95 replies to this topic

[KimT]

Historical Themes Review Index

How this works:
The pictures are "clickable". If a set/picture has the [NEED REVIEW], then a review has not been done. If there is nothing stated after the set name, then go ahead and click the picture for the review.
Pretty simple, hoah?

This is where all the reviews done on Eurobricks for the Castle themes are gathered.
Remember giving feedback to the reviewer and the set reviewed, is a nice thing, but remember to be "professional".
Old review threads may be "revived" but only if you've got something to say other than "sweeettttt!"
Any missed reviews? - post them here and we'll add them as fast as possible.

The Ninja Theme and the Viking Theme have their own indexes.

All Castle (Fantasy Era) Instructions

Legends
3739 Blacksmith's Shop

Black Falcons 1984-1987
6011 Black Knight’s Treasure[NEED REVIEW]
6030 Catapult[NEED REVIEW]
6035 Castle Guard[NEED REVIEW]
6062 Battering Ram
6073 Knight’s Castle[NEED REVIEW]
6074 Black Falcons’ Fortress

Black Knights: 1988-1993 (1998)
1491 Dual Defender[NEED REVIEW]
1547 Black Knight’s Boat[NEED REVIEW]
1624 King’s Archer[NEED REVIEW]
1888 Black Knight’s Guardshack[NEED REVIEW]
1917 King’s Catapult[NEED REVIEW]
1971 Black Knight’s Battering Ram[NEED REVIEW]
2890 Stone Bomber[NEED REVIEW]
6009 Black Knight Review 2
6018 Battle Dragon[NEED REVIEW]
6034 Black Monarch’s Ghost
6057 Sea Serpent
6059 Knight's Stronghold
6085 Black Monarch’s Castle
6086 Black Knight’s Castle

Classic Castle 1978-1983
0016 Castle Mini Figures I[NEED REVIEW]
0015 Castle Mini Figures II[NEED REVIEW]
375/6075 Yellow Castle
6002 Knights Figures[NEED REVIEW]
6077/677 Knight’s Procession[NEED REVIEW]
6083/383 Knight’s Tournament[NEED REVIEW]

Crusaders 1990-1992 (1998)
1463/2889/1695 Treasure Cart[NEED REVIEW]
1480 King’s Catapult[NEED REVIEW]
6042 Dungeon Hunters
6081 King’s Mountain Fortress

Dark Forest 1996
6024 Bandit Ambush[NEED REVIEW]
6046 Hemlock Stronghold
6079 Dark Forest Fortress

Dragon Knights 1993-1995 (1998)
1712/1732/1746 Crossbow Cart[NEED REVIEW]

1794 Dragon Master Chariot[NEED REVIEW]
1906 Majisto’s Tower[NEED REVIEW]
2891/1736 Wizard Trader/Wizard’s Cart[NEED REVIEW]
6020 Magic Shop
6043 Dragon Defender
6048 Majisto’s Magical Workshop
6056 Dragon Wagon[NEED REVIEW]
6076 Dark Dragon’s Den
6082 Fire Breathing Fortress


to be continued...

Edited by Rufus, 21 May 2011 - 05:58 PM.
6042 Added

[KimT]

Castle/Undead/Fantasy Era 2007-
5373 Knight & Catapult
5614 The Good Wizard Review 2
5615 The Knight Review 2 Review 3 Review 4
5618 Troll Warrior Review 2
7009 The Final Joust Review 2
7029 Skeleton Ship Attack
7036 Dwarves’ Mine Review 2
7037 Tower Raid Review 2
7038 Troll Assault Wagon Review 2
7040 Dwarves’ Mine Defender Review 2 Review 3
7041 Troll Battle Wheel
7048 Troll Warship Review 2
7078 King's Battle Chariot Review 2
7079 Drawbridge Defense Review 2 Review 3
7090 Crossbow Attack Review 2 Review 3
7091 Knights’ Catapult Defense Review 2
7092 Skeletons’ Prison Carriage
7093 Skeleton Tower
7094 King’s Castle Siege
7097 Trolls' Mountain Fortress
7979 Castle Advent Calendar 2008 Review 2
852001 Castle Chess
852293 Castle Giant Chess Set
852271 Battle Pack Knights Review 2
852272 Battle Pack Skeletons
852701 Battle Pack Troll Warriors
852702 Battle Pack Dwarfs
10193 Medieval Village Market Review 2

Forestmen 1987-1990
1680 Crusader’s Cart[NEED REVIEW]
1877 Crusader’s Cart[NEED REVIEW]
1974 Smuggler’s Hayride[NEED REVIEW]
6054 Forestmen’s Hideout
6066 Camouflaged Outpost Review 2
6071 Forestmen’s Crossing
6077 Forestmen’s River Fortress Review 2

Fright Knights 1997-1998
6004 Crossbow Cart
2538 Fright Knights Fire-Cart[NEED REVIEW]
2539/2848 Fright Knights Flying Machine[NEED REVIEW]
2540 Fright Knights Catapult Cart[NEED REVIEW]
2872 Witch and Fireplace Review 2
6007 Bat Lord[NEED REVIEW]
6027 Bat Lord’s Catapult[NEED REVIEW]
6028 Treasure Cart[NEED REVIEW]
6029 Treasure Guard[NEED REVIEW]
6031 Fright Force[NEED REVIEW]
6037 Witch's Windship[NEED REVIEW]
6047 Traitor Transport[NEED REVIEW]
6087 Witch’s Magic Shop[NEED REVIEW]
6097 Night Lord’s Castle
6099 Traitor Transport with Cave[NEED REVIEW]

to be continued...

[KimT]

Knights Kingdom I 2000
1286 King Leo’s CartNEED REVIEW
1287 CrossbowsNEED REVIEW
1288 Fire CartNEED REVIEW
1289 SlingerNEED REVIEW
4801/4811 Defense ArcherNEED REVIEW
4806 Axe CartNEED REVIEW
4807 Fire AttackNEED REVIEW
4816 Knight’s CatapultNEED REVIEW
4817 DungeonNEED REVIEW
4818 Dragon Rider
4819 Rebel ChariotNEED REVIEW
6026 King LeoNEED REVIEW
6032 Catapult Crusher
6091/10176 King Leo’s Castle NEED REVIEW
6096 Bull’s AttackNEED REVIEW
6094 Guarded TreasuryNEED REVIEW
6095 Royal JoustNEED REVIEW

Lion Knights 1984-1989
6010 Supply WagonNEED REVIEW
6012 Siege Cart
6016 Knights’ ArsenalNEED REVIEW
6017 King’s Oarsmen
6021 Jousting KnightsNEED REVIEW
6022 Horse CartNEED REVIEW
6023 Maiden’s CartNEED REVIEW
6039 Twin Arm Launcher
6040 Blacksmith Shop
6041 Armor ShopNEED REVIEW
6049 Viking Voyager
6055 Prisoner Convoy
6060/1584 Knight’s ChallengeNEED REVIEW
6061 Siege TowerNEED REVIEW
6067/10000 Guarded Inn
6080 King’s Castle

Royal Knights 1995-1996 (1998)
1752 Boat With ArmourNEED REVIEW
1804 Crossbow BoatNEED REVIEW
2892 Thunder Arrow BoatNEED REVIEW
6008 Royal KingNEED REVIEW
6036 Skeleton SurpriseNEED REVIEW
6044 King’s CarriageNEED REVIEW
6078 Royal DrawbridgeNEED REVIEW
6090 Royal Knight’s Castle

Minifigure packs mixing themes
6102 Castle Mini Figures 1985NEED REVIEW
6103 Castle Mini Figures 1988NEED REVIEW
6105 Medieval Knights 1994NEED REVIEW

Wolfpack 1992-1993
1596/1590 Ghostly HideoutNEED REVIEW
6038 Wolfpack Renegades
6075 Wolfpack Tower Review 2

to be continued...

Edited by Rufus, 21 May 2011 - 06:32 PM.
6032 added

[KimT]

Knights Kingdom II 2004-2006
5994 CatapultNEED REVIEW
5996 RascusNEED REVIEW
5998 VladekNEED REVIEW
5999 JaykoNEED REVIEW
8777 Vladek Encounter
8778 Border AmbushNEED REVIEW
8780 Citadel of OrlanNEED REVIEW
8779 The Grand TournamentNEED REVIEW
8799 Knights’ Castle WallNEED REVIEW
8800 Vladek’s Siege EngineNEED REVIEW
8801 Knights’ Attack BargeNEED REVIEW
8802 Dark Fortress LandingNEED REVIEW
8813 Battle at the PassNEED REVIEW
8822 Gargoyle Bridge
8873 Fireball Catapult
8874 Battle WagonNEED REVIEW
8875 King’s Siege TowerNEED REVIEW
8821 Rogue Knight Battleship
8823 Mistlands Tower
8876 Scorpion Prison CaveNEED REVIEW
8877 Vladek’s Dark FortressNEED REVIEW

King's Castle

Kingdoms 2010-present

  6918 Blacksmith Attack
7187 Escape from Dragon's Prison
7188 King's Carriage Ambush
7189 Mill Village Raid
7946 King's Castle
7947 Prison Tower Rescue
7948 Outpost Attack
7949 Prison Carriage Rescue Review 2 Review 3
7950 Knights' Showdown Review 2 Review 3
7952 Kingdoms 2010 Advent Calendar
7953 Jester Review 2
7955 Wizard Review 2
30061 Attack Wagon
30062 Target Practice
852922 Battle Pack Dragons

Edited by Rufus, 07 June 2011 - 02:32 PM.
6918 Added

[KimT]

Western/Indians
6746 Chief's Tepee
6769 Fort Legoredo

"Tadaaa!"
The Review Index is done.
This fine index will contain all reviews done on Eurobricks.com with the Castle Themes.
Exceptions:
- Vikings and Ninja have their own indexes
- Reviews done within the past week haven't been indexed yet.
- No more than 3 reviews of a set will be indexed.
- Single picture reviews or reviews with no pictures
- Off-site reviews
- Reviews with blurry pics and/or pics bigger than 800x600

Remember giving feedback to the reviewer and the set reviewed, is a nice thing, but remember to be "professional".
Old review threads may be "revived" but only if you've got something to say other than "sweeettttt!"
Any missed reviews? - post them here and we'll add them as fast as possible.

Enjoy and do contribute by reviewing sets which we need reviews for.
If in doubt on how to review - then join the Reviewers Academy.

Edited by Rufus, 21 May 2011 - 07:11 PM.
ISC adding Western theme

[CopMike]

Wow - well done Kim! Took you about 25 minutes to get that on the screen I guess?
Seriously though, do sets like 8770/8782 Danju, 4941 Rascus & 8794 Sir Santis really NEED reviews ? Isn´t just better to let them rest in peace?

CopMike

[Hinckley]

CopMike, on Sep 8 2008, 11:05 AM, said:

Wow - well done Kim! Took you about 25 minutes to get that on the screen I guess?
Seriously though, do sets like 8770/8782 Danju, 4941 Rascus & 8794 Sir Santis really NEED reviews ? Isn´t just better to let them rest in peace?

CopMike

Well, it's good to be thorough, which is why I'm starting my Galidor review index next. Galidor Revival On!

[KimT]

CopMike, on Sep 8 2008, 05:05 PM, said:

Wow - well done Kim! Took you about 25 minutes to get that on the screen I guess?
Seriously though, do sets like 8770/8782 Danju, 4941 Rascus & 8794 Sir Santis really NEED reviews ? Isn´t just better to let them rest in peace?

CopMike

Yup I've had that thought as well.
Maybe one day when you look at this, you'll discover that they're gone.
Aren't they Technic more than Castle anyways?

[Admiral Blockbeard]

I have quite a few KK1 sets and could do the reviews for them, however I can not find where my instructions have gone! I will join up with the RevA and see what I can do!

Regards Cpt PB.

[KimT]

Cpt. Pegleg Blockbeard, on Sep 9 2008, 11:42 AM, said:

I have quite a few KK1 sets and could do the reviews for them, however I can not find where my instructions have gone! I will join up with the RevA and see what I can do!

Regards Cpt PB.

You can probably find the instructions on peeron.com

[Hinckley]

I'm a little offended that my Dwarves' Mine review wasn't in there, but it's okay. I added it along with JopieK's...

[dj2005]

Hinckley, on Sep 15 2008, 02:32 PM, said:

I'm a little offended that my Dwarves' Mine review wasn't in there, but it's okay. I added it along with JopieK's...

That is because KimT has his own guidelines that he follows when adding reviews.

[Hinckley]

Oh yes, I see now. My review is off-site. Oh well. Now I understand how it works, thank you. What else can you tell me about how this site works?

[Matn]

I will try to review the Battle Wheel with pictures this week, so it can be added to this list.  

Here it is: http://www.eurobrick...showtopic=21444

Edited by Matn, 17 September 2008 - 03:30 PM.

[KimT]

Hinckley, on Sep 16 2008, 05:05 PM, said:

Oh yes, I see now. My review is off-site. Oh well. Now I understand how it works, thank you. What else can you tell me about how this site works?

Normally we put the "indexed" logo in a review, when we've indexed it.
Strangely I just had to do that to JopieK's review on the Dwarf Mine...it was indexed, but no index sign...
Very odd indeed.

dj2005, on Sep 15 2008, 11:41 PM, said:

That is because KimT has his own guidelines that he follows when adding reviews.

? My own rules? I like the sound of that. But I am fairly sure that my rules are everybody's rules...

Matn, on Sep 16 2008, 08:40 PM, said:

I will try to review the Battle Wheel with pictures this week, so it can be added to this list.  

Here it is: http://www.eurobrick...showtopic=21444

Thanks and indexed

[dj2005]

KimT, on Sep 19 2008, 12:20 PM, said:

? My own rules? I like the sound of that. But I am fairly sure that my rules are everybody's rules...

I was merely stating the fact why you never included Hinckley's well done review on the Dwarves' Mine set. From your previous Castle review thread:
"What reviews wont become part of the index
1. Single picture or no picture reviews wont be part of the index
2. Off site linked reviews wont be part of the index
3. Blurry pics or pics bigger than 800x600 reviews wont be part of the index"

I'm not sure if these guidelines pertain to every review index or not so that I was I labeled them yours.

[KimT]

dj2005, on Sep 19 2008, 09:10 PM, said:

I'm not sure if these guidelines pertain to every review index or not so that I was I labeled them yours.

I know, I was merely making a joke on behalf of Hinckley's not-included review.

[dj2005]

KimT, on Sep 19 2008, 02:56 PM, said:

I know, I was merely making a joke on behalf of Hinckley's not-included review.

Ah, now it makes sense. I'm not good with humor on message boards. Also, I have no clue why I stuck "I was" in that sentence that you quoted.

Now that is settled, would the initial post from the thread http://www.eurobrick...showtopic=21291 be considered a review for the 7979 Castle Advent Calendar 2008 set?

[KimT]

dj2005, on Sep 20 2008, 12:12 AM, said:

Now that is settled, would the initial post from the thread http://www.eurobrick...showtopic=21291 be considered a review for the 7979 Castle Advent Calendar 2008 set?

It does live up to MY rules
I'll add it to the Index.
Perhaps the Reviewers Academy is something for you?


7979 Castle Advent Calendar Review added to the index

[KimT]

As a special treat I've copied all the new Castle instructions into a folder on Brickshelf.
If you ever need one, look here.
I'll add the link to the first post as well.
Remember the folder needs to be public before it's viewable.

[Zarkan]

I did a couple reviews last year of Crossbow Attack and Knight's Catapult Defense. I know they have Indexed at the top, but I don't see them on the current index. Could you add them if they live up to your standards?

Crossbow Attack
Knight's Catapult Defense

Nevermind! I only just now realized that if you click the pictures, they lead you to other reviews. Sorry about that!  

Edited by Grevious, 06 October 2008 - 02:27 AM.

[KimT]

Grevious, on Oct 6 2008, 03:17 AM, said:

I did a couple reviews last year of Crossbow Attack and Knight's Catapult Defense. I know they have Indexed at the top, but I don't see them on the current index. Could you add them if they live up to your standards?

Crossbow Attack
Knight's Catapult Defense

Nevermind! I only just now realized that if you click the pictures, they lead you to other reviews. Sorry about that!  

Do not be sorry.
I will add a comment in the first post on the clickability of the pics

[Antoi]

May my reviews get a little place in your review index???

Review 6054
Review 6066

That is, if they apply to the standard:)  

[KimT]

Antoi, on Oct 14 2008, 08:15 PM, said:

May my reviews get a little place in your review index???

Review 6054
Review 6066

That is, if they apply to the standard:)  

I'll check'em out and thanks for the reviews in advance.

Oh and it's not my review index - it's ours!

[Antoi]

KimT, on Oct 17 2008, 10:37 AM, said:

Oh and it's not my review index - it's ours!

Thanks for building out index then :) and putting my reviews in them:)