PF Train Motor Testing
Posted 06 June 2010 - 06:49 PM
I have been testing a pair of new PF train motors to check that they are a drop-in replacement for 9V motors in terms of power, torque and speed regulation.
The RC motors performed poorly in the same test, compared to a pair of 9V motors, so it was important for the future of LEGO trains that the new PF train motors should be up to scratch.
I used the Electric Parts pictured above.
The LiPo battery (fully charged) and PF IR receiver were the same for all tests.
You can see a pair of 9V train motors, a pair of RC train motors and a pair of PF train motors, as well as the bogie trims I used.
The PF motors have the wire exiting at one end of the bogie plate part of the casing. If the wires on a pair of motors exit in opposite directions along the track then you will need to use a pole reverser switch to make both motors turn in the same track direction as I have done.
The PF motors were each in a Test Bogie top and bottom
The bogies are taller than the motor. the motor's pin is fixed into a Technic plate and the additional bogie plate attaches to the coach body. This is just because that's the real scale dimension for the coach bogie. We don't realise how tall bogies are when we're standing on the platform!
The Test Coach 1, 2, 3
Two trains were used for testing, a heavy passenger train 1 2 and a 20-straight-long goods train 1 2.
The passenger train has a lot of weight and drag, especially in the curves. The goods train has fairly heavy 4-wheel wagons and the oscillation of the couplings makes for variable drag. Both are a good test of motor tractive effort.
The PF train motors performed very well, passing the standard test comfortably.
In a further test, with a heavier train, they performed well, showing a limit of operation at least as good as 9V motors. This test was beyond expectations for the maximum load to be pulled by a pair of motors at a train show.
The good speed regulation means that both passenger and goods trains can be left to run up and down slopes while the operator talks to the public at a show.
This is a good result and bodes well for the future of LEGO trains
We can now proceed at full pace with building PF diesel and electric trains, and steamers that have motors in the tender. Get your PF train set orders in!
Full explanation of Test info
Folder when moderated
I might do a few more-specific tests, especially for electrical load sharing, but I anticipate no problems there. Perhaps Philo will do the proper tests to plot the motor graphs for his motor web page.
TLG, please speed up the availability of PF train motors as a separate set!
Posted 06 June 2010 - 08:32 PM
Posted 07 June 2010 - 12:32 AM
Posted 07 June 2010 - 05:20 PM
Check out my Team Fortress 2 Moc, my Green lantern moc or my brickshelf
Posted 08 June 2010 - 04:16 PM
I don't yet have any detailed information on whether a PF motor could outperform a 9V motor.
Now that I've found the PF train motors sufficient, I'll look more closely at their performance relative to 9V motors.
0 user(s) are reading this topic
0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users