tweaks would make it even better: I think the water could use a little work (maybe transparent blues?) and the masts would look better if you used actual LEGO masts (they'd give you a mast that was thicker than a 1x1 without being a bulky 2x2). Minor complaints aside, this my favorite entry.

Fat Tony - Where's the rest of the crew? - 1 pt
Stunning photos, and an excellent, clever build. I especially love the first photo, with the forced perspective of the tank-tread rope bridge and cliff face. Great work, as always.

Edited by Pellaeon, 16 July 2011 - 11:31 PM.

[tchuk-norst]

"Tia Dalma's Shack" by Matn - 5 points

[Dix]

Yatkuu (Encounter at the blacksmith workshop Mill set) - 1 point
Sebeus Iniwum (Hello Beastie Mill set ) - 1 point
Matn (Tia Dalma's Shack Mill set) - 1 Point
Skrytsson (Da Grande Finale - Jack vs Kraken Mill Set) - 1 point
Hammelgeier (Attack of the Kraken Mill Set) - 1 point

[Commander Red Hat]

A lot of good entries for this contest!
But I have to divide five points, so here goes:

Hammelgeier, attack of the Kraken - 2 points
This is my favourite, as it is such a complete and lively scene, well done!

Yatkuu,encounter at the blacksmith's shop - 1 point
A very recognizable and detailed scene.

Fat Tony, where is the rest of the crew? - 1 point
Flawless picture of the scene.

Sebeus Iniwum, hello beastie! - 1 point
A very lively and detailed scene, too bad the Kraken isn't fully finished.


Good luck everybody!  

[hardcorowy]

Cecile - Fountain of Youth - 1 point
Matn - Tia Dalma's Shack - 1 point
MstrOfPppts - Isla de la Muerta - 1 point
sok117 - Isla de la Muerta - 1 point
Fat Tony - "Where's the rest of the crew?" - 1 point

[Ecclesiastes]

My vote:



Fat Tony Where's the rest of the crew? - 1 point
Sebeus Iniwum Hello Beastie  - 1 point
Matn Tia Dalma's Shack - 2 points
hammelgeier Attack of the Kraken - 1 point

Edited by mcdenbesten, 17 July 2011 - 01:39 PM.

[BrickBucket]

hammelgeier 2 points

Yatkuu 1 points

Cecilie 2 points

Edited by meatbucket, 17 July 2011 - 04:01 PM.

[Captain Genaro]

1)Fat Tony         Where's the rest of the crew? 1 point. I love the cages, cliff, bridge, and you did a great job with photoshop. Overall, a great MOC!

2)Sebeus Iniwum      Hello Beastie 1 point. The picture with Jack starring down the kraken sold this MOC for me. The Black Pearl with the crew preparing for battle is also really well done!

3)Matn                  Tia Dalma's Shack 2 points. Outstanding detail on everything especially the vegetation and interior of the shack. Tia Dalma looks great and this is why I gave you a second point!      

4)hammelgeier   Attack of the Kraken 1 point. What's not to like, you did a fantastic job with the Kraken and the ship breaking up. The brick sails also looks really good!


Overall, great entries everyone! I wish that I had more points to give to some of you!