Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0
JimBee

Review: 9472 Attack on Weathertop

   50 members have voted

  1. 1. How do you rate this set?

    • Poor
      0
    • Below Average
      1
    • Average
      8
    • Above Average
      26
    • Outstanding
      15
  2. 2. What is your favorite new piece of this set?

    • Longsword
      10
    • Shortsword
      0
    • Sting
      7
    • The Ring
      14
    • Masonry brick
      16
    • Other (please specify)
      3

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

17 posts in this topic

gallery_6705_157_68483.png

In the past several years, TLG has given its fans themes based on favorite film series, such as Indiana Jones, Pirates of the Caribbean, and the ongoing Star Wars theme. However, all of those, except for SW, have only lasted two years or less. Each one has only been made into a theme because of a recent sequel or spin-off (Kingdom of the Crystal Skull, On Stranger Tides, and now The Hobbit), and the theme's popularity has largely depended on the film's relevance. Will LEGO Lord of the Rings be any different? This is yet to be seen, but hopefully by looking at the current sets we can get some indication of that answer.

A largely anticipated theme, the first wave of LOTR Lego sets has given us some memorable scenes from the film trilogy. The Attack on Weathertop is one of those. But how does the set compare to the scene in The Fellowship of the Ring? And does the set show enough potential for the theme to live on? Read on to find out.

7839697800_2b4a4f3594_z.jpg

Set: 9472 Attack on Weathertop

Pieces: 430

Minifigures: 5

Price: 59.99 USD / 49.99 GBP / 59.99 EUR

Theme: Lord of the Rings

Year Released: 2012

Brickset

Bricklink Catalog

Box:

7806516852_94d8a3e997_z.jpg

Let's start with what you pick off the shelf: the box. I didn't get this set from the store myself, so I was fairly surprised at the size when I found it waiting for me at home. For a 430-piece set, the box's height and length are more similar to a set of 600 pieces or more. The design is fairly straightforward, with a plain, dark background with some trees you can hardly see anyway. Personally, I think that the angle and presentation of this set on the box gives a rather poor impression. Just the way the different parts were set up and the angle make the set look like a big blob of rocks.

The colors are a black-fade-to-gold, with the Lord of the Rings font title as well as Sauron's finger with "the one ring to rule them all". Not sure if the picture is of the finger post-severance, or...? And naturally, the front of the box depicts the set itself, the minifigs, and the set info.

7806516316_b8e91603c0_z.jpg

The back shows more of the set and some of its features. The box displaying the accessories (swords and ring) seems to be a trend among this wave of LOTR sets. There is also a small ad for what I assume to be the upcoming Lego LOTR video game. The observant customer would also notice that the background depicts a map of Middle Earth, which I find to be very cool. Once I tried reading Fellowship of the Ring, but could never get through itI did read The Hobbit, though... . Instead I always looked at the maps in the back of the book, and as far as I can remember (it was a long time ago), the maps used for the artwork in these sets is accurate.

7839785738_30664b5f49_z.jpg

7806515282_bc6c490f26_z.jpg

The top of the box shows the minifigures, again (more on those later), while the bottom gives you translations for "Lord of the Rings" in French and Spanish (at least this version of it, sold in the USA). "Senor de los Anillos" may not have as nice of a ring to it, but from now on I'm going to use SDLA for the acronym and see if people know what I'm talking about.

Contents:

7806514994_d904754318_z.jpg

Pouring out the contents, accompanied by that freshly-opened box smell, you get four numbered bags and an instruction booklet (below). I turns out the box's large size was completely unnecessary, as the contents only take up about half the space. And as you see here, the bags are also needlessly spacious. Seriously, a bag 2/3rds the size could accommodate the pieces of bag four. I feel as though this extra space was meant to make the set look larger than it really is, considering the 60 USD price tag. Like a bag of chips that's half air. So much for being eco-friendly, I guess.

7806514220_7d06e0963c_z.jpg

Also in the box comes a single instruction booklet. In the back are your usual ads and whatnot. It's folded, as usual, but the damage wasn't too bad for this set.

7806511560_4633507c73_z.jpg

Each numbered bag has it's own part of the build, and naturally you build everything in each bag, in order. There are part call-outs for each step, with sub-steps in yellow boxes. The background of each page depicts a faint outline of the map of Middle Earth; the casual viewer (i.e. one who is building) will most likely not notice it but it's a nice detail anyway.

Minifigures:

Strangely, the minifigures are built separately with the bags, instead of all being built before everything else. Maybe I'm just not remembering that larger sets do this, but I think this is a new thing. Your guess is a good as mine when it comes to the reason for it, but I suppose it has something to do with preventing theft, or maybe the designers just wanted to spread out the fun. I don't think it's a huge deal either way.

7812750756_b76f642bc2_z.jpg

Anyways, the set comes with five figures: Aragorn, Merery, Frodo and two Ringwraiths (I only showed one since they're the exact same). Aragorn comes with a pearl light grey longsword, which is probably my favorite new piece this year. We're been waiting a long time for a proper longsword, and the earlier versions pale in comparison. For one, it has a point at the end, which is much better than the rounded shortswords and broadswords from other Castle/Fantasy themes. Also, it is angled on the sides, allowing for a realistic look, while remaining simple enough to fit in with other Lego accessories. My only gripe is that the Lego logo and part information etched into the blade is pretty apparent, compared to other pieces where it is hardly noticeable. I'm not sure why this is, but up close it looks pretty ugly. Each Ringwraith comes with a peral dark grey version of the longsword.

Merry wields the nice new shortsword piece, while Frodo carries the ring and Sting. Although he doesn't acquire the orc-detecting sword until after the scene at Waethertop, I still would've rather the designers include it instead of another shortsword. The ring is chrome gold, and it is much more versatile than one might think. Because it can grip studs on both sides, more innovative connections with this piece are possible, including SNOT and reversing the direction of bricks when stacked.

Overall, a good crew of figs. I like how TLG has diversified their minifig selection for this theme by putting different figs in different sets. It's not always Frodo, Sam, and Gollum in every set. Instead we get Merry in this set, Pippin in Moria, and Gandalf in his own small set. This way allows the consumer to collect all of the Fellowship without just buying the largest set, while encouraging them to but different sets and collect as they please. Does this make sense?

7812749950_0b2c988a0e_z.jpg

Let's start details on each minifigure, starting with Aragorn, the real hero of LOTR. He wears a grey tunic underneath a dark brown coat, a print that carries from the torso to the legs. He also wears the fairy necklace that Eowyn gave him, though again that takes place after Weathertop. A deep jawline, a goatee, and some stubble make up the ranger's face, although I don't think the figure looks anything like Viggo Mortenson. The torso colors aren't accurate to the film, and this is just one face print that I don't think is right. The reverse "battle" side is slightly closer, but not by much. There is also some back printing, but it's so subtle that I wonder why the designers even bothered to put it there. It's not a bad thing, just not really worth it IMO.

Overall, one of the less impressive minifigures of the theme so far. I think a cape or some sort of longcoat could've gone a long way for adding to the "cool factor", but this is easily fixed.

7812750364_affaf5f802_z.jpg

Next up is Frodo Baggins, played by Elijah Wood in the film. Unlike Aragorn, I think this minifig is fairly accurate and similar to the actor. The new hair piece is fitting for all of the hobbits, as is the short cape piece (Frodo's is dark green). The reverse side of this fig is also much more interesting than Aragorn's, although I can't get a

out of my head when I look at his "possessed" face...

A solid figure all around. The only thing I think it would've benefited from is more wrinkles/detailing around the "normal" face to capture that very stressed mood that Wood portrays in the films.

7812749550_bbc53bed34_z.jpg

Onto Merry. Like I said before, I'm glad the designers included him instead of, for example, Sam. It's nice that they change things up like this. In this set he wears a fancy yellow vest with a dark green cloak. His cape is in the new olive green color, and both the torso and face have back prints. The hair is the same as Frodo's, but in medium orange (Sam's is nougat/sand orange, in case you were wondering).

IMO, Merry is best figure of this set. His normal face is, well... merry, and the battle face is instantly recognizable from multiple scenes in the trilogy, such as Weathertop, the orc camp, and when he fights the Witch King at Minas Tirith. Just a well-drawn design that captures Merry's real-life counterpart.

7812749068_31ac573729_z.jpg

Finally, we have the Ringwraiths. While there's a unique print for these guys, they're not all that different from the dementors from Harry Potter sets. I don't have them to compare, but from what I can tell, the cloaks are pretty similar, as well as the obvious black robes/hood. No fault on the designers, of course, I think these Ringwraiths are accurate (and cool to boot). Maybe it's just that fantasy writers have a fetish for evil, faceless, soul-sucking hooded undead entities.

There is one major gripe that I have about these minifigs, that that's about the fact that their hoods don't stay on when the cloak is attached. The cloaks are hooked onto the neck of the torso by three holes instead of two like other capes. This causes big, stiff creases near the shoulders, so the hood pops off really easily. Just touching the minifigure can cause this. The creases will probably loosen up over time, but it is still pretty frustrating.

Bag One:

The first bag deals with a very small portion of the set: the dementors Ringwraiths, their steeds, and a... rock.

Interesting pieces:

7806513268_323e1c3bf8_z.jpg

There's not a whole lot to see in the first, very small build. Two dark pearl grey longswords, an orange piece separator, and two wraith horses are present. The separator is a nice bonus that seems to be becoming the norm in recent sets, and is much superior to the older version in that it can lift tiles and punch through Technic axles.

7806513598_887f226ff6_z.jpg

A white cardboard box also comes in this bag, which contains the four capes belonging to the Ringwraiths, Frodo, and Merry.

7821372858_b64ee73d31_z.jpg

7806512014_f64503bc2c_n.jpg7806511792_6fa2800459_n.jpg

Since this is a new piece, I will look at the Ringwraith's horse in great detail. In comparison to the older Lego horse, this one is a lot curvier and more realistic, while retaining the original simplicity. The new one also has rounder ears, more pronounced detailing (such as the mane and the angled head), a longer tail, and pose-able hind legs. All in all, the new horse is far superior, and a well-needed upgrade.

Speaking strictly about this particular design of the new horse, there is some neat metallic printing on the head as well as the creepy red eyes. Very reminiscent of the film.

7806510276_5e5cbb4f68_z.jpg

One other thing I would like to mention about the horse is that the Ringwraiths can sit comfortably on them without having to bend the cloaks at all. :thumbup:

7806510924_e2f7983b8c_z.jpg

The rest of Bag 1 focuses on building this small rock. It's kind of random, but well-built. As I will mention later in the review, the designers have done an excellent job at substituting brick-build rocks for Big Ugly Rock Pieces (BURPs). Also, fans of the dark tan bush piece from Prince of Persia sets will be glad to note that another one has been included in this set.

7806510604_c45c8833d5_z.jpg

The complete build of the first bag with extra pieces (piece separator and hobbit capes not included). The black 1x2 bricks with 1x2 plates on top can be switched out with the saddles on the horses to fill the gap when the Ringwraiths aren't riding them.

Overall, a fairly unimpressive build for an entire bag. I started to feel like I wasn't getting my money's worth at this point, because I thought the main part of the set would be rather unimpressive with only three bags.

Bag Two:

The second bag deals with building the first half of Weathertop itself. Let's take a look at the interesting pieces first.

7806509986_3370310d7c_z.jpg

A light grey microfigure statue and some weapons. I have never had a microfigure before, so it is interesting to see one in person. I can imagine that it will be useful for acting as a statue (what it's supposed to be) in MOCs, though those creative builders out there will probably find other uses for it. The pearl dark grey shortsword and spear are decoration in the set, and the pearl light grey longsword belongs to Aragorn. One thing I would like to point out is that the bottom of the spear's shaft is flat, unlike the previous mold which had a rounded bottom. I'm not sure about the reason for this other than to make it more aesthetically pleasing, but it's not a huge deal.

Now, let's jump into the build.

7806509850_ac3fcb3b97_z.jpg

We start out by stacking some hinge plates. There's quite a few of them in this set, so MOCers take note.

7806509408_4d305fc97b_n.jpg7806509670_db070ec32d_n.jpg

We continue by building up a wall. Combinations of slops make for an excellent rock surface while giving the buyer the pieces to create their own (whereas the same thing could not be achieved with BURPs).

This next part is really gratifying. Using the hinge plates, you fold the walls inward...

7806509116_e38e0d8311_z.jpg

...and lock them in place by attaching 1x4 dark green tiles to the plates. This, to me, was really cool to see. I never had enough hinge pieces to make a round wall or surface myself, so seeing it in action has taught me a valuable skill in building. It is also at this point that the build comes together very quickly, and any reservations had about the set design have all but vanished.

7806508796_3707cb752d_n.jpg7806508454_89987a7153_n.jpg

After a weapons rack, a rat, torches, and some more slopes and hinges (for support) are added, we have a nice full, temple-like structure. The holes in the lower floor are also covered with some plates.

7806508130_e7b6de3904_z.jpg

After adding some plates to the top, the second build is completed.

This is the half not shown on the front of the box, so I really felt like I was getting a better deal for my money after building this far. An extra spear is included, as well.

Bag Three:

The third bag builds the other half of Weathertop.

7806507814_3f47661d6d_z.jpg

More interesting pieces. The hollow Technic column I personally have not seen since the original Bionicle sets. We also get some masonry bricks in dark tan, a dark tan 2x2 plate with a Technic pin on the bottom, black PoP arches, and pieces for a spiral staircase.

7806507618_9a0c6be6bd_z.jpg

Starting with the build, we can see some sort of sewer starting to form, as well as a candelabra. While building, I found that 2x2 jumper plate with a 1x1 tile attached to it to be rather strange, but it does have a purpose, as you'll soon find out.

7806507242_6f500f480e_n.jpg7806506854_4638ec593b_n.jpg

The build is continued by adding non-BURP rock builds, for the wall. The Technic tube is added, and the spiral staircase pieces are stacked. These are always so much fun to build, and we finally figure out the purpose of the strange tiling. It is to keep the stairs in place, so that they can't easily fold up again. The staircase is topped off with that 2x2 plate with pin so that more can be built on top of it. Nice!

7812759602_d3b788e902_z.jpg

Next, the build of Bag 3 is connected to the build of Bag 2 via hinge brick. This allows the set to fold open and closed for playability purposes.

7812759256_b0219a5f28_z.jpg

More wall and support is built up on the front and sides of this half of Weathertop.

7812758792_fd9d51af32_z.jpg

And finally the third bag is completed, with just a few small extra pieces. Almost done!

Bag Four:

The fourth and final bag deals with adding final details and finishing touches. These will be focused on more in the next section, but here are the interesting parts.

7812758316_d916c9dc4a_z.jpg

Sting, a leek, The One Ring to Rule Them All, and the new sack accessory. A good amount of useful pieces. :thumbup:

7812758140_3c593a85ed_z.jpg

Bag 4 completed! As you can see some arches and walls were added to the top to give that "ruined" vibe. Various other details were added too, which you'll see shortly. The extra pieces include two more rings and a second Sting. Very nice.

The Complete Set:

7812756084_2801d351ff_z.jpg

The full set in all its glory. It was definitely much bigger than I originally thought, and there's a lot of nice details that really make this set worth the price. Before we take a look, I would like to mention one thing.

While this set may be a tad low on the piece count for 60 USD (about 14 cents per piece), the parts are actually useful. This isn't to say that any Lego part is useless, but I find that this set offered a lot of basic pieces that will be useful for MOCing. This is in stark contrast to some large Star Wars vehicles, where a facade of semi-useful angled plates cover a skeleton of Technic beams. Don't get me wrong, some SW ships are really nice and I'm not saying that they should be built a different way, but there is definitely less part value. What's more is the fact that this set doesn't use any <insert that tiresome argument> parts, such as BURPs or those castle wall pieces. This gives the buyer a lot of basic, useful parts for creating MOCs.

Just my two cents on the matter. I really think that this set offers a good part value, despite the steep cost.

7812757592_89121e8e8c_z.jpg

And now we can fold the set in. It snaps together via Technic pin. The arch acting as a sewer drain really helps to attach and separate the two sides here.

7812757140_3869e7c2bf_n.jpg7812756672_fa2b6a8b91_n.jpg

Here's what Weathertop looks like from both sides while folded up. Not bad, I must say. It looks like a natural mountain with man-made touches to create the watchtower that it should be. In the back we have the camp that the hobbits set up, complete with a fire and some food. The front shows that awesome rounded wall will remnants of the tower that once was.

7812755544_9c5fb52028_n.jpg7812754794_520542a47f_n.jpg

The back has some flick-fire missiles. Wow, they even managed to include those in a LOTR set... :hmpf::tongue: I don't remember anything shooting in this scene, but I guess it's a nice and subtle feature that will entertain children who own this set. They can only be fired when the set is folded open, though.

7812752778_c25d016c63_z.jpg

Merry remains oblivious as Frodo gets shot in the back of the head... he should really look where he's going!

7812753674_021de2d05e_z.jpg

Setting the minifigures up like the scene in The Fellowship of the Ring was admittedly more fun than building it. :laugh:

And now it is the time where the review comes to a close. It's for the...

Final Ratings:

Build/Design: 10/10 - Really nothing to complain about here. Despite the poor first impression I got before opening the box, this set really has a nice design. The rounded walls are great and fun to build, and I enjoyed learning how to make better rock structures. The "ruined" look is present, and the folding mechanism works great.

Playability: 9/10 - I'll admit, recreating the scenes from the film with this set was fun. :blush: The dollhouse-style opening of the set allows even more playability options, as do the missiles and trap door. Might've been cool to have some sort of launching mechanism for the minifigures on top, but playability isn't weighted very heavy in my book anyway.

Minifigures: 8.5/10 - There are some really great prints, and some not-so-great ones (Aragorn). Overall not the best of the theme's minifigure selection, but still very neat ones. The main gripe I have is with the issue with the hoods staying on the Ringwraiths.

Parts: 5/5 - You couldn't ask for a better selection of parts in a set. All of them are very useful, and we get some neat new molds. Top scores from me.

Price: 4.5/5 - Like I said, this set has an excellent parts value, but it is still a little steep at 60 USD.

FINAL SCORE: 37/40 - A must-have set for LOTR and Castle fans alike. The pieces can be used for anything, from medieval castles to modern skyscrapers. Most of the minifigures are very desirable, and the set has a great design to boot. I would reccomend that anyone considering buying some LOTR sets purchase this before Helm's Deep, but after the Mines of Moria.

---

7812751368_7125b01071_z.jpg

Even the Ringwraiths are frightened of zombie Frodo.

---

Want to learn how to make professional reviews like this? Then join the Reviewers Academy!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for the review!

This is definitely one of the best Lego sets out there right now!

I didn't know there were flick fires in this one *huh*

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Wow this set is much more awesome than I thought, however the $75 price point here in Canada hampers it too much to warrant a purchase.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

One of the two LOTR sets I'd like to own (the other one being Uruk-Hai Army), it bearies an awfully high price tag (60 Euros!). (So does 9471 at 40 Euros).

Still, you made me want it even more. Let's home for some sales...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for your insightful review. :thumbup:

I like your written descriptions which explain a alot on the details of your shots and also give comparisons etc. Since release, this set is on my wish list. Despite it's small overall size at a high price, you have shown it's advantages in a good way. There's quite a bit of interesting building techniques or use of parts, respectively.

Too bad it's not commonly available over here and thus was not part of summer sales. I'll keep my eyes open. The set has a good selection and design of minifigures and the scene itself is a great standalone worth a place in LOTR fans' collections.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This is indeed a very nice set, and it's presented in an excellent review, JimButcher!

While I do not remember the hidden chamber from the book (I never saw the film; and I'm not an alien for that :tongue: ), I think it works very well with the overall design. Great work, TLG designers. :thumbup:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Great review and fantastic set. But the price is just a little too high... I appreciate licensed sets tend to be more expensive but I think I'll be waiting to see if the LOTR sets drop by about £5/10 each before jumping. (This goes for Uruk-Hai army set as well. Get army builder, but at £25 would be more desirable).

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

not a bad set, I liked the details, but honestly wanted it a bit bigger, currently it felt a little too small for my liking. Do like some of the blocks in the set though. and the weapons :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Great review and fantastic set. But the price is just a little too high... I appreciate licensed sets tend to be more expensive but I think I'll be waiting to see if the LOTR sets drop by about £5/10 each before jumping. (This goes for Uruk-Hai army set as well. Get army builder, but at £25 would be more desirable).

I was just able to get a damaged box one from my Lego store for $49 US, which seemed to me to be a more reasoable price for the piece count. (And what do I care, I have no room to store the boxes anyway).

Between this set and the "Big Hairy Spider" set I ended up with enough extra "One Rings" that I was able to fully stock the Grand Emporium's jewelry counter with horrifically cursed artifacts, and I still had one more extra for the Zombie Groom to present to his pale green Bride.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I really enjoyed reading this review JimButcher. :wink: I think this set has some nice details but just seems a bit overpriced compared to some of the other LOTR sets.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for this very detailed review JimB! This really makes me appreciate the set more to the point that I'm tempted to buy it, but... I'm not normally a price complainer, but the high price tag is something that's preventing me from getting this. I do think it's a very good set overall, the minifig line-up is pretty solid and it sure does look like a good 'parts pack', so if the right deal comes along I'll definitely grab this one.

Oh and for my favorite new piece of this set, I choose Merry's torso. For me the Hobbit torsos are some of the best new pieces the LOTR sets has to offer, having unique and nicely-detailed prints (especially Merry's in this set) which I can see being useful for custom minifigs for other themes. :thumbup:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for the great review!

While I've had a luke-warm response to most of the LOTR offerings to date (maybe I've just been waiting for so long (40+ years) my expectations are a little unrealistic) I think that this is my favorite of the official offerings to date. I've already got one and will probably be picking up several more for parts, figures and horses. It's not a "home run" in my book (and why on earth (or Middle Earth as the case may be) are there flick fire missiles in it??) but overall, it's a good little kit.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

It's not a "home run" in my book (and why on earth (or Middle Earth as the case may be) are there flick fire missiles in it??) but overall, it's a good little kit.

Ah, but my three year old son loves the flick fire missiles.

I agree it's not a home run but I still vote outstanding. It's like a mini-castle in design. I love the curved walls and the spiral staircase. It's not as "playable" as Helm's Deep though. Helm's Deep is my favorite of the current LotR sets.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I first saw this set and was pretty skeptical, but between my love of LotR and the want to get every set, I'll be asking for this one. (Not buying it mind you.) You covered everything and some things I hadn't thought of, nice work! :thumbup:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I liked this set instantly. However, the price feels a bit odd in comparison to other LOTR sets. There's a nice number of parts included, most of them are of great use for building, but the price per brick is higher. Nevertheless, the set is still nice, so I'm considering buying it with a discount (if I'll be lucky). Thanks for a nice review!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thank you Jimbee for this fine review. This LOTR is next on my shopping list and I hope I am able to get it soon, despite of its hefty price tag. The Ringwraiths are nasty indeed and could like to form a force of them with this, but this don't come affordable at all, so I am pretty much satisified of what this set can provide me with.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm a bit late, but excellent review, 'JimButcher'! :sweet:

I still regret my decision of not getting this set back when they had it at Barnes&Nobles for around $40... :cry_sad:

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!


Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.


Sign In Now
Sign in to follow this  
Followers 0

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.